Sir: Between January and December of 2008, this technique has been used in 96 consecutive unilateral cleft lip repairs. Forty-nine were of male and 47 of female patients, and 50 were incomplete unilateral cleft lip and 46 were complete unilateral cleft lip repairs. The patients' ages ranged between 3 months and 15 years, with a mean of 6.5 months. The operative markings are shown in Figure 1. The problem deserving of our attention is the marking of point 12; point 12 is marked just above the cutaneous roll, and then line 12-11 and line 4-6 are of equal length and will meet, line 13-12 and line 3-6 are of equal length and will meet too, and the line 13-12 plus line 12-10 is equal to that of the non–cleft-side philtral column (line 2-5).Fig. 1.: (Above, left) Preoperative sketch of unilateral incomplete cleft lip showing marking points and incision design. (Above, right, and below, left) Preoperative sketch of unilateral complete cleft lip showing marking points and incision design. (Below, right) Postoperative sketch of unilateral cleft lip repaired with the skin-vermilion method.All lines in Figure 1 are operative incisions. A skin-vermilion triangle flap is designed on the affected side of the lateral lip and inserted into the medial lip (line 6-4) to reconstruct a vermilion tubercle and lengthen the vertical height of the affected lip. The affected orbicularis is freed from its upturned insertion in the region of the columellar base, alveolar cleft margin, and alar base, and then the normal anatomical structure of the upper lip is reconstructed by resetting and fixing orbicularis, nasal columella, and nasal alae, and constructing the nasal base (Fig. 1). All of the patients presented good contour of the vermilion tubercle and chubby nasal base. The vertical height of their upper lip, nasal alae, and vermilion were symmetrical between affected and unaffected lateral lips. The technique can be applied to all degrees of unilateral cleft lip (Fig. 2).Fig. 2.: (Above, left) Preoperative markings of unilateral complete cleft lip. (Above, right) The operating incisions have been completed; a skin-vermilion triangle flap with skin, vermilion, and orbicularis has been formed on the affected side of the lateral lip and will be inserted into the medial lip to reconstruct a vermilion tubercle and lengthen the vertical height of the affected lip. Patient is shown preoperatively (below, left) and 7 days postoperatively (below, right).In patients with cleft lip, surgeons are constantly striving for the ultimate goal of achieving a lip and nose of normal form and function by operative repair. Even though we cannot achieve the ultimate goal at present, some achievements have been gained.1–3 For obtaining a normal upper lip and nose, we consider that we must solve two problems. The first is to recover the normal anatomical structure and tissue tension of the upper lip and nose with cleft lip, and the second is to provide an operative design with a minimal scar in the upper lip and a minimal impact on growing maxillae after cleft lip repair. This formed the basis of the described repair. The strengths of this described technique, then, are (1) effective completion of the problem about the affected medial lip deficient in vertical height without an increased incision in the nasal base; (2) application of lateral lip tissue in reconstructing the nasal agger and filling the nasal base; (3) maximum reservation of vermilion tissue, effective prevention of “whistle deformity,” and formation of a fluent red line; (4) minimal scar; and (5) an obvious vermilion tubercle and minimal tension of the upper lip for scarcely abandoning any tissue. The short-term effect of a cleft lip repair with the described technique is very satisfactory, but the long-term result after surgery should be observed by longer term follow-up of more cases. PATIENT CONSENT Parents or guardians provided written consent for use of patient images. Haisheng Yu, M.D. Qian Wei, M.D. Plastic Surgery Nan Ning, China
Read full abstract