Transition metal borides, carbides, pnictides, and chalcogenides (X-ides) are a new class of oxygen evolution reaction (OER) electrocatalysts, which have become a relevant topic for electrocatalytic energy conversion and storage research. This is because of their earth abundance, high electrical conductivity, and resultant high OER performance. Furthermore, some X-ide electrocatalysts demonstrate various degrees of oxidation resistance under OER potentials due to their differences in chemical composition, crystal structure, and morphology. Interestingly, there are three possible post-OER electrocatalyst models: a fully oxidized oxide/(oxy)hydroxide material, a partially oxidized core@shell structure, and an unoxidized material.1 In the past ten years (from 2013 to 2022), over 890 peer-reviewed research papers have focused on X-ide OER electrocatalysts. Recently, several topical reviews have been published. However, typically these literature reviews have provided limited conclusions targeted at only certain X-ides. Additionally, certain reviews omit key points, especially regarding the “catalytically active species” in X-ide OER electrocatalysts.In this work, we provide a comprehensive summary of (i) the experimental parameters (e.g., substrates, electrocatalyst loading amounts, electrocatalyst shapes, geometric overpotentials, Tafel slopes, etc.) and (ii) the details of the electrochemical stability tests and following post analyses used in all the X-ide OER electrocatalyst publications from 2013 (the birth of this research area) to 2022.2 In particular, based on the reported post-OER analytical results, we attempt to exhaustively classify all the X-ide electrocatalysts into four groups: no oxidation, partial oxidation, full oxidation, and unknown, which is relevant to the nature of the “catalytically active species” in X-ide OER electrocatalysts. After investigating the simpler X-ide systems, transition metal-based polyanion compounds/composites are also surveyed. Finally, we introduce the reported novel and special analytical techniques employed for observing X-ide reconstruction (i.e., oxidation and other phase transformations) during OER testing, which can be useful in selecting the analytical technique of maximum utility for the researchers’ purpose. Additionally, for each material sub-group (e.g., borides, carbides, nitrides, phosphides, sulfides, selenides, and tellurides), we also point out further challenges to be addressed and propose further questions yet to be answered, which may provide clues pointing to future research tasks. References B. R. Wygant, K. Kawashima, and C. B. Mullins, ACS Energy Lett., 3, 2956–2966 (2018).K. Kawashima et al., Chem. Rev., 123, 12795–13208 (2023).
Read full abstract