218 Results From the First Four Rounds of the Colorectal Cancer Screening Program With Guaiac Fecal Occult Blood Test Conducted in the Haut-Rhin (Alsace, France)

Abstract

Whether the results of randomized controlled trials on colorectal cancer (CRC) screening with guaiac fecal occult blood test (gFOBT) are transposable in the real world is questionable. gFOBT has several drawbacks, one is the requirement for frequent testing, which may limit compliance and thereby effectiveness. Aim: To assess the short term outcomes of the four first rounds of a population-based CRC screening program using gFOBT. Methods: Comparison of the outcomes of the four first rounds (R1 to R4) of the organized CRC screening program with Hemoccult II implemented in the Haut-Rhin, a French administrative area, since 2003 (Denis B et al Gut 2007;56:1579-84). All average-risk residents aged 50 74 were invited by mail to participate every other year. Results: Main outcomes are presented in the table. The crude uptake rate decreased from 47.9% to 38.5%. The decrease in adjusted uptake was similar in men and women but was observed in younger age groups (50 64) only and maximal in the 50 54 year age group. 15.8% of people who participated in Rn did not participate in Rn+1. Overall, 56.7% of the target population had completed at least one test and 19.6% four tests. More than 80% of the completed tests were provided by general practitioners. The positive predictive value for advanced neoplasia decreased significantly from 31.4% in R1 to 26.1% in R4 (and detection rate from 9.7‰ to 4.7‰). The rate of stage I colon cancers decreased significantly from 44.9% in R1 to 38.1% in R4. Conclusion: Participation and yield deteriorated with time in our organized population-based gFOBT CRC screening program. This deterioration was not observed in previous randomized controlled trials on gFOBT screening and may question the reproducibility of their effectiveness on the reduction of CRC mortality in the real world. Effort is needed to enhance uptake and to reduce inequalities in participation related to sex, age, place of residence and deprivation.