Sir, We congratulate Hashida et al (2013) on an interesting report that Merkel cell polyomavirus (MCV) is present in ∼18% of non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC). An important clarification is needed; however, we have not yet discovered a naturally occurring mutation in the MCV large T retinoblastoma-binding motif (LFCDE). We engineered the sequence that the authors refer to as Appendix206 ({type:entrez-nucleotide,attrs:{text:JN038578,term_id:354683949,term_text:JN038578}}JN038578) to have a lysine substitution mutation (LFCDK) to serve as a negative control for the wild-type appendix-derived LT deposited as {type:entrez-nucleotide,attrs:{text:JN038579,term_id:354683952,term_text:JN038579}}JN038579, which possesses a wild-type LXCXE motif. Post-submission editing at NCBI obfuscated the description of {type:entrez-nucleotide,attrs:{text:JN038578,term_id:354683949,term_text:JN038578}}JN038578, leading to the confusion described in this paper. Thus, all but one of the MCV sequences Hashida et al (2013) report are consistent with wild-type virus and do not have the tumour-specific mutations we described that eliminate MCV LT helicase activity (Shuda et al, 2008). The authors do describe one virus (AC43) with a terminally truncated LT consistent with a tumour-derived mutation. Together with its high viral copy number, this case represents a particularly intriguing tumor that deserves careful follow-up, such as Southern blotting for clonality and histopathological characterization with reliable biomarkers for NSCLC to investigate a potential MCV contribution to its tumorigenesis.
Read full abstract