Contemporary Westerns: Film and Television since 1990 Andrew Patrick Nelson, Editor. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Press, 2013.It has been nearly a quarter century since Dances with Wolves (1990) and Unforgiven (1992) renewed Hollywood's interest in the Western. The genre's current revival has, in fact, now lasted longer than its prematurely reported death in the 1970s and 1980s. Contemporary Hollywood Westerns sets out to map the contours of the ongoing Western revival but ultimately fails to capture either the conceptual breadth or the thematic depth that has sustained it.Eight of the book's eleven essays focus on a single film or television series, two deal with paired films, and one with two films and a television series. The essays' narrow focus and limited numbers mean that, even within its narrow chronological range (1990- 2010), the book omits more than it covers. Dances with Wolves (1990), No Country for Old Men (2007), and True Grit (2010) get full essays, but Tombstone (1993), Lone Star (1996), and 3:10 to Yuma (2007) receive a sentence or less. Neo-traditionalist telefilms like Conagher (1991) and Appaloosa (2008); high-concept, stardriven Westerns like Maverick (1994) and Shanghai Noon (2000); and mainstream television series like The Young Riders (1989-1992) and Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman (1993-1998) are absent, save for brief mentions in the introduction. Shaping any book requires choices, but no guiding concept seems to lie behind the choices that shaped Contemporary Westerns. It offers neither a comprehensive survey of the post-1990 Western, nor a framing of the era's canonical classics, nor a championing of hitherto-neglected works. Only chronology and genre link the articles.The lack of cohesion is exacerbated by the contributors' collective unwillingness to relate their films to other Westerns, whether pre- or post-1990. William C. Siska's essay on There Will be Blood and No Country for Old Men (both 2007) is a particular case in point. Its central theme-the rupture of traditional Western values by modern capitalism-cries out for genre context. Josh Brolin's cocky antihero Llewellyn Moss exists in dialogue with Warren Beatty's doomed frontier entrepreneur from McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971), and Daniel Day-Lewis's ruthless oilman Daniel Plainview stands in the shadow not only of Michael Corleone and Gordon Gekko (as Siska notes), but also cattle baron Thomas Dunson in Red River (1948). Those resonances go unacknowledged, however, as does the Western's view of frontier capitalism as both blessing and curse. …
Read full abstract