0342 Are Clinical Trials for Insomnia Recruiting Real World Patients?

Abstract

Abstract Introduction Studies that have resulted in recent approval of hypnotics for chronic insomnia disorder (CID) have extremely restrictive inclusion criteria. We sought to determine how many patients seen in a sleep medicine clinic would be eligible to participate in these trials in order to assess the generalizability of these findings to clinical populations. Methods Six-hundred and twenty-eight patients were screened to identify 100 patients who were ≥18 years old, had a diagnosis of CID, and were prescribed a hypnotic medication at a sleep medicine clinic in a quaternary level healthcare center. Information regarding age, sex, body mass index, comorbid diagnoses, sleep schedule, medications, alcohol/tobacco/illicit drug use, caffeine intake, as well as Epworth Sleepiness Scale, Generalized Anxiety Disorder-7, Patient Health Questionnaire-9, and Insomnia Severity Index scores were abstracted. These data were compared against the inclusion and exclusion criteria for recent regulatory Phase III trials of orexin receptor antagonists (suvorexant, lemborexant, daridorexant). Results Of the 100 patients with CID (mean age=56.2 years; 57% female), only 3 patients met eligibility criteria for inclusion. A majority of patients (80%) would have been excluded due to a prior/concurrent trial of cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia. If this criterion was set aside, only 11 patients would have been eligible to participate. The remaining top reasons for potential exclusion from the regulatory trials were: presence of medical comorbidities (36%), daytime napping (33%), and sleep apnea (30%). Conclusion A very small number of patients with CID seen in a clinical setting met eligibility criteria for clinical trials of hypnotic medications resulting in regulatory approval. This substantially limits the generalizability of findings from these trials and restricts our ability to determine the efficacy of these drugs in clinical populations. Future trials should enroll patients with less restrictive criteria to help determine the effectiveness of these medications in real world settings. Support (if any)