3-D orientation and distribution of ammonites in a concretion from the Upper Cretaceous Pierre Shale of Montana

Abstract

One of the most common modes of preservation of ammonites in the Upper Cretaceous US Western Interior is in concretions. We examine an accumulation of ammonites from a single concretion in the lower Maastrichtian Pierre Shale of eastern Montana. The concretion is an oblate spheroid 50 cm in length and 26 cm in diameter, with its long axis parallel to the substrate. It contains approximately 90 ammonite specimens representing three species of Hoploscaphites including adults and juveniles. The concretion also contains other fauna, primarily bivalves and gastropods. A total of 33 ammonites, mostly adults, are concentrated in a cluster that spans 71 % of the length of the concretion (called the “sculpture”). 3-D measurements of the ammonites in the sculpture reveal that (1) the shells dip at all angles, with a significant trend toward more horizontal from west to east; (2) the shells dip with a highly significant bias toward the east, suggesting a current from that direction; and (3) a highly significant number of the shells that are non-vertical face with their left side up. Most of the shells show lethal damage as indicated by missing pieces of body chamber. After settling to the bottom, the shells may have piled up against each other, creating a sediment trap. Other organisms such as scavenging gastropods may have been attracted to the site to feed on the stranded ammonite carcasses. The chambers of the ammonite phragmocones and even some of the body chambers are empty, suggesting relatively rapid burial. Oxygen and carbon isotopic analyses of the ammonite shells reveal that they preserve their original isotopic signature. The values of δ13C of the carbonate cement in the concretionary matrix are much lighter than those in the ammonite shells and imply that cementation of the concretion occurred in association with the decomposition of organic matter.