193 Apparent Total Tract Nutrient Digestibility of Frozen Raw, Freeze-Dried Raw, Fresh, and Extruded Dog Foods and Their Effects on Fecal Characteristics and Metabolites of Adult Dogs

Abstract

Abstract Various pet food diet formats are now available. Processing methods are known to impact nutrient digestibility and are thought to affect pet health but are poorly studied. Therefore, the objective of this study was to determine the apparent total tract macronutrient digestibility (ATTD) of frozen raw, freeze-dried raw, fresh, and extruded dog foods and assess their effects on fecal characteristics, and fecal metabolites of healthy adult dogs. Ten healthy adult spayed female dogs were used in a replicated 5x5 Latin square study to test the following diets: Chicken and Barley Recipe [extruded diet; Hill’s Science Diet (EXT)], Chicken and White Rice Recipe [fresh diet; Just Food for Dogs (FRSH)], Chicken Formula [raw frozen diet; Primal (FRZN)], Chicken and Sorghum Hybrid Freeze-dried Formula [hybrid freeze-dried raw diet; Primal (HFD)], and Chicken Dinner Patties [raw freeze-dried diet; Stella & Chewy (FD)]. The experiment was composed of five 35-day periods. Total feces excreted during a 5-day total collection phase was frozen until analyses and ATTD calculations. On the first day of fecal collections, one fresh fecal sample was collected for measurement of pH, dry matter (DM) content, and bile acid (BA) and fermentative metabolite concentrations. Data were analyzed statistically by Mixed Models using SAS 9.4, with P < 0.05 being significant. Widespread differences were noted among diets. Wet and DM fecal output was greater for EXT than other diets, and wet fecal output was greater for FRSH than FRZN, HFD, and FD. Protein ATTD was greater for FRZN and FD than other diets, and greater for HFD than FRSH and EXT. Fat ATTD was greater for HFD than FRZN and EXT, and less for EXT than other diets. Fecal pH was less in EXT and FRSH than other diets. Fecal scores were greater (looser) in EXT and FRSH than FRZN and FRZDR. Fecal DM% was greater in FD than other diets, and greater in FRZN and HFD than EXT and FRSH. In general, fecal short-chain fatty acids were highest in EXT, intermediate in FRSH and HFD, and least in FRZN and FD. Fecal branched-chain fatty acids were greatest in FDF, intermediate in EXT, FRZN, and FD, and least for FRSH. Fecal phenols and indoles were greatest in HYB and least in FRSH, with others being intermediate. Fecal primary BA were greater in FRSH than other diets, while fecal secondary BA were greater in FRZN than HFD, FRSH, and EXT, greater in FD than FRSH and EXT, and greater in HFD than FRSH. In summary, the diets tested were very different in regard to nutrient digestibility, fecal characteristics, and fecal metabolites. More research is necessary to distinguish how ingredient source, diet processing, macronutrient composition, and other factors may contribute to these differences.