Abstract Criminal enforcement plays an important role to safeguard both the private rights and the public interests against counterfeiting, piracy and other unlawful activities related to the infringement of intellectual property rights (IPRs). Owing to the international obligations outlined in the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (the TRIPS Agreement), infringement of IPRs has been criminalized by all member states and criminal procedures shall apply accordingly under the conditions determined in their national laws. This article aims to present an overview and comparative analysis of the criminal law protection of IPRs in the Balkans to point out the main difficulties faced by the criminal courts in their practice. In particular, attention focuses on trade mark rights as a case study. The article examines the relevance of criminal law within the context of international obligations and domestic legal frameworks by providing a detailed legal analysis of the corresponding criminal law provisions in the Balkan countries. In this regard, the article identifies the elements required for the investigation and prosecution of such type of offences by evidencing the practical issues and difficulties of law enforcement agencies where they need to prove the intention of deceiving consumers as a necessary element to hold a person criminally responsible. Overall, the article explores the practical significance of criminal law in the enforcement of IPRs as an effective tool in deterring and prosecuting IP crimes, as well as provides some important steps to improve criminal law tools in the Balkans.
Read full abstract