Transient Protein-protein Complexes Research Articles

Structure and thermodynamics of transient protein-protein complexes by chemometric decomposition of SAXS datasets

Transient biomolecular interactions play crucial roles in many cellular signaling and regulation processes. However, deciphering the structure of these assemblies is challenging owing to the difficulties in isolating complexes from the individual partners. The additive nature of small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data allows for probing the species present in these mixtures, but decomposition into structural and thermodynamic information is difficult. We present a chemometric approach enabling the decomposition of titration SAXS data into species-specific information. Using extensive synthetic SAXS data, we demonstrate that robust decomposition can be achieved for titrations with a maximum fraction of complex of 0.5 that can be extended to 0.3 when two orthogonal titrations are simultaneously analyzed. The effect of the structural features, titration points, relative concentrations, and noise are thoroughly analyzed. The validation of the strategy with experimental data highlights the power of the approach to provide unique insights into this family of biomolecular assemblies.

Substrate Channeling via a Transient Protein-Protein Complex: The case of D-Glyceraldehyde-3-Phosphate Dehydrogenase and L-Lactate Dehydrogenase

Substrate channeling studies have frequently failed to provide conclusive results due to poor understanding of this subtle phenomenon. We analyzed the mechanism of NADH-channeling from D-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) to L-lactate Dehydrogenase (LDH) using enzymes from different cells. Enzyme kinetics studies showed that LDH activity with free NADH and GAPDH-NADH complex always take place in parallel. The channeling is observed only in assays that mimic cytosolic conditions where free NADH concentration is negligible and the GAPDH-NADH complex is dominant. Molecular dynamics and protein-protein interaction studies showed that LDH and GAPDH can form a leaky channeling complex only at the limiting NADH concentrations. Surface calculations showed that positive electric field between the NAD(H) binding sites on LDH and GAPDH tetramers can merge in the LDH-GAPDH complex. NAD(H)-channeling within the LDH-GAPDH complex can be an extension of NAD(H)-channeling within each tetramer. In the case of a transient LDH-(GAPDH-NADH) complex, the relative contribution from the channeled and the diffusive paths depends on the overlap between the off-rates for the LDH-(GAPDH-NADH) complex and the GAPDH-NADH complex. Molecular evolution or metabolic engineering protocols can exploit substrate channeling for metabolic flux control by fine-tuning substrate-binding affinity for the key enzymes in the competing reaction paths.

The Transient Complex of Cytochrome c and Cytochrome c Peroxidase: Insights into the Encounter Complex from Multifrequency EPR and NMR Spectroscopy.

We present a novel approach to study transient protein‐protein complexes with standard, 9 GHz, and high‐field, 95 GHz, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and paramagnetic NMR at ambient temperatures and in solution. We apply it to the complex of yeast mitochondrial iso‐1‐cytochrome c (Cc) with cytochrome c peroxidase (CcP) with the spin label [1‐oxyl‐2,2,5,5‐tetramethyl‐Δ3‐pyrroline‐3‐methyl)‐methanethiosulfonate] attached at position 81 of Cc (SL−Cc). A dissociation constant KD of 20±4×10−6 M (EPR and NMR) and an equal amount of stereo‐specific and encounter complex (NMR) are found. The EPR spectrum of the fully bound complex reveals that the encounter complex has a significant population (60 %) that shares important features, such as the Cc‐interaction surface, with the stereo‐specific complex.

Interface residues of transient protein-protein complexes have extensive intra-protein interactions apart from inter-protein interactions

BackgroundProtein-protein interactions are crucial for normal biological processes and to regulate cellular reactions that affect gene expression and function. Several previous studies have emphasized the roles of residues at the interface of protein-protein complexes in conferring stability and specificity to the complex. Interface residues in a protein are well known for their interactions with sidechain and main chain atoms with the interacting protein. However, the extent of intra-protein interactions involving interface residues in a protein-protein complex and their relative contribution in comparison to inter-protein interactions are not clearly understood. This paper probes this feature using a dataset of protein-protein complexes of known 3-D structure.ResultsWe have analysed a dataset of 45 transient protein-protein complex structures with at least one of the interacting proteins with a known structure available also in the unbound form. We observe that a large proportion of interface residues (1608 out of 2137 interface residues, 75%) are involved in intra and inter-protein interactions simultaneously. The amino acid propensities of such interfacial residues involved in bifurcated interactions are found to be highly similar to the general propensities to occur at protein-protein interfaces. Finally, we observe that a majority (83%) of intra-protein interactions of interface residues with bifurcated interactions, are also observed in the protein uncomplexed form.ConclusionsWe have shown, to the best of our knowledge for the first time, that a vast majority of the protein-protein interface residues are involved in extensive intra-protein interactions apart from inter-protein interactions. For a majority of such interface residues the microenvironment in the tertiary structure is pre-formed and retained upon complex formation with its cognate partner during transient interactions.ReviewersThis article was reviewed by Arumay Pal and Mallur Madhusudhan.

Genetically Encoded 2-Aryl-5-carboxytetrazoles for Site-Selective Protein Photo-Cross-Linking.

The genetically encoded photo-cross-linkers promise to offer a temporally controlled tool to map transient and dynamic protein–protein interaction complexes in living cells. Here we report the synthesis of a panel of 2-aryl-5-carboxytetrazole-lysine analogs (ACTKs) and their site-specific incorporation into proteins via amber codon suppression in Escherichia coli and mammalian cells. Among five ACTKs investigated, N-methylpyrroletetrazole-lysine (mPyTK) was found to give robust and site-selective photo-cross-linking reactivity in E. coli when placed at an appropriate site at the protein interaction interface. A comparison study indicated that mPyTK exhibits higher photo-cross-linking efficiency than a diazirine-based photo-cross-linker, AbK, when placed at the same location of the interaction interface in vitro. When mPyTK was introduced into the adapter protein Grb2, it enabled the photocapture of EGFR in a stimulus-dependent manner. The design of mPyTK along with the identification of its cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase makes it possible to map transient protein–protein interactions and their interfaces in living cells.

Weak conservation of structural features in the interfaces of homologous transient protein-protein complexes.

Residue types at the interface of protein-protein complexes (PPCs) are known to be reasonably well conserved. However, we show, using a dataset of known 3-D structures of homologous transient PPCs, that the 3-D location of interfacial residues and their interaction patterns are only moderately and poorly conserved, respectively. Another surprising observation is that a residue at the interface that is conserved is not necessarily in the interface in the homolog. Such differences in homologous complexes are manifested by substitution of the residues that are spatially proximal to the conserved residue and structural differences at the interfaces as well as differences in spatial orientations of the interacting proteins. Conservation of interface location and the interaction pattern at the core of the interfaces is higher than at the periphery of the interface patch. Extents of variability of various structural features reported here for homologous transient PPCs are higher than the variation in homologous permanent homomers. Our findings suggest that straightforward extrapolation of interfacial nature and inter-residue interaction patterns from template to target could lead to serious errors in the modeled complex structure. Understanding the evolution of interfaces provides insights to improve comparative modeling of PPC structures.

The Near-iron Transporter (NEAT) Domains of the Anthrax Hemophore IsdX2 Require a Critical Glutamine to Extract Heme from Methemoglobin

Several gram-positive pathogenic bacteria employ near-iron transporter (NEAT) domains to acquire heme from hemoglobin during infection. However, the structural requirements and mechanism of action for NEAT-mediated heme extraction remains unknown. Bacillus anthracis exhibits a rapid growth rate during systemic infection, suggesting that the bacterium expresses efficient iron acquisition systems. To understand how B. anthracis acquires iron from heme sources, which account for 80% of mammalian iron stores, we investigated the properties of the five-NEAT domain hemophore IsdX2. Using a combination of bioinformatics and site-directed mutagenesis, we determined that the heme extraction properties of IsdX2 are dependent on an amino acid with an amide side chain within the 310-helix of the NEAT domain. Additionally, we used a spectroscopic analysis to show that IsdX2 NEAT domains only scavenge heme from methemoglobin (metHb) and that autoxidation of oxyhemoglobin to metHb must occur prior to extraction. We also report the crystal structures of NEAT5 wild type and a Q29T mutant and present surface plasmon resonance data that indicate that the loss of this amide side chain reduces the affinity of the NEAT domain for metHb. We propose a model whereby the amide side chain is first required to drive an interaction with metHb that destabilizes heme, which is subsequently extracted and coordinated in the aliphatic heme-binding environment of the NEAT domain. Because an amino acid with an amide side chain in this position is observed in NEAT domains of several genera of gram-positive pathogenic bacteria, these results suggest that specific targeting of this or nearby residues may be an entry point for inhibitor development aimed at blocking bacterial iron acquisition during infection.

Substrates of IAP Ubiquitin Ligases Identified with a Designed Orthogonal E3 Ligase, the NEDDylator

Inhibitors of Apoptosis Protein (IAPs) are guardian ubiquitin ligases that keep classic proapoptotic proteins in check. Systematic identification of additional IAP substrates is challenged by the heterogeneity and sheer number of ubiquitinated proteins (>5,000). Here we report a powerful catalytic tagging tool, the NEDDylator, which fuses a NEDD8 E2-conjugating enzyme, Ubc12, to the ubiquitin ligase, XIAP or cIAP1. This permits transfer of the rare ubiquitin homolog NEDD8 to the ubiquitin E3 substrates, allowing them to be efficiently purified for LC-MS/MS identification. We have identified >50 potential IAP substrates of both cytosolic and mitochondrial origin that bear hallmark N-terminal IAP binding motifs. These substrates include the recently discovered protein phosphatase PGAM5, which we show is proteolytically processed, accumulates in cytosol during apoptosis, and sensitizes cells to death. These studies reveal mechanisms and antagonistic partners for specific IAPs, and provide a powerful technology for labeling binding partners in transient protein-protein complexes.

Mapping Ultra-weak Protein-Protein Interactions between Heme Transporters of Staphylococcus aureus

Iron is an essential nutrient for the proliferation of Staphylococcus aureus during bacterial infections. The iron-regulated surface determinant (Isd) system of S. aureus transports and metabolizes iron porphyrin (heme) captured from the host organism. Transportation of heme across the thick cell wall of this bacterium requires multiple relay points. The mechanism by which heme is physically transferred between Isd transporters is largely unknown because of the transient nature of the interactions involved. Herein, we show that the IsdC transporter not only passes heme ligand to another class of Isd transporter, as previously known, but can also perform self-transfer reactions. IsdA shows a similar ability. A genetically encoded photoreactive probe was used to survey the regions of IsdC involved in self-dimerization. We propose an updated model that explicitly considers self-transfer reactions to explain heme delivery across the cell wall. An analogous photo-cross-linking strategy was employed to map transient interactions between IsdC and IsdE transporters. These experiments identified a key structural element involved in the rapid and specific transfer of heme from IsdC to IsdE. The resulting structural model was validated with a chimeric version of the homologous transporter IsdA. Overall, our results show that the ultra-weak interactions between Isd transporters are governed by bona fide protein structural motifs.

Roles of residues in the interface of transient protein-protein complexes before complexation

Transient protein-protein interactions play crucial roles in all facets of cellular physiology. Here, using an analysis on known 3-D structures of transient protein-protein complexes, their corresponding uncomplexed forms and energy calculations we seek to understand the roles of protein-protein interfacial residues in the unbound forms. We show that there are conformationally near invariant and evolutionarily conserved interfacial residues which are rigid and they account for ∼65% of the core interface. Interestingly, some of these residues contribute significantly to the stabilization of the interface structure in the uncomplexed form. Such residues have strong energetic basis to perform dual roles of stabilizing the structure of the uncomplexed form as well as the complex once formed while they maintain their rigid nature throughout. This feature is evolutionarily well conserved at both the structural and sequence levels. We believe this analysis has general bearing in the prediction of interfaces and understanding molecular recognition.

Residue conservation in viral capsid assembly

To evaluate the evolutionary constraints placed on viral proteins by the structure and assembly of the capsid, we calculate Shannon entropies in the aligned sequences of 45 polypeptide chains in 32 icosahedral viruses, and relate these entropies to the residue location in the three-dimensional structure of the capsids. Three categories of residues have entropies lower than the chain average implying that they are better conserved than average: residues that are buried within a subunit (the protein core), residues that contain atoms buried at an interface between subunits (the interface core), and residues that contribute to several such interfaces. The interface core is also conserved in homomeric proteins and in transient protein-protein complexes, which have only one interface whereas capsids have many. In capsids, the subunit interfaces implicate most of the polypeptide chain: on average, 66% of the capsid residues are at an interface, 34% at more than one, and 47% at the interface core. Nevertheless, we observe that the degree of residue conservation can vary widely between interfaces within a capsid and between regions within an interface. The interfaces and regions of interfaces that show a low sequence variability are likely to play major roles in the self-assembly of the capsid, with implications on its mechanism that we discuss taking adeno-associated virus as an example.

Strategies to search and design stabilizers of protein–protein interactions: A feasibility study

Since protein-protein interactions play a pivotal role in the communication on the molecular level in virtually every biological system and process, the search and design for modulators of such interactions is of utmost importance. In recent years many inhibitors for specific protein-protein interactions have been developed, however, in only a few cases, small and druglike molecules are able to interfere in the complex formation of proteins. On the other hand, there are several small molecules known to modulate protein-protein interactions by means of stabilizing an already assembled complex. To achieve this goal, a ligand is binding to a pocket, which is located rim-exposed at the interface of the interacting proteins, for example as the phytotoxin Fusicoccin, which stabilizes the interaction of plant H+-ATPase and 14-3-3 protein by nearly a factor of 100. To suggest alternative leads, we performed a virtual screening campaign to discover new molecules putatively stabilizing this complex. Furthermore, we screen a dataset of 198 transient recognition protein-protein complexes for cavities, which are located rim-exposed at their interfaces. We provide evidence for high similarity between such rim-exposed cavities and usual ligands accommodating active sites of enzymes. This analysis suggests that rim-exposed cavities at protein-protein interfaces are druggable binding sites. Therefore, the principle of stabilizing protein-protein interactions seems to be a promising alternative to the approach of the competitive inhibition of such interactions by small molecules.

Protein−Protein Interactions Studied by EPR Relaxation Measurements: Cytochrome c and Cytochrome c Oxidase

The complex formed between cytochrome c oxidase from Paracoccus denitrificans and its electron-transfer partner cytochrome c has been studied by multi-frequency pulse electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. The dipolar relaxation of a fast-relaxing paramagnetic center induced on a more slowly relaxing center can be used to measure their distance in the range of 1-4 nm. This method has been used here for the first time to study transient protein-protein complex formation, employing soluble fragments for both interacting species. We observed significantly enhanced transversal relaxation of the CuA center in cytochrome c oxidase due to the fast-relaxing iron of cytochrome c upon complex formation. The possibility to measure cytochrome c oxidase in the presence and absence of cytochrome c permitted us to separate the dipolar relaxation from other relaxation contributions. This allowed a quantitative simulation and interpretation of the relaxation data. The specific temperature dependence of the dipolar relaxation together with the high orientational selectivity achieved at high magnetic field values may provide detailed information on distance and relative orientation of the two proteins with respect to each other in the complex. Our experimental results cannot be explained by any single well-defined structure of the complex of cytochrome c oxidase with cytochrome c, but rather suggest that a broad distribution in distances and relative orientations between the two proteins exist within this complex.

4‐Fluoroproline derivative peptides: effect on PPII conformation and SH3 affinity

Eukaryotic signal transduction involves the assembly of transient protein-protein complexes mediated by modular interaction domains. Specific Pro-rich sequences with the consensus core motif PxxP adopt the PPII helix conformation upon binding to SH3 domains. For short Pro-rich peptides, little or no ordered secondary structure is usually observed before binding interactions. The association of a Pro-rich peptide with the SH3 domain involves unfavorable binding entropy due to the loss of rotational freedom on forming the PPII helix. With the aim of stabilizing the PPII helix conformation in the Pro-rich HPK1 decapeptide PPPLPPKPKF (P2), a series of P2 analogues was prepared, in which specific Pro positions were alternatively occupied by 4(S)- or 4(R)-4-fluoro-L-proline. The interactions of these peptides with the SH3 domain of the HPK1-binding partner HS1 were quantitatively analyzed by the NILIA-CD approach. A CD thermal analysis of the P2 analogues was performed to assess their propensity to adopt the PPII helix conformation. Contrary to our expectations, the K(d) values of the analogues were lower than that of the parent peptide P2. These results clearly show that the induction of a stable PPII helix conformation in short Pro-rich peptides is not sufficient to increase their affinity toward the SH3 domain and that the effect of 4-fluoroproline strongly depends on the position of this residue in the sequence and the chirality of the substituent in the pyrrolidine ring.

Solution Structure of the Phosphoryl Transfer Complex between the Cytoplasmic A Domain of the Mannitol Transporter IIMannitol and HPr of the Escherichia coliPhosphotransferase System

The solution structure of the complex between the cytoplasmic A domain (IIA(Mtl)) of the mannitol transporter II(Mannitol) and the histidine-containing phosphocarrier protein (HPr) of the Escherichia coli phosphotransferase system has been solved by NMR, including the use of conjoined rigid body/torsion angle dynamics, and residual dipolar couplings, coupled with cross-validation, to permit accurate orientation of the two proteins. A convex surface on HPr, formed by helices 1 and 2, interacts with a complementary concave depression on the surface of IIA(Mtl) formed by helix 3, portions of helices 2 and 4, and beta-strands 2 and 3. The majority of intermolecular contacts are hydrophobic, with a small number of electrostatic interactions at the periphery of the interface. The active site histidines, His-15 of HPr and His-65 of IIA(Mtl), are in close spatial proximity, and a pentacoordinate phosphoryl transition state can be readily accommodated with no change in protein-protein orientation and only minimal perturbations of the backbone immediately adjacent to the histidines. Comparison with two previously solved structures of complexes of HPr with partner proteins of the phosphotransferase system, the N-terminal domain of enzyme I (EIN) and enzyme IIA(Glucose) (IIA(Glc)), reveals a number of common features despite the fact that EIN, IIA(Glc), and IIA(Mtl) bear no structural resemblance to one another. Thus, entirely different underlying structural elements can form binding surfaces for HPr that are similar in terms of both shape and residue composition. These structural comparisons illustrate the roles of surface and residue complementarity, redundancy, incremental build-up of specificity and conformational side chain plasticity in the formation of transient specific protein-protein complexes in signal transduction pathways.

Transient Kinetics of Intracomplex Electron-Transfer in the Human Cytochrome b5 Reductase-Cytochrome b5 System: NAD + Modulates Protein-Protein Binding and Electron Transfer

Transient kinetics of reduction and interprotein electron transfer in the human cytochrome b 5 reductase-cytochrome b 5 (b5R-b5) system was studied by laser flash photolysis in the presence of 5-deazariboflavin and EDTA at pH 7.0. Flash-induced reduction of the FAD cofactor of b5R by deazariboflavin semiquinone (in the absence of b5) occurred in a rapid second-order reaction ( k 2 = 3.1 × 10 8 M −1 s −1) and resulted in a neutral (blue) FAD semiquinone. The heme of cytochrome b 5 (in the absence of b5R) was also rapidly reduced in this system with k 2 = 3.1 × 10 8 M −1 s −1. When the two proteins were mixed at low ionic strength, a strong complex was formed. Although the heme of complexed b5 could be directly reduced by deazariboflavin semiquinone, the second-order rate constant was nearly an order of magnitude smaller than that of free b5 ( k 2 = 3.4 × 10 7 M −1 s −1). In contrast, access to the FAD of b5R by the external reductant was decreased by considerably more than an order of magnitude ( k 2 < 1 × 10 7 M −1 s −1). When an excess of b5R was titrated with small increments of b5 and then subjected to laser flash photolysis in the presence of deazariboflavin/EDTA, interprotein electron transfer from the b5R FAD semiquinone to the heme of b5 could be observed. At low ionic strength ( I = 16 mM), the reaction showed saturation behavior with respect to the b5 concentration, with a limiting first-order rate constant for interprotein electron transfer k 1 = 375 s −1, and a dissociation constant for protein-protein transient complex formation of approximately 1 μM. The observed rate constants for interprotein electron transfer decreased 23-fold when the ionic strength was increased to 1 M, indicating a plus-minus electrostatic interaction between the two proteins. Saturation kinetics were also observed at I = 56, 96, and 120 mM, with limiting first-order rate constants of 195, 155, and 63 s −1, respectively. In the presence of NAD +, the transient protein-protein complex was stabilized by approximately a factor of two, and limiting first-order rate constants of 360 s −1 were obtained at both I = 56 mM and I = 96 mM and 235 s −1 at I = 120 mM. Thus, NAD + appears to stabilize as well as to optimize the protein-protein complex with respect to electron transfer. Another effect of NAD + is to appreciably slow autoxidation and disproportionation of the FAD semiquinone. Cytochrome b 5 also increases the binding constant for NAD + in the ternary complex.