Building Information Modelling Adoption Research Articles

Digitization of AEC Industries Based on BIM and 4.0 Technologies

BIM and 4.0 technologies are currently the leading branches of digitization in construction. The aim of this article is to confront theses on building information modeling (BIM) and coexisting technologies, and to present an analysis along with conclusions regarding the digitization process of AEC industries using BIM methodology and advanced digital technologies within the scope of 4.0 technologies. Key aspects of BIM and 4.0 technology integration were discussed, including artificial intelligence (AI) or big data and data science analytics. The impact of these fields on design processes, as well as on data management, monitoring of design and construction progress, and overall efficiency of AEC industries, was analyzed. The article pays particular attention to the synergy between BIM and 4.0 technology, identifying benefits, challenges, and development perspectives. Conclusions indicate the growing importance of interdisciplinarity for improving AEC industry processes and the need to adapt to the changing digital landscape in the field of design and construction. A survey was conducted, where respondents’ answers were presented in the form of charts. Questions focused on the issue of the use of BIM methodology along with coexisting technologies in the design process by the Polish engineering staff. The research results indicate that the use of the latest technological solutions in Poland is still rare, and the digital potential of these solutions is not fully utilized. The article can make a significant contribution to the discussion on technological evolution in AEC industries, identifying development directions in the context of digitization and the use of the latest achievements of 4.0 technology. Previous research has not included such a wide spectrum of BIM use in Poland. An analysis was conducted comparing Poland in a global context with other countries in BIM adoption.

Enhancing BIM implementation in Spanish public procurement: A framework approach

The European Union supports the use of technology to improve public procurement, acknowledging Building Information Modeling (BIM) as a catalyst for cost-effective public works and innovation. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate BIM implementation practices in Spanish public procurement. The methodology used in this study is a mixed research method involving a questionnaire survey and semi-structured expert interviews. The findings reveal market maturity as a barrier to BIM adoption in Spanish public procurement throughout the asset lifecycle. Selecting the right instrument for implementation proves challenging for public organizations. This study has contributed to the development of more practical and effective strategies to ensure full adoption of BIM within the public procurement sector of Spain. It proposes a framework approach for the pre-contractual phase, helping contracting authorities to make the optimal instrument selection. Two criteria are considered: the maturity of the public client and sector, and the economic value classification of tenders.

Perceived barriers to implementing building information modeling in Iranian Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs): a Delphi survey of construction experts

ABSTRACT Building information modeling (BIM) is a disruptive information technology tool in the construction sector. Although this technology had a significant impact on the manufacturing industries, it, like any other technology, encountered several challenges when applied to the construction sector. Conversely, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in developing economies often face significant impediments when using innovative technologies. Thus, this paper seeks to determine and investigate the perceived barriers to applying BIM in construction SMEs based in Iran. Three rounds of Delphi surveys were carried out with 15 BIM experts engaged in construction SMEs to identify the key barriers to BIM implementation in SMEs. An empirical survey questionnaire comprising these identified barriers was subsequently designed and disseminated to the invited experts. Altogether, 56 valid survey responses were received and analyzed. The study’s findings revealed SMEs management’s hesitancy to adopt BIM, stakeholders’ reluctance to change their established methods, and a lack of technical understanding as the critical impediments to BIM adoption in construction SMEs. Also, the study identified four barrier dimensions – technology, legal, management, and financial. These BIM implementation barrier dimensions can be employed to better allocate resources and financing for BIM deployment and construction innovation in SMEs. The study will assist major project stakeholders and SMEs make better-informed BIM adoption decisions, particularly in developing nations like Iran.

Building information modeling (BIM) adoption for enhanced legal and contractual management in construction projects

Building information modeling (BIM) adoption offers significant benefits for construction projects, including enhanced collaboration and legal/contractual management. However, the impacts of BIM deployment on construction contracts and dispute resolution remain unclear. This research analyzed the regulatory and legal implications of BIM adoption in construction industry via a framework evaluating Contractual Frameworks (CF), Dispute Resolution (DR), Legal Awareness (LA), and Risk Management (RM). Fifteen qualitative interviews with construction industry experts provided key insights. The results showed CF, DR, and LA have a large positive impact on BIM adoption, while RM has a smaller effect. Specifically, clearly defined BIM protocols in contracts, efficient dispute resolution mechanisms, and legal knowledge of BIM are essential to ensure effective deployment. These findings imply construction project managers should proactively address contractual and legal factors to manage risks, encourage collaboration, and adhere to regulations when implementing BIM. This research makes a significant contribution by addressing the lack of empirical insights on the contractual and legal aspects of BIM adoption. The qualitative methodology provides in-depth perspectives from experienced industry practitioners. The findings offer valuable insights for stakeholders worldwide seeking to leverage BIM. Further comparative research across regions and industries would continue to advance comprehension of the legal implications of BIM adoption.

The use of building information modelling (BIM) in the management of construction safety: The development towards automation hazard identification and assessment

The construction industry faces safety management challenges that impact its reputation and workforce well-being. Despite existing safety regulations, safety violations persist, necessitating innovative solutions. This thesis explores the potential of Building Information Modeling (BIM) as a tool to improve safety practices throughout the project lifecycle. A literature review identifies key safety factors and BIM features, revealing their interconnections and potential for synergistic improvements. A questionnaire survey and semi-structured interviews with 55 construction professionals from diverse regions revealed that over 45% of respondents reported positive outcomes from BIM implementation in their projects. A comprehensive framework is developed to integrate BIM-based safety improvement strategies into various project phases, providing practical guidelines and recommendations for construction professionals to enhance safety practices effectively and efficiently. The research emphasizes the significance of BIM adoption in the construction industry, promoting better safety outcomes and elevating safety management practices. The proposed framework offers valuable insights for stakeholders, encouraging the widespread adoption of BIM technology and its seamless integration with safety practices for improved project safety and overall construction efficiency.

Decoding BIM Adoption: A Meta-Analysis of 10 Years of Research—Exploring the Influence of Sample Size, Economic Level, and National Culture

In recent years, some studies have explored the determinants of Building Information Modeling (BIM) adoption. However, the findings of these studies are varied and sometimes contradicting. Consequently, this study undertakes an in-depth exploration of the relationship between influencing factors and behavioral intention. This analysis is achieved through a synthesis of findings from prior empirical studies, considering the nuanced impacts of specific contextual factors, including sample size, national culture, and economic level, on these relationships. In total, this meta-analysis encompasses 57 articles, and as of 31 December 2023, incorporates 63 datasets comprising a collective sample size of 13,301. An extended Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) model was developed based on the most frequently studied constructs relevant to BIM adoption. The analysis reveals that BIM adoption is primarily affected by performance expectancy, social influence, facilitating conditions, effort expectancy, and perceived value. The moderator analysis indicates that sample size statistically significantly moderates the relationships between facilitating conditions and use behavior. Moreover, the extent of individualism in each national culture significantly moderates the associations between facilitating conditions and user behavior. The research serves to enrich the existing body of literature on BIM acceptance by addressing contradictory and mixed results found in empirical studies. It represents one of the first attempts to explore the influence of sample size, economic level, and Hofstede’s six cultural dimensions as moderators in the field of BIM utilizing meta-analytic techniques.

Barriers to BIM Implementation in the HVAC Industry: An Exploratory Study

In recent times, the rise of urbanization, industrialization, population growth, food security, and the COVID-19 pandemic have led to an increased demand for indoor spaces with efficient air conditioning systems. As a result, there is a growing interest in creating more complex HVAC systems to improve indoor spaces. Building information modeling (BIM) offers numerous benefits to the HVAC industry, such as clash detection, budget and time reductions, and increased efficiency. However, its implementation is currently hindered by various challenges. This research aims to identify the major barriers to BIM implementation in the HVAC industry in Turkey, using a questionnaire survey of 224 domain experts working in 42 different companies across various fields of the HVAC industry. The study utilized several statistical analyses to categorize and prioritize the most critical barriers, including reliability tests, exploratory factor analysis (EFA), confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), the Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin (KMO) test, Bartlett’s test, and ranking of factors (IRI). The results indicate that the “Deficiencies of Infrastructure and Lack of Qualified Personnel (DIP)” factor group constituted the most significant barrier, followed by “Lack of Documentation and Specifications (LDS)”, “Deficiencies of Case Studies and Project Drawings (DCP)”, and “Lack of Motivation and Resistance to BIM (LMR)”. Moreover, our research revealed that 60% of the participants’ companies allocate less than 40% of their budgets to technological infrastructure, which hinders the adoption of BIM. To promote BIM in the HVAC sector, we recommend enhancing personnel capacity building, improving skills and knowledge about BIM, promoting guidelines, and providing free access to documentation for practitioners.

Innovation communities as catalysts for BIM adoption: a cross-case analysis of BIM communities in Norway and Vietnam

Purpose This paper aims to explore how open innovation communities contribute to the adoption of building information modelling (BIM) in the construction industry. Design/methodology/approach The paper presents a cross-case analysis of two construction communities, buildingSMART Norway and the BIM Vietnam Community. Data were collected based on 21 semi-structured interviews conducted with industry experts actively engaged in these two communities. The theoretical basis for the study was open innovation and the institutional intervention model, which delineates institutional actions related to the adoption of new information technology. Findings The findings show both similarities and differences in the way in which the communities contribute to industrial practice. Both communities use similar knowledge channels and repositories but apply different approaches to innovation creation and diffusion. In addition, trust can support BIM innovation in the community context. Originality/value The comparison of buildingSMART Norway and the BIM Vietnam Community in accelerating BIM innovation allows for exploring how open innovation communities support BIM adoption in the construction industry. The findings provide insights for construction communities into creating and diffusing BIM innovation. In addition, the examples of gaining benefits from community innovation activities are useful for construction firms and practitioners.

Analyzing the Variances in Perspectives on BIM Implementation among Korea AEC Participants

The goals and benefits of implementing building information modeling (BIM) in different facilities are comparable, although there are variations in the employed technologies. Nevertheless, when considering the practical aspects of BIM, the specific variations in implementing BIM across different facilities lack clarity. This study investigated the variations in viewpoints among participants in the architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industry regarding the adoption of BIM. The objective was to assess the necessity of developing diverse BIM application strategies based on the specific needs of AEC facilities. The following outlines the investigative process: (1) The survey questions were structured as items that necessitate prior investigation and consultation of BIM execution plans from prominent countries. (2) Appropriate statistical tests were chosen to analyze the correlation between respondents’ information and the questions. (3) The findings of the analysis conducted on the group of respondents were deliberated. The survey revealed that strategic variations are essential for the implementation of space for meetings in a technical setting, the formulation of data standards and BIM team for a cooperative environment, and the assessment of subjects based on the type of facility. Specifically, client-specified common data environments exhibited variations in the responsibilities of participants, while the assignment of BIM coordinators also displayed differences in participant roles, depending on the type of facilities involved. Nevertheless, all participants were in complete agreement regarding the collaborative environment, technical environment, organizational structure, implementation guide, and the necessity for evaluation. Surveys of the perceptions of these AEC participants help identify factors that may hinder collaboration in advance and assist in adjusting communication and collaboration strategies. The BIM implementation strategy, which considers variations depending on the type of facility and the role of participants, facilitates seamless collaboration throughout the project and helps establish forward-thinking guidelines for BIM operations from the standpoint of the client and governance.

A Holistic Evaluation of BIM Implementation Barriers in the Indian Construction Industry: Pre- and Post-Adoption Perspectives

ABSTRACT The existing Building Information Modelling (BIM) research does not provide a holistic understanding of pre- and post-adoption barriers to its implementation, especially in developing countries such as India, where BIM adoption lags. First, a total of 32 barriers to BIM implementation were identified after a comprehensive literature review. Second, after discussion with experts, the barriers were classified into 23 pre- and 21 post-adoption barriers. Next, the barriers were ranked based on 218 completed survey responses from professionals working in 125 organizations in the Indian construction industry. Finally, an independent samples t-test was conducted to understand differences in the perceptions of different groups of participants. The top five pre-adoption barriers were (1) high hardware costs, (2) high software costs, (3) low adoption across the supply chain, (4) low market support, and (5) unclear benefit evaluation. In comparison, the top five post-adoption barriers were (1) high ongoing cost (license renewal, training cost, etc.), (2) shortage of skills and expertise, (3) unclear benefit evaluation, (4) client’s lack of understanding, and (5) user resistance. Moreover, clients, contractors and consultants shared different views on very few barriers, which shows that these barriers are prevalent across different types of organizations in the Indian construction industry.

Building Information Modeling Uses and Complementary Technologies in Road Projects: A Systematic Review

Building Information Modeling (BIM) has been widely adopted in the building sector. However, it is still an emerging topic in road infrastructure projects despite its enormous potential to solve ongoing issues. While there have been several recent studies on BIM implementation in road projects, there is a lack of research analyzing the actual BIM Uses in road projects as reported in academic and technical documents. Considering this gap, this paper presents a systematic review of BIM Uses and complementary technologies to BIM in road infrastructure projects. The research method consisted of a systematic review composed of five stages: (1) question formulation, (2) searching of relevant documents, (3) document selection, (4) evidence collection, analysis, and synthesis, and (5) results report. A total of 384 documents were collected, from which 134 documents reporting BIM Uses on roads were analyzed. This study has two main contributions. First, 39 BIM Uses were identified, which are classified into nine categories: road design, traffic analysis, soil aspects, road safety, environmental issues, other engineering analysis, construction planning and analysis, cost analysis, and construction monitoring and control. Second, a set of 26 technologies complementary to BIM adoption in roads were identified, among the most prevalent of which are geographic information systems (GISs) and laser scanning. The results serve as a basis for researchers to learn about the status and propose future developments on BIM adoption in road infrastructure.

Apply advanced management techniques in demolition, renovation and construction projects to improve building material recycling efficiency and reduce carbon emissions

This research delves into the complicated issues associated with demolition, renovation, and construction of buildings to find viable, sustainable practices that will relieve some strain on nature. Identifying major components like governmental policies, cooperative work of stakeholders, assimilation of technology, and the possible transformative capacity brought by Building Information Modeling (BIM), this research attempts to unveil how a more ecologically mindful construction industry can be achieved. The methodology used in this research has a multi-dimensional approach that is aimed at thoroughly understanding and clearing the challenges within the construction industry. The strengths like government support, stakeholder involvement, technological innovations, and adoption of BIM assist in building a strong base for sustainability. The research identified opportunities for technological advancements, special solutions, and government incentives. Technological advancement is a constantly changing environment, which gives the building sector an opportunity to adapt and enhance its recycling strategies. Customized solutions highlight the fact that such "place-based" strategies are needed because different urban, suburban, and rural landscapes present distinct challenges. Most property owners would be convinced to swap their regular buildings with sustainable building techniques through incentives from the government, such as tax benefits and subsidies. Furthermore, regulatory compliance issues and resistance to change cement the fact that societies need not only solid guidelines but also constant efforts to redefine standards in every industry. Effective negotiation between stakeholders becomes essential. Therefore, it can be stated that the findings give weight as catalysts of change in terms of action within the construction industry.

Barriers to Building Information Modelling Adoption in Small and Medium Enterprises: Nigerian Construction Industry Perspectives

The widespread adoption of building information modelling in the construction industry faces significant obstacles, particularly among small and medium-sized construction enterprises. This research accessed barriers to building information modelling adoption among small and medium enterprises in the Nigerian construction industry. The study obtained quantitative data from 182 participants out of the 200 questionnaires that were distributed. A combination of descriptive and exploratory factor analysis was performed using IBM SPSS version 26, and the Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin (KMO) test and Bartlett’s sphericity test were conducted to check data adequacy and reliability. The study findings clustered five factors from the 25 identified barriers to BIM adoption in SMEs in the Nigerian construction industry. They are functionality and compatibility, risk and the unavailability of BIM resources, inadequate awareness of BIM, inadequate clients’ demands and support, and stakeholders’ skills gaps. The study recommends training opportunities for construction professionals, government facilitation through incentives, and safeguarding intellectual property linked to BIM-oriented projects. Collaboration among construction stakeholders would also increase client awareness and knowledge sharing on modern technology, such as BIM adoption in SMEs in the construction industry.

Construction management students’ perception of BIM adoption and its implications in a non-mandated country

Building information modeling (BIM) is increasingly being recognized and gradually adopted by the construction industry in India, even though it is still not mandated by the Government. As the demand for trained BIM professionals grows, many educational institutes in India have started including BIM in their respective architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) related curriculum courses, mostly at a beginner level. This study tries to access the perceptions of these AEC students towards various aspects related to the BIM practice and its adoption in India. It aims to provide a reference point, and help bridge the gap between the industrial BIM proficiency requirements, and the institutional BIM teaching-learning approach. As students are the prospective BIM professionals, this study gives important insights for the BIM practice stakeholders to understand the learners’ individual motivation, bias and experience. The methodology consisted of conducting an online questionnaire survey to collect the students’ demography and background data; as well as their perceptions (on a five-point Likert scale) towards BIM benefits, BIM functionalities, BIM as a career option, and challenges to BIM implementation in India. The 188 responses were divided into subgroups and statistically compared based on two-sample t-test and analysis of variance (ANOVA). Findings are discussed with their possible implications in the academia as well as the industry. The study emphasizes having a better engagement of the academia with the BIM industry and policy makers to develop a synergic BIM learning ecosystem.

A Framework of Contractual Protocol for Building Information Modelling (BIM) Implementation in Water Treatment Plant Projects

Building Information Modelling (BIM) is becoming a comprehensive collaborative process in the construction industry. Since the introduction of BIM in Malaysia in 2009, the technology adoption rate is slow when compared to other countries of the world. Most of the construction companies in Malaysia have an insight on the BIM concept but are yet to implement it in the management of their construction projects. By the year 2020, the Malaysian government will make BIM mandatory, this makes it important to carry out research on the possible applications of the technology. The aim for this research is to establish a Framework of Contractual Protocol for BIM-Water Treatment Plant projects in Malaysia. This research focuses on four (4) objectives which are: (a)to explore the Contractual Issues on BIM Implementation for Water Treatment Plant projects. (b) to identify the Contractual provision on BIM Implementation for Water Treatment Plant projects. (c) to determine the Requirement Components of Contractual Protocol for on BIM Implementation for Water Treatment Plant projects. (d) to establish a Framework of Contractual Protocol for on BIM Implementation for Water Treatment Plant projects. A qualitative method of enquiry was used for this study in Klang Valley using semi structured interview. The responses received were analyzed by using SPSS. The result of the analysis showed that the contractual issues posed by the adoption of BIM, the contractual provision, the requirement component of contractual protocol and to establish the framework of contractual protocol for BIM Implementation for Water Treatment Plant projects. The implication of this findings is that to prove the studies on legal and contractual aspect of BIM implementation in water Treatment Plant Projects is increase to meet the demand of the implementations of BIM technology is regarded as the future of construction industry, which makes it very important for the industry.

Methodology for retrospectively developing a BIM model from point cloud scans using ongoing building project as case study

Purpose The purpose of this study is to explore the suggestions that construction processes could be considerably improved by integrating building information modelling (BIM) with 3D laser scanning technologies. This case study integrated 3D laser point cloud scans with BIM to explore the effects of BIM adoption on ongoing construction project, whilst evaluating the utility of 3D laser scanning technology for producing structural 3D models by converting point cloud data (PCD) into BIM. Design/methodology/approach The primary data acquisition adopted the use of Trimble X7 laser scanning process, which is a set of data points in the scanned space that represent the scanned structure. The implementation of BIM with the 3D PCD to explore the precision and effectiveness of the construction processes as well as the as-built condition of a structure was precisely captured using the 3D laser scanning technology to recreate accurate and exact 3D models capable of being used to find and fix problems during construction. Findings The findings indicate that the integration of BIM and 3D laser scanning technology has the tendency to mitigate issues such as building rework, improved project completion times, reduced project cost, enhanced interdisciplinary communication, cooperation and collaboration amongst the project duty holders, which ultimately enhances the overall efficiency of the construction project. Research limitations/implications The acquisition of data using 3D laser scanner is usually conducted from the ground. Therefore, certain aspects of the building could potentially disturb data acquisition; for example, the gable and sections of eaves (fascia and soffit) could be left in a blind spot. Data acquisition using 3D laser scanner technology takes time, and the processing of the vast amount of data acquired is laborious, and if not carefully analysed, could result in errors in generated models. Furthermore, because this was an ongoing construction project, material stockpiling and planned construction works obstructed and delayed the seamless capture of scanned data points. Originality/value These findings highlight the significance of integrating BIM and 3D laser scanning technology in the construction process and emphasise the value of advanced data collection methods for effectively managing construction projects and streamlined workflows.

Overcoming Barriers to Implementing Building Information Modelling in Kuwait’s Ministry of Public Works: A Framework for Sustainable Construction

Construction projects in Kuwait’s Ministry of Public Works (MPW) involve numerous resources and stakeholders, necessitating effective communication and data sharing to avoid errors, conflicts, and resource wastage. Integrating Building Information Modelling (BIM) into the traditional procurement management approach has the potential to revolutionise the construction industry, enabling remote access to information and waste prevention, particularly for megaprojects. Despite its benefits, BIM adoption has been slow in MPW projects. This study investigates the reasons behind this reluctance and proposes a framework to integrate BIM into MPW projects. A qualitative research method of narrative analysis on semi-structured open interviews with key stakeholders in MPW was conducted to identify the benefits and barriers of BIM implementation. The study found that while tangible barriers were absent, challenges included a lack of senior management support, an inadequate BIM-skilled workforce, adherence to traditional processes, and limited awareness of BIM’s importance in circularity and sustainability. Nevertheless, a pilot project demonstrated improvements in collaboration, visualisation, budget estimation, and information sharing through BIM. This study proposes a framework for incorporating BIM into the MPW tendering process to address these issues, validated through interviews with tender managers. This framework aligns with Kuwait’s Vision 2035 for sustainable buildings and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) of the United Nations by encouraging the implementation of BIM. Since BIM has the potential to be an effective instrument in reaching these global goals, Kuwait’s construction industry should embrace and deploy BIM.

Challenges in the adoption of building information technology (BIM) technology in Indian construction industry (ICI)

Aim: This study aims to identify the challenges hindering the adoption of BIM technology in the ICI and provide insights into ways to overcome these challenges. Methodology: A questionnaire using a Likert scale was developed and distributed to 121 participants working for developers in the ICI. Factor analysis was conducted using SPSS 25 to examine the obtained data and identify the primary reasons that impede the adoption of BIM technology. Findings: Factor analysis of the data identified six main factors accounting for 74.31% of the variance. These factors included regulatory framework, lack of expertise, knowledge, and adoption, compatibility issues, resource limitations, and inadequate demand. Originality Value: The research above is unique since it specifically examines the obstacles that are preventing the widespread use of Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology in the building sector in India. While there is existing research on BIM adoption in other countries, there is a lack of comprehensive studies on the specific challenges faced by the Indian construction industry. This study provides insights into the main obstacles to BIM adoption in India and identifies six main factors that have not been extensively studied before. Additionally, the study uses a Likert scale questionnaire and factor analysis to analyze the data, which is a unique approach that has not been widely used in previous research on BIM adoption. Implications: The study’s findings offer valuable insights into the primary barriers hindering the adoption of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in the construction sector of India.. The identified factors can help developers and policymakers in the industry overcome these challenges to improve project efficiency and outcomes. This study can also provide a foundation for future investigations into the adoption of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in India and other emerging economies.. The implications of this study can contribute to the broader understanding of technology adoption in the construction industry, which can lead to better decision-making processes and improved project outcomes. Limitations and Scope for Future Research: The research has significant drawbacks. First, the study focused on the Indian construction industry and may not apply to other emerging or industrialized nations. Second, the limited sample size may restrict generalizability. The study solely examined BIM adoption barriers and did not provide solutions. Researchers might create techniques to overcome these obstacles and encourage BIM adoption in the Indian building sector. Finally, the research did not consider contractors, architects, and engineers, who may shed light on BIM adoption issues and solutions.

Developing a Model to Improve the Efficiency of Maintenance Management for Service Buildings Using BIM and Power BI: A Case Study

[1] Seely, I.H.1987. Building Maintenance. London, Second Edition.470p. [2] Hawass, Zaki. Building diseases.(1992). Egypt, World of Books, first edition, 54 pages. (Arabic version) [3] Abu Al-Majd, Sharif. (1993). Cracking in concrete structures and methods of treating them. Egyptian Universities Publishing House - Al-Wafaa Library, Egypt, 143 pages. (Arabic version) [4] - Menoun, Muhammad Suleiman. (1996). Residential building maintenance. Master's thesis, Egypt, 150 pages. (Arabic version) [5] Saladin, Wael. (1997). An approach to improving maintenance efficiency in hotels through evaluating actual performance after occupancy. Egypt University of Science and Technology.20 p. (Arabic version) [6] Al-Khatam, J.( 2003). Buildings Maintenance Cost. Master Thesis, King Fahd University of Petroleum Minerals, 66P [7] Reffat,R; Gero,J; Peng, W.(2004). Using Data Mining on Building Maintenance During the Building Life Cycle. University of Tasmania, Australia,91-97. [8] Bin Akasha. (2007),Generic Process Model for Maintenance Management of School Buildings, Malaysia University, 92p [9] Chanter, B; Swallow. (2007) . Building Maintenance Management. 2nd. Blackwell Publishing. USA, 313p. [10] Abdulateef ,O.A. (2008). Building Maintenance in Malaysia.207-214.10 [11] Abdel Sabour, Manar. Hosni, Abdul Hadi. Issawi, Ahmed. Naseer, Ibrahim. (2009), Maintenance of residential facilities in the Arab Republic of Egypt between reality and hopes. Doctoral thesis at Ain Shams University. 472 pages. [12] Akcamete, A; Akinci, B. (2010). Potential Utilization of Building Information Models for PlanningMaintenance Activity. Carnegie Mellon University, USA,7P. [13] Al-Nadawi, Abdul Aziz. (2011). Business Intelligence is an advanced methodology for developing administrative processes in business organizations. Journal of Financial and Commercial Studies, Issue 2, 26 pages. (Arabic version) [14] Hadad,Ruba, ; Hassan, Bassam. (2011), Developing a methodology to analyze the factors affecting the maintenance costs of hospitals, Master’s thesis, Tishreen University, 115 pages. (Arabic version) [15] Eastman, C; Teicholz, P; Sacks, R; Liston, K,(2011). BIM handbook: A guide to building information modeling for owners, managers, designers, engineers and contractors, John Wiley Sons15 [16] Wang, Y; Chen, H. (2011). A 3-dimensional Visualized Approach for Maintenance and Management of Facilities. Information and Computational Technology, 468-47516... [17] Choka ,D.G. (2012);Study on The Impact of Management System on Maintenance Condition of Built Facilities(Case Study of Public Universities in Kenya).June , ,76p17 [18] Abdel Rahman, Hisham. Eid, Muhammad. Abdul Karim. (2013), A proposed methodology for the maintenance of basic general buildings in Egypt. Assiut University Journal of Engineering Sciences, Volume 41, Issue 1, January 257-289. (Arabic version)18 [19] Lopes,I, H.(2016). Requirements Specification of a Computerized Maintenance Management System-Case Study268-273. [20] Al-Hassan, Basil; Jarad, Fayez. (2016), Improving maintenance management for government buildings using building information modeling (BIM) techniques, Master’s thesis, Tishreen University, 133 pages(Arabic version) [21] Ibrahim, Reham. Arja, Muhammad. (2017). Developing a system to manage the school building maintenance process based on performance indicators. Master's thesis, Tishreen University, 164 pages(Arabic version) [22] Ahmed, Sonia; Saleem, Omar (2018), The Way to BIM, Guide for Individuals and Companies, Dar Al-Kutub Al-Ilmiyyah for Publishing and Distribution, 151 pages. (Arabic version). [23] Shaban, M.H. and Elhendawi, A.,( 2018). Building Information Modeling in Syria: Obstacles and Requirements for Implementation. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 1(1). [24] Yusof, N., Ishak, S. Doheim, R., 2018. An Exploratory Study of Building Information Modelling Maturity in the Construction Industry. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 1(1), pp. 6-19. [25] Elhendawi, A.I.N., 2018. Methodology for BIM Implementation in KSA in AEC Industry. Master of Science MSc in Construction Project Management), Edinburgh Napier University, UK. [26] Elhendawi, A., Omar, H., Elbeltagi, E. and Smith, A.,( 2019). Practical approach for paving the way to motivate BIM non-users to adopt BIM. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 2(2), pp.1-22. [27] Banawi, A., Aljobaly, O., Ahiable, C. (2019). A comparative review of building information modeling frameworks. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 2(2), 23-48. [28] Elhendawi, A., Smith, A. Elbeltagi, E., 2019. Methodology for BIM implementation in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 2(1), pp. 1-21. [29] Al-Hassan, Basil; Omran, Jamal, Jarad, Fayez. (2019), Developing a system to support maintenance decisions in service buildings with an integrated methodology between knowledge management and BIM, PhD thesis, Tishreen University, 171 p. (Arabic version) [30] Al-Mazawi, Sanaa; Jarad, Fayez. Mia, Rana.(2019). Proposing a model for monitoring and evaluating the actual performance of managing the building maintenance process in public universities according to the theory of balanced performance (the case of Tishreen University) Tishreen University Journal, Engineering Sciences, Volume (41), Issue 4, 317-339. (Arabic version) [31] Morais ,G.A ; Casado,A.(2019). Building Maintenances Management Activities in A Public Institution . University de Pernambuco , Brazil .October,85-103 . [32] Al-Mazawi, Sanaa; Jarad, Fayez. Mia, Rana. (2020). Improving the efficiency of maintenance management in public universities through evaluating actual performance. Master's thesis, Tishreen University, 180 pages [33] Hamma-adama, M., Kouider, T. Salman, H., ( 2020). Analysis of barriers and drivers for BIM adoption. International journal of BIM and engineering science, 3(1), pp. 18-41. [34] Salamah, Taher, Shibani, Abdussalam, Alothman, Kheder: Improving AEC Project Performance in Syria Through the Integration of Earned Value Management System and Building Information Modelling: A Case Study, International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp:75. [35] Safour, R., Ahmed, S. Zaarour, B., (2021). BIM Adoption around the World. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 4(2), pp. 49-63. [36] Zaarour, B. Maihoub, N.(2021). Effect of needle diameters on the diameter of electro spun PVDF nanofibers. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, pp. 26-32. [37] Salami, H. Alothman, K.,( 2022). Engineering Training and its Importance for Building Information Modelling. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 5(1), pp. 41-60 [38] Roumieh, N. Ahmed, S. (2022). Adopting Risk Management Professional Methodologies as an Effective Strategy to Protect Heritage Sites in Syria, International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp: 61-72. [39] Saada, M. Aslan, H. (2022). The effectiveness of applying BIM in increasing the accuracy of estimating quantities for public facilities rehabilitation projects in Syria after the war, International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 5(2), pp: 08-1 [40] Mashali, A. El tantawi, A.,( 2022). BIM-based stakeholder information exchange (IE) during the planning phase in smart construction megaprojects (SCMPs). International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 5(1), pp. 08-19. [41] Dalloul. F. Saod. Lama,( 2023). Proposing a framework for introducing the concept of engineering digitization to develop curricula: case study - Tishreen University, Faculty of Civil Engineering. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science (IJBES) Vol. 06, No. 01, PP. 34-51, 2023 [42] Al Mezawy,S; Jrad,F;Maya,R.(2023).Methodology to Improve Efficiency of Maintenance Management for Service Building Using Business Intelligence .Damascus University Journal for The Engineering Sciences ,12. [43] Saleh ,F, H., Elhendawi , A Darwish.A,S. and Farell, P.,( 2024). An ICT-based Framework for Innovative Integration between BIM and Lean Practices Obtaining Smart Sustainable Cities. Al-Rasheed International Private University International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 2(2), pp.68-75.
 [44] Fawaz Saleh, Ashraf Elhendawi, Abdul Salam Darwish, Peter Farrell. (2024). A Framework for Leveraging the Incorporation of AI, BIM, and IoT to Achieve Smart Sustainable Cities. Journal of Journal of Intelligent Systems and Internet of Things, 11 (2), 75- 84 (Doi: https:doi.org10.54216JISIoT.110207) [45] Evans, M., Farrell, P., Elbeltagi, E., Mashali, A. and Elhendawi, A., 2020. Influence of partnering agreements associated with BIM adoption on stakeholder's behaviour in construction mega-projects. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 3(1), pp.1-20 [46] Elgendi, A.F., Elhendawi, A., Youssef, W.M.M. and Darwish, A.S., 2021. The Vulnerability of the Construction Ergonomics to Covid-19 and Its Probability Impact in Combating the Virus. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 4(1), pp.01- 19. [47] Ahmed, S., Dlask, P., Selim, O. and Elhendawi, A., 2018. BIM Performance Improvement Framework for Syrian AEC Companies. International Journal of BIM and Engineering Science, 1(1), pp.21-41

Effectiveness of using BIM in construction: comparative analysis and evaluation methodology

The paper focuses on investigating methods to improve the integration of Building Information Modeling (BIM) in the construction sector with the aim of enhancing the efficiency of executing investment and construction projects. The relevance is caused by the complexity of calculating the economic effect in the short-term planning period when implementing investment and construction projects using BIM and, accordingly, the lack of methods for economic justification of the need and possibility of using BIM at the design and construction stages. The study aims to compare modern software products and establish a methodology for evaluating the effectiveness of utilizing BIM in investment and construction projects (ICP). This methodology will facilitate conducting an economic analysis to justify the integration of these technologies in project implementation. The study concluded with an examination of global implementation practices, identification of challenges in BIM utilization, a survey of software alternatives, and an assessment of current approaches for economically justifying the adoption of BIM throughout various stages of the ICP life cycle. The research is based on systemic, process and situational approaches, methods of comparative and factor analysis, as well as methods of economic-mathematical and graphical modeling.