A column study: Impact of redox, substrate composition and exposure order on toluene and benzene biodegradation and microbial communities

Abstract

Aromatic compounds persist as hazardous contaminants in both aquatic and terrestrial environments, needing rapid and effective remediation strategies. This study evaluated toluene and benzene biodegradation under sulfate and nitrate-reducing conditions in column experiments, utilizing aquifer sediments from a contaminated site. Over a period of 36 weeks, four glass columns were operated simultaneously in an alternating flow-batch regime. Each column received either nitrate or sulfate as an electron acceptor while being exposed to different substrate compositions in varied exposure orders. A redox dependent contaminant removal efficiency was observed, with toluene removal efficiency at 81% under sulfate and 55% under nitrate-reducing conditions, and benzene removal efficiency approximately at 44% and 59%, respectively, within 4–6 weeks. The rapid removal under anaerobic conditions was attributed to the alternating flow-batch regime, allowing biomass growth in batch mode, and applying selection pressure to non-specific biodegraders during flow regime. Toluene removal remained unaffected by benzene's presence but exhibited slight inhibition in the presence of an aromatic mixture composed of BTEX, indene, indane, and naphthalene. Benzene removal efficiency dropped to 8% in the presence of toluene but remained unaffected by the mixture. Pre-exposure to a single compound enhanced breakdown efficiency when further faced with a more complex mixture. Additionally, beta-diversity analysis conducted on the four columns revealed distinct microbial community clustering between sulfate and nitrate-reducing conditions, emphasizing the determining role of redox conditions. Findings of this study can be used to develop more effective pollution cleanup strategies, specifically targeting parameters like redox conditions, substrate interactions, and pollution history, thus improving our ability to mitigate contamination across diverse environments.