Use Of Dietary Fluoride Supplements Research Articles

Dental caries and fluorosis experience of 8-12-year-old children by early-life exposure to fluoride.

It is important to evaluate concurrently the benefit for dental caries and the risk for dental fluorosis from early exposure to fluoride among children. To evaluate associations of different levels of exposure to fluoride in early childhood with dental caries and dental fluorosis experience in school children. A Child Dental Health Survey (CDHS) was conducted among school children in the Australian state of New South Wales (NSW) in 2007. Trained and calibrated examination teams conducted oral epidemiologic examinations to assess caries experience as decayed, missing or filled tooth surfaces of the primary and permanent dentitions (dmfs/DMFS) and fluorosis using the Thylstrup & Fejerskov (TF) index on the maxillary central incisors only. A parental questionnaire collected information on residential histories and tap water usage to enable calculation of percentage of 3-year lifetime exposure to fluoride in water. Use of dietary fluoride supplements was also collected. Dental caries and fluorosis experience were compared among groups by levels of exposure to fluoride from water and fluoride supplements in bivariate and multivariable analysis, controlling for socioeconomic factors. Exposure to different fluoride sources varied in the group of 2611 children aged 8-12 years. Lower household income was significantly associated in both bivariate and multivariable analyses with the greater prevalence and severity of primary tooth caries among 8-10-year-old children and permanent tooth caries among 8-12 year old. Exposure to fluoride in water during the first 3 years of life was associated with both caries and fluorosis experience observed at age 8-12 years. Having higher percentage of 3-year lifetime exposure to fluoride in water was associated with higher prevalence of mostly mild fluorosis, but significantly lower prevalence and severity of caries in the primary and permanent dentitions. There were significant associations of dental caries and fluorosis experience with sources of early childhood fluoride exposure among children aged 8-12 years in New South Wales. Exposure to fluoridated water during the first 3 years of life was associated with better oral health of school-age children.

Use of Dietary Fluoride Supplements by Children Living in Berlin, Germany, may have a Dose-response Preventive Effect Against Dental Caries, Regardless of their Use of Fluoridated Salt

Effects of fluoride tablets on caries and fluorosis occurrence among 6- to 9-year olds using fluoridated salt. Meyer-Lueckel H, Grundmann E, Stang A. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2010;38(4):315-23. Eugenio D. Beltrán-Aguilar, DMD, MPH, MS, DrPH To assess benefits (caries prevention) and risks (dental fluorosis) of using dietary fluoride supplements (referred as “fluoride tablets” in the article) among children consuming fluoridated salt in a district of Berlin, Germany. Information not available. The authors acknowledged the cooperation of the Public Dental Services of the Steglitz-Zehlendorf district in Berlin Retrospective cohort study Level 2: Limited-quality, patient-oriented evidence Not applicable

Decision-making for national programs of community fluoride use.

Every community, region or country with a high or rising prevalence of dental caries should implement a caries-preventive program that automatically brings the benefits of systemic and topically applied fluoride to the entire population. The fluoridation of community water supplies or salt fulfills the requirements of providing safe, effective protection from dental caries at reasonable cost. The use of dietary fluoride supplements or fluoridated milk does not meet the requirements of a comprehensive national or community program because compliance is poor or only selected age groups are targeted. Water fluoridation is ideal for countries, regions or communities with many central water supplies or where salt production or distribution is not centralized or easy to control. Water fluoridation also has advantages where many areas exist with natural water fluoride concentrations at optimal or greater than optimal concentrations. Salt fluoridation is ideal for countries or regions with few, potable central water supplies in which salt production and distribution are centralized and easily controlled. Concentrations of fluoride for water fluoridation range from 0.5 to 1.2 parts per million (ppm) parts of water depending on climate and dietary practices. The concentration for fluoridation of salt is approximately 200 to 250 mg fluoride per kg of salt, also depending on dietary practices. Properly fluoridated salt should produce levels of urinary fluoride excretion similar to those found in communities with fluoridated water. Benefits of the two methods are similar. Salt fluoridation may be done more cheaply.

Total fluoride intake and implications for dietary fluoride supplementation.

This paper reviews the history and validity of recommended "optimal" levels of systemic fluoride intake and the available information on levels of fluoride intake in young children from foods and beverages (including water), dentifrices, dietary fluoride supplements, mouthrinses, and gels. Most of the studies emphasize the substantial variation in ingestion among individuals. Often, a substantial proportion of individuals received fluoride well beyond the mean exposure reported in the study. Limitations in the existing data make it difficult to determine the total distribution of fluoride intake from all sources. Therefore, hypothetical combinations of possible daily fluoride intake from the three main sources (diet, dentifrices, and supplements) are presented for those aged 6, 12, 24, and 36 months, with associated mean intake per kg body weight. Findings suggest that some children exceed the "optimal" level of fluoride intake from single sources alone, while others can from a combination of sources. Moreover, if current recommended "optimal" levels, which have been derived on an empirical basis, are actually lower than what has been quoted in the literature, then more children could be ingesting excessive amounts of fluoride, which could increase their risk of developing objectionable dental fluorosis. The variation and complexity of fluoride ingestion from all sources should be considered in the evaluation of recommendations for use of dietary fluoride supplements.

The case for eliminating the use of dietary fluoride supplements for young children.

Fluoride supplements have been used for years to prevent dental caries; nevertheless, there are three reasons why their use is inappropriate today among infants and young children in the United States. Evidence for the efficacy of fluoride supplements when used from birth or soon after is weak, supplements are a risk factor for dental fluorosis, and fluoride has little preeruptive effect in caries prevention. While there are many reports on the caries-preventive efficacy of supplements, few meet standards for acceptability as clinical trials, and those that do have tested chewable tablets or lozenges under supervision in school-aged children. North American children today are exposed to fluoride from many sources--drinking water, toothpaste, gels, rinses, and in processed foods and beverages. The additional cariostatic benefits that accrue from using supplements are marginal at best, while there is strong risk of fluorosis when young children use supplements. Available evidence suggests that the public is more aware of the milder forms of fluorosis than was previously thought; thus, it is prudent for caries-preventive policies to aim to maximizing caries reductions while minimizing the risk of fluorosis. It is therefore concluded that the risks of using supplements in infants and young children outweigh the benefits. Because alternative forms of fluoride for high-risk individuals exist, fluoride supplements should no longer be used for young children in North America.

Commentary on and Recommendations for the Proper Uses of Fluoride

Fluorosis has been associated with the fluoride concentration of drinking water, use of dietary fluoride supplements, early use of dentifrices, and prolonged use of infant formula. The literature, however, does not show associations between fluorosis and use of fluoride mouthrinses, professionally applied fluorides, bottled waters, carbonated beverages, and juices. It is unwise to issue laundry lists of items that may be implicated as problem-causing when, in fact, they may not be. Although usually classified without fluorosis, children in Dean's "questionable" category would be classified with the condition if the TFI or TSIF were used. Accordingly, Dean, in 1942, really reported only 52.8 percent of children without fluorosis in Kewanee, a community with 0.9 ppm fluoride in drinking water. Because the morbidity and sequelae of dental caries have declined, undue emphasis has been placed recently on the risks of using fluoride rather than on its profound beneficial effects. Although of paramount importance, conclusions cannot be drawn on whether fluoride protects against, contributes to, or has no effect on bone fractures or is valuable in treating osteoporosis. Careful thought is required before making recommendations that may reduce health benefits because of unfounded concerns about perceived risks. There should be greater regulation of extraneous fluoride sources, rather than reliance on educational efforts or recommendations to eliminate use of highly effective preventive regimens.

Factors Associated with the Use of Fluoride Supplements and Fluoride Dentifrice by Infants and Toddlers

Dental fluorosis may be associated with the inappropriate use of fluoride dentifrices and/or dietary fluoride supplements by young children, especially for those who consume optimally fluoridated water. Studies to date have used retrospective designs that rely on anamnestic responses of adults to determine fluoride exposures in their children. The 1986 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) collected information on current use of fluoride-containing dental products (dentifrices, drops, tablets, and mouthrinses) by all household members during home interviews. This report contains information obtained from adults for 1,996 children younger than two years of age. Nearly half of the children used fluoride dentifrices or dietary fluoride supplements. Eleven percent of the children younger than one year of age and nearly 60 percent of children between one and two years of age reportedly used a fluoride toothpaste. Dietary fluoride supplements were used about equally in these age groups (about 16%). The use of a fluoride dentifrice was similar across racial-ethnic groups, but the use of dietary fluoride supplements was less among blacks and Hispanics. A significantly higher proportion of children whose respondent knew the purpose of water fluoridation used some type of fluoride product. Because young children tend to swallow dentifrices, the findings of this study suggest the need for educational programs targeted to parents and health care providers regarding the appropriate use of fluorides and the risk of fluorosis when they are used inappropriately.

Evaluation of appropriate use of dietary fluoride supplements in the US

Recent epidemiologic and related evidence suggests the following trends: 1. the prevalence of caries continues to decline in children of the US and several other developed countries; 2. the prevalence of mild dental fluorosis is increasing; 3. the majority of the cariostatic effects of fluoride are topical; and 4. dietary fluoride supplements are a risk factor for dental fluorosis. These trends, and the scientific evidence on fluoride and fluorosis, suggest that it is time to re-evaluate the use of dietary fluoride supplements. This paper examines the evidence for each of the four trends and the use of fluoride supplements in caries prevention today.

The Future of Water Fluoridation and Other Systemic Fluorides

School and community water fluoridation, salt fluoridation, and use of dietary fluoride supplements have abundant scientific support as effective caries-preventive methods. Because caries has declined greatly in many developed countries from use of topical fluorides, the absolute caries reduction will be considerably smaller when systemic fluoride methods are implemented now than it was 20 to 40 years ago. For countries with most of the population living in cities with communal water supplies, community fluoridation is the most logical approach from the standpoints of cost-effectiveness and total caries-preventive impact. In countries with a mostly rural population without central water supplies, salt fluoridation is more practical. Dietary fluoride supplements can be recommended only for regions where neither water fluoridation nor salt fluoridation is possible, or as a temporary measure. Although divergent views exist concerning the relative caries-preventive effects of pre-eruptive and post-eruptive fluoride administration, the effectiveness of systemic fluoride methods for preventing dental caries remains unchallenged. Persuasive scientific and public health arguments exist to justify implementing and sustaining their use. The future of these methods will be influenced by the findings of new clinical and epidemiological research. Social, political, economic, and educational factors will be of equal, if not greater, importance. Perceptions of the current severity of dental caries as a health problem and of risks associated with preventing the problem may affect the future uses of systemic fluorides more than will recommendations of scientists.

Guidelines for the use of dietary fluoride supplements in Australia.

A survey in 1988 of brands of fluoride supplements available in a non-fluoridated town in Western Australia, and tablets described in pharmaceutical product registers, revealed that six brands of tablets and one brand of solution (drops) were on the market. Tablets contained 2.2 mg or 1.1 mg NaF; the solution contained 2.2 mg NaF per mL. All products provided age-dose schedules which would give fluoride supplementation at levels greater than the National Health and Medical Research Council guidelines. In one case, infants following the schedule would receive four times the recommended dose for the first two years of life. Compliance with several of the age-dose schedules would be certain to cause significant dental fluorosis. Whether the others caused fluorosis would depend on the quantity of fluoride in the diet, and consumption of fluoride toothpaste. The survey showed a generalized disregard on the part of the ethical pharmaceutical industry for the risk of dental fluorosis, and reveals a need for a voluntary, or legally enforced, code of conduct for manufacturers of fluoride supplements. The value of guidelines which are not monitored is doubtful.

Amounts of Fluoride in Self-Administered Dental Products: Safety Considerations for Children

With the increased use of various fluoride preparations for caries prevention, all dental personnel should know their potential toxicity and the margins of safety associated with their use. An understanding of the body's mechanisms for handling fluoride provides a rational basis for assessing the possible risks of excessive fluoride ingestion. Five to 10 g of sodium fluoride is considered a certainly lethal dose for a 70-kg adult. One quarter of the certainly lethal dose can be ingested without producing serious acute toxicity and is known as the safely tolerated dose. Comparisons of certainly lethal and safely tolerated doses for commonly used fluoride agents and procedures show that they can be applied with little or no risk of adverse acute effects, as long as they are used judiciously. If their use is abused, there is a risk of illness or even death. If amounts of fluoride close to the certainly lethal dose are ingested, the speed of initiating proper treatment is critical for survival. Vomiting should be induced, if it is not spontaneous; fluoride-binding liquids, such as milk or liquid or gel antacids, administered; and the patient taken to the nearest hospital for emergency care. Frequent ingestion of low but excessive quantities of fluoride during the period of tooth formation can lead to dental fluorosis. Particular concern is warranted for the ingestion of fluoride-containing toothpastes by young children and the inappropriate use of dietary fluoride supplements in communities with sufficient fluoride already present in drinking water.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Dental caries and the pediatrician.

The recent advent on the market of fluoride-vitamin combinations, with an impending proliferation of products and preparations for the beguilement of the pediatrician, makes it desirable to get the problem of dental caries and its prevention into proper perspective. The use of dietary fluoride supplements, alone or in combination with unrelated nutrients, is a by-product of the development of broader measures for the prevention of dental caries. The pediatrician, because of the nature of his training and practice, is concerned with the prevention of disease states affecting any organ system during childhood. Dental caries, the most common chronic and progressive condition prevailing throughout childhood and adolescence, should not be excluded from this concern, especially since there are effective means available to eliminate a large segment of the problem through preventive measures and early and regular treatment in the dental office. Dental caries may become manifest in the deciduous teeth soon