A 4‐Year Prospective Study to Assess Peri‐Implant Hard and Soft Tissues Adjacent to Titanium Versus Gold‐Alloy Abutments in Cemented Single Implant Crowns

Abstract

The purpose of this prospective clinical study was to compare titanium and gold-alloy abutments when used with cemented, implant-supported single-tooth crowns. For 4 years following prosthodontic rehabilitation, these abutments were evaluated with respect to peri-implant marginal bone levels and peri-implant soft tissue parameters. During the years 1998 to 2000, 20 patients were selected from a patient population receiving treatment in the Implantology Department at the University of Padova, Italy. They all presented with single-tooth bilateral edentulous sites in the premolar/molar region with adequate bone width, similar bone height on each side, and an occlusal scheme that allowed for the establishment of identical occlusal cusp/fossa contacts on each side. Each subject received two identical implants (one in each edentulous site). One was randomly selected to be restored with a titanium abutment and a cemented implant-supported single-tooth crown, and the other was restored with a gold-alloy abutment and a cemented implant-supported single tooth crown. Data on peri-implant marginal bone levels and soft tissue parameters were collected for 4 years after abutment and crown insertion placement and analyzed to determine whether there was a significant (p< .001) difference with respect to the type of abutments (titanium vs. gold alloy) used. All subjects completed the study. All 40 implants survived, resulting in a cumulative implant success rate of 100%. Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences between the two groups with respect to peri-implant marginal bone levels and soft tissue parameters. Within the limitations of this study, the results indicate that there was no evidence of different response with the peri-implant marginal bone and soft tissue when titanium or gold-alloy abutments were used in conjunction with the cemented, single-tooth implant restorations provided for this limited patient population. There was no evidence of different behavior of peri-implant marginal bone and of peri-implant soft tissue when titanium abutments or gold-alloy abutments were used for cemented single-tooth implant restorations in this limited patient population.