324. A RETROSPECTIVE SINGLE CENTRE PROPENSITY-MATCHED ANALYSIS OF TRANSTHORACIC VERSUS TRANSABDOMINAL PROCEDURES FOR GIANT HIATAL HERNIAS

Abstract

Abstract Background Transthoracic open procedure (TTO) was historically the preferred approach for treatment of giant hiatal hernias. However, the last decades transabdominal laparoscopic procedures (TAL) became the standard approach in many centres. The aim of the study was to compare short-term and midterm outcomes, as well as patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs, between TTO and TAL for giant hiatal hernias. Methods A retrospective analysis was conducted on all primary surgeries performed for giant hiatal hernias between 2008 and 2022. Patients who underwent TAL were propensity-matched (n= 36) to those who underwent TTO based on: age, gender, Charlson Comorbidity Score and hernia type. The two groups were compared in terms of surgery duration, length of stay (LOS), Clavien-Dindo score, intrahospital reoperation, hernia recurrence and need for reinterventions. PROMswere compared between total of TTO (n= 187) and TAL (n= 48): for symptom score, QoL-score, overall satisfaction and wound pain. Median clinical follow-up was 365.5 days. Median PROMsfollow-up was 55.3 months. Results Surgery duration (224 vs 177min, P<0.001) and LOS (11 vs 4days, P<0.001) were longer in TTO. Clavien-Dindo scores were alike (P= 0.260). Intrahospital reoperation was not statistically different (8.3% vs 0%, P= 0.239). Midterm recurrence rates suggested a non-significant trend towards lower recurrence in TTO (2.8% vs 16.7%, P= 0.107). Reintervention rates were alike (16.7% vs 11.1%, P= 0.735). QoL-score was inferior for TTO (0.705 vs 0.355, P= 0.036). Wound pain scores were higher in TTO (1 vs 0, P <0.001). Symptom score and satisfaction scores were alike, respectively 0.685 vs 0.760, P= 0.688 and 9 vs 9, P= 0.421. Conclusions TAL for giant hiatal hernias showed superior results compared to TTO for duration of surgery, length of hospital stay, QoL-score and wound pain scores. However, midterm results showed a noticeable trend towards higher recurrence rates for TAL. TAL should be considered when proceeding with surgery for giant hiatal hernias but a possible higher risk of recurrence must be taken into account. Further long-term clinical follow-up and comparison to PROMscould guide future decision-making.