3 CI Cognitive Therapy: Initial Application in a Pilot Study to Improve Cognitive Impairment in Chronic Stroke Survivors

Abstract

Objective:CI Cognitive Therapy (CICT) is a combination of behavioral techniques derived from CI Movement Therapy (CIMT) modified to apply to the cognitive domain, and Speed of (Cognitive) Processing Training (SOPT). SOPT is effective in improving cognitive function in the treatment setting and driving ability in everyday situations. The data concerning the effect of SOPT on other cognition-based instrumental activities of daily living (IADL) in everyday situations is incomplete. The strengths of CIMT, based on its Transfer Package (TP), are to facilitate 1) transfer of improved function from the treatment setting to IADL in everyday settings, and 2) long-term retention of the improved performance of IADL. This study sought to determine in a preliminary case series whether the TP of CI Movement Therapy combined with SOPT would have the same effect on a wide range of impaired cognition-based ADL.Participants and Methods:Participants were 6 adults with chronic stroke: mean chronicity = 36.2 months, (range, 16-56 months); mean age = 59.7 years, (range, 47-55); 1 female; 3 African American and 3 European American. Five had mild cognitive impairment, while one had moderate impairment. Participants received 35 hours of outpatient treatment in 10-15 sessions distributed over 2-6 weeks, depending on the participants’ availability. Sessions began with 1 hour of SOPT training followed by training of cognition-based ADL by the process of shaping, a common method in the behavior analysis field. Other behavior analysis methods employed in the TP of CI Movement Therapy were used, including: 1) behavior contracting, daily assignment of homework, participation of a family member in the training and monitoring process, daily administration of a structured interview assessing amount and quality of performance of 30 IADL, problem solving to overcome perceived (or real) barriers to performance of IADL. Participants were given daily homework assignments in follow-up and were contacted in periodic, pre-arranged phone calls to determine status, compliance and problem-solve.Results:All six participants showed marked improvement on the SOPT test similar to that in the Ball et al studies. However, here transfer to IADL outside the treatment setting was substantial. On the main real-world outcome, the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM), there were increases of 2.7±1.3 and 2.1±1.6 on the two scales (d’s = 1.9 & 1.3, respectively). (Changes on the COPM > 2 points are considered clinically meaningful and changes in d’ >.8 are considered large). On two other real-word measures, the Cognitive Task Activity Log (CTAL) and inventory of Improved and New Cognitive Activities (INCA), there was a marked increase during the acquisition phase of training. There was no loss in retention over the 6-16 months (mean = 12.2) of follow-up to date. Instead, the INCA showed strong further improvement after the end of treatment-setting training, especially in the New Activities Not Performed Since Before Stroke Onset category, going from a mean of 8.2 after training to 14.6 at the end of follow-up.Conclusions:These very preliminary results suggest that CICT may be an efficacious therapy for mild to moderate cognitive impairment in chronic stroke and possibly other disorders.