You have accessJournal of UrologyGeneral & Epidemiological Trends & Socioeconomics: Practice Patterns, Quality of Life and Shared Decision Making II1 Apr 2016PD17-02 THE USE OF CYTOLOGY DURING THE WORKUP OF PATIENTS WITH PRIMARY MICROSCOPIC HEMATURIA: GUIDELINE COMPLIANCE PATTERNS AMONG A COHORT OF ACADEMIC UROLOGISTS Patrick Samson, Paras Shah, Derek Friedman, Karly Stoltman, Vinay Patel, Simpa Salami, Andrew Ng, Manaf Alom, Jessica Kreshover, Joph Steckel, Manish Vira, Lee Richstone, Louis Kavoussi, and Justin Han Patrick SamsonPatrick Samson More articles by this author , Paras ShahParas Shah More articles by this author , Derek FriedmanDerek Friedman More articles by this author , Karly StoltmanKarly Stoltman More articles by this author , Vinay PatelVinay Patel More articles by this author , Simpa SalamiSimpa Salami More articles by this author , Andrew NgAndrew Ng More articles by this author , Manaf AlomManaf Alom More articles by this author , Jessica KreshoverJessica Kreshover More articles by this author , Joph SteckelJoph Steckel More articles by this author , Manish ViraManish Vira More articles by this author , Lee RichstoneLee Richstone More articles by this author , Louis KavoussiLouis Kavoussi More articles by this author , and Justin HanJustin Han More articles by this author View All Author Informationhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2016.02.1167AboutPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints ShareFacebookTwitterLinked InEmail INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES The diagnostic utility of urine cytology in the workup of patients with primary microscopic hematuria (MH) has come into question given most urologic malignancies are reliably detected with cross-sectional imaging and cystoscopy. As such, the current AUA guidelines for MH regard cytology as an optional test, reserved for those who have concerning risk factors for malignancy. We evaluate the practice patterns of a cohort of twenty-three academic urologists serving a large geographical area with respect to the use of urine cytology in the workup of patients with primary MH. METHODS We retrospectively reviewed 2736 patients evaluated for MH between 2012 and 2015. Patients were stratified as “high-risk” if they possessed one or more risk factors for malignancy as specified by the AUA microscopic hematuria guidelines (smoking history, irritative voiding symptoms, chemotherapy exposure, and pelvic irradiation) versus “low-risk” if they lacked risk factors. Fisher's exact test was used to compare proportions of patients receiving cytology as part of their workup, stratified by risk group and urologist training (five oncology fellowship trained vs eighteen non-oncology fellowship trained). RESULTS Among 1761 patients with primary MH, 856 had risk factors that justified the use of cytology. Despite this, cytology was utilized in the evaluation of over 90% of low-risk patients. Interestingly, the rate of usage of cytology was significantly higher in low-risk compared with high-risk patients (90.7% vs 86.9%; p=0.002). When stratified by type of fellowship training, urologic oncologists were more likely to order cytology for low-risk patients compared with non-oncology trained urologists (98.9% vs 89.8%; p=0.004). The sensitivity for urothelial malignancy was 42.9%, whereas the positive predictive value among high-risk patients was 7.3%. CONCLUSIONS Despite being classified by current guidelines as an optional test, cytology remains a highly utilized screening tool for both low- and high-risk patients presenting with primary MH by both oncology-trained and non-oncology trained urologists. Given its marginal diagnostic yield, use of cytology likely represents an unnecessary medical expenditure especially in low risk patients. Stricter guideline statements are required to reduce its indiscriminate use during workup of patients with primary MH. © 2016FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Volume 195Issue 4SApril 2016Page: e399 Advertisement Copyright & Permissions© 2016MetricsAuthor Information Patrick Samson More articles by this author Paras Shah More articles by this author Derek Friedman More articles by this author Karly Stoltman More articles by this author Vinay Patel More articles by this author Simpa Salami More articles by this author Andrew Ng More articles by this author Manaf Alom More articles by this author Jessica Kreshover More articles by this author Joph Steckel More articles by this author Manish Vira More articles by this author Lee Richstone More articles by this author Louis Kavoussi More articles by this author Justin Han More articles by this author Expand All Advertisement Advertisement PDF downloadLoading ...
Read full abstract