Synthetic Anion Transporters Research Articles

The Lucigenin Assay: Measuring Anion Transport in Lipid Vesicles

AbstractInvited for this month′s cover are the collaborating groups of the Université libre de Bruxelles and Masaryk University. The cover picture shows liposomes with a fluorescent probe encapsulated to study the transmembrane transport of chloride by synthetic anion transporters via quenching of the fluorescence. More information can be found in the Concept article by Hennie Valkenier and co‐workers.

Anion transporters based on halogen, chalcogen, and pnictogen bonds: towards biological applications.

Motivated by their potential biological applications, anion receptors are increasingly explored as transmembrane transporters for anions. The vast majority of the reported anion transporters rely on hydrogen bonding to interact with the anions. However, in recent decades, halogen, chalcogen, and pnictogen bonding, collectively referred to as sigma-hole interactions, have received increasing attention. Most research efforts on these interactions have focused on crystal engineering, anion sensing, and organocatalysis. In recent years, however, these sigma-hole interactions have also been explored more widely in synthetic anion transporters. This perspective shows why synthetic transporters are promising candidates for biological applications. We provide a comprehensive review of the compounds used to transport anions across membranes, with a particular focus on how the binding atoms and molecular design affect the anion transport activity and selectivity. Few cell studies have been reported for these transporters based on sigma-hole interactions and we highlight the critical need for further biological studies on the toxicity, stability, and deliverability of these compounds to explore their full potential in biological applications, such as the treatment of cystic fibrosis.

Fluorinated tetrapodal anion transporters

Synthetic anion transporters show potential in treating life-threatening diseases like cystic fibrosis and cancer. However, with increasingly complex transporter architectures designed to control anion binding and transport, it is important to consider solubility and deliverability during transporter design. The fluorination of synthetic anion transporters has been shown to tune the transporter lipophilicity, transport rates, and binding strength. In this work, we expand on our previously reported tetrapodal (thio)urea transporters with a series of fluorinated tetrapodal anion transporters. The effects of fluorination on tuning the lipophilicity, solubility, deliverability, and anion transport selectivity of the tetrapodal scaffold were investigated using anion-binding and transport assays. The primary mode of anion transport was H+/X- cotransport, with the most fluorinated tetrathiourea (8) displaying the highest transport activity in the 8-hydroxypyrene-1,3,6-trisulfonic acid (HPTS) assay. Intriguingly, inversion of the transmembrane Cl- vs NO3 - transport selectivity compared with previously reported tripodal (thio)urea transporters was observed under a modified HPTS assay.

Transmembrane Transport of Bicarbonate by Anion Receptors.

The development of synthetic anion transporters is motivated by their potential application as treatment for diseases that originate from deficient anion transport by natural proteins. Transport of bicarbonate is important for crucial biological functions such as respiration and digestion. Despite this biological relevance, bicarbonate transport has not been as widely studied as chloride transport. Herein we present an overview of the synthetic receptors that have been studied as bicarbonate transporters, together with the different assays used to perform transport studies in large unilamellar vesicles. We highlight the most active transporters and comment on the nature of the functional groups present in active and inactive compounds. We also address recent mechanistic studies that have revealed different processes that can lead to net transport of bicarbonate, as well as studies reported in cells and tissues, and comment on the key challenges for the further development of bicarbonate transporters.

Highly Active Halogen Bonding and Chalcogen Bonding Chloride Transporters with Non-Protonophoric Activity.

Synthetic anion transporters show much promise as potential anti‐cancer agents and therapeutics for diseases associated with mis‐regulation of protein anion channels. In such applications high activity and anion selectivity are crucial to overcome competing proton or hydroxide transport which dissipates cellular pH gradients. Here, highly active bidentate halogen bonding and chalcogen bonding anion carriers based on electron deficient iodo‐ and telluromethyl−triazole derivatives are reported. Anion transport experiments in lipid bilayer vesicles reveal record nanomolar chloride transport activity for the bidentate halogen bonding anion carrier, and remarkably high chloride over proton/hydroxide selectivity for the chalcogen bonding anionophore. Computational studies provide further insight into the role of sigma‐hole mediated anion recognition and desolvation at the membrane interface. Comparison with hydrogen bonding analogues demonstrates the importance of employing sigma‐hole donor motifs in synthetic anionophores for achieving both high transport activity and selectivity.

Synthesis and biological activity of squaramido-tethered bisbenzimidazoles as synthetic anion transporters.

A series of squaramido-tethered bisbenzimidazoles were synthesized from the reaction of diethyl squarate with substituted 2-aminomethylbenzimidazoles. These conjugates exhibit moderate binding affinity toward chloride anions. They are able to facilitate the transmembrane transport of chloride anions most probably via an anion exchange process, and tend to be more active at acidic pH than at physiological pH. The viability of these conjugates toward four selected solid tumor cell lines was evaluated using an MTT assay and the results suggest that some of these conjugates exhibit moderate cytotoxicity probably in an apoptotic fashion.

Transmembrane Anion Transport Mediated by Halogen Bonds: Using Off-Center Charges.

Synthetic anion transporters are promising therapeutic agents designed to emulate the specialized role of certain transmembrane proteins that maintain the ion concentration in cells. In the last few years, besides hydrogen bonds and ion pairs, halogen bonds have also been explored to promote the association between the synthetic molecule and the anion and their subsequent transport. This interaction is due to an anisotropic charge distribution on the halogen, and therefore, modeling halogen bonds is not a trivial task using classical force field methods that typically rely on point-charge models.Herein, a computational protocol capable of dealing with halogen bonds is presented. This protocol takes advantage of the addition of anoff-center particle during the charge fitting procedure, and the resulting set of charges can be used along with the classical force field parameters from GAFF or GROMOS 54A7.

Imidazolinium-based Multiblock Amphiphile as Transmembrane Anion Transporter.

Transmembrane anion transport is an important biological process in maintaining cellular functions. Thus, synthetic anion transporters are widely developed for their biological applications. Imidazolinium was introduced as anion recognition site to a multiblock amphiphilic structure that consists of octa(ethylene glycol) and aromatic units. Ion transport assay using halide-sensitive lucigenin and pH-sensitive 8-hydroxypyrene-1,3,6-trisulfonate (HPTS) revealed that imidazolinium-based multiblock amphiphile (IMA) transports anions and showed high selectivity for nitrate, which plays crucial roles in many biological events. Temperature-dependent ion transport assay using 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) indicated that IMA works as a mobile carrier. 1 H NMR titration experiments indicated that the C2 proton of the imidazolinium ring recognizes anions via a (C-H)+ ⋅⋅⋅X- hydrogen bond. Furthermore, all-atom molecular dynamics simulations revealed a dynamic feature of IMA within the membranes during ion transportation.

Tetrapodal Anion Transporters.

Synthetic anion transporters that facilitate chloride transport are promising candidates for channelopathy treatments. However, most anion transporters exhibit an undesired side effect of facilitating proton transport via interacting with fatty acids present in the membrane. To address the limitation, we here report the use of a new tetrapodal scaffold to maximize the selective interaction with spherical chloride over binding the carboxylate headgroup of fatty acids. One of the new transporters demonstrated a high selectivity for chloride uniport over fatty acid-induced proton transport while being >10 times more active in chloride uniport than strapped calixpyrroles that were previously the only class of compounds known to possess similar selectivity properties.

Biological applications of synthetic anion transporters.

The use of synthetic ion transporters for alteration of the concentration of ions across cell membranes has drawn attention from scientists over the last two decades. This ion transport property has been sensibly used to reduce the viability of cancer cells mainly due to the disruption of their ion homeostasis, leading to the perturbation of their abnormal pH gradient. The use of the proanionophore strategy has been recently adopted to increase cellular deliverability and reduce unwanted cytotoxicity towards normal cells. Meanwhile, various anionophores exhibiting non-toxic behavior in epithelial cells have shown a great propensity to be used as a putative treatment for channelopathies like cystic fibrosis. Anionophores with Cl- ion transport mediated antibacterial activities have also been successfully used against clinically relevant bacterial strains, many of which are tolerant towards commercial antibiotics. Recent developments in the chloride ion transport mediated biological activities of anionophores have been mainly discussed in this article. It also highlights other aspects, such as design criteria, targeted delivery options, and others, which can be useful for the further development of selective anionophores for specific biological applications.

Synthetic Anion Transporters as Endoplasmic Reticulum (ER) Stress Inducers.

Cl--ion transporters (2a-2h) were synthesized based on the binding motifs of prodigiosin. Transporter 2e clearly displays Cl--ion transportation activity across both model and live cell membranes. Furthermore, 2e can disrupt Ca2+ homeostasis and increase the intracellular concentration of Ca2+ in the DLD-1 cell. This disruption can lead to Caspase-dependent apoptosis supported by CHOP expression (a marker of ER stress) and the appearance of the cleaved forms of Caspase 3 and PARP.

Voltage‐Switchable HCl Transport Enabled by Lipid Headgroup–Transporter Interactions

AbstractSynthetic anion transporters that facilitate transmembrane H+/Cl− symport (cotransport) have anti‐cancer potential due to their ability to neutralize pH gradients and inhibit autophagy in cells. However, compared to the natural product prodigiosin, synthetic anion transporters have low‐to‐modest H+/Cl− symport activity and their mechanism of action remains less well understood. We report a chloride‐selective tetraurea macrocycle that has a record‐high H+/Cl− symport activity similar to that of prodigiosin and most importantly demonstrates unprecedented voltage‐switchable transport properties that are linked to the lack of uniport activity. By studying the anion binding affinity and transport mechanisms of four other anion transporters, we show that the lack of uniport and voltage‐dependent H+/Cl− symport originate from strong binding to phospholipid headgroups that hampers the diffusion of the free transporters through the membrane, leading to an unusual H+/Cl− symport mechanism that involves only charged species. Our work provides important mechanistic insights into different classes of anion transporters and a new approach to achieve voltage‐switchability in artificial membrane transport systems.

Voltage‐Switchable HCl Transport Enabled by Lipid Headgroup–Transporter Interactions

Synthetic anion transporters that facilitate transmembrane H+ /Cl- symport (cotransport) have anti-cancer potential due to their ability to neutralize pH gradients and inhibit autophagy in cells. However, compared to the natural product prodigiosin, synthetic anion transporters have low-to-modest H+ /Cl- symport activity and their mechanism of action remains less well understood. We report a chloride-selective tetraurea macrocycle that has a record-high H+ /Cl- symport activity similar to that of prodigiosin and most importantly demonstrates unprecedented voltage-switchable transport properties that are linked to the lack of uniport activity. By studying the anion binding affinity and transport mechanisms of four other anion transporters, we show that the lack of uniport and voltage-dependent H+ /Cl- symport originate from strong binding to phospholipid headgroups that hampers the diffusion of the free transporters through the membrane, leading to an unusual H+ /Cl- symport mechanism that involves only charged species. Our work provides important mechanistic insights into different classes of anion transporters and a new approach to achieve voltage-switchability in artificial membrane transport systems.

Selective Alteration of the Root Morphology of Arabidopsis thaliana by Synthetic Anion Transporters (SATs)

Aims: The aim of the study was to determine whether and to what extent any of a family of amphiphilic heptapeptide synthetic anion transporters (SATs) affected the growth or root morphology of Arabidopsis thaliana.
 Study Design: A. thaliana plants were grown from seedlings in PNS media in the absence or presence of one of 21 SATs.
 Place and Duration of Study: Departments of Chemistry & Biochemistry, University of Missouri – St. Louis, 1 University Blvd., St. Louis, MO 63121 U. S. A. The study was conducted 2017-2018.
 Methodology: Twenty one compounds of the form R2N-COCH2YCH2CO-(Aaa)3Pro(Aaa)3-O(CH2)6CH3 were prepared and studied. The amino acids included Ala, Gly, and Ser. R was normal alkyl having 6, 10, 12, or 18 carbons. Y was methylene, oxygen, sulfur, or absent. The PNS media was infused with various concentrations of the SAT and 21 plants in each group were allowed to grow for 11 days. Overall plant growth and root morphology were visualized and/or measured and the results recorded.
 Results: A comparison of primary root length and lateral root number revealed that the greatest alterations in lateral root densities were observed for peptide sequences of the type GGGPSGS, whether or not serine was protected by t-butyl. Differences were also observed for these peptide sequences according to the identity of Y in the ~COCH2YCH2CO~ chain.
 Conclusion: The presence of serine’s oxygen atoms on the C-terminal side of the heptapeptide interact with Cl¯ leading to a change in ion concentrations and alterations in primary root lengths and lateral root densities.

New Anionophores and Insights into Ion-Transport-Induced Cancer Cell Death

In this issue of Chem, Pellois, Gabbai, and colleagues introduce pnictogenium cations as useful transmembrane anion transporters, and Gale, Sessler, Injae, and co-workers provide insights into the cellular mechanism elicited by some of these compounds, leading to the induction of apoptosis in cancer cells.

Determinants of Ion-Transporter Cancer Cell Death

Recently, we showed that synthetic anion transporters DSC4P-1 and SA-3 had activity related to cancer cell death. They were found to increase intracellular chloride and sodium ion concentrations. They were also found to induce apoptosis (DSC4P-1) and both induce apoptosis and inhibit autophagy (SA-3). However, determinants underlying these phenomenological findings were not elucidated. The absence of mechanistic understanding has limited the development of yet-improved systems. Here, we show that three synthetic anion transporters, DSC4P-1, SA-3, and 8FC4P, induce osmotic stress in cells by increasing intracellular ion concentrations. This triggers the generation of reactive oxygen species via a sequential process and promotes caspase-dependent apoptosis. In addition, two of the transporters, SA-3 and 8FC4P, induce autophagy by increasing the cytosolic calcium ion concentration promoted by osmotic stress. However, they eventually inhibit the autophagy process as a result of their ability to disrupt lysosome function through a transporter-mediated decrease in a lysosomal chloride ion concentration and an increase in the lysosomal pH.

Tailoring the Binding Properties of Phosphazane Anion Receptors and Transporters.

The binding and sensing of anions is an important cross-disciplinary field, which impacts broad areas such as biology, supramolecular chemistry and catalysis. To date, however, this area has been dominated by organic architectures which function as H-bonding, anion receptor molecules. Inorganic anion receptors have largely been based on Lewis acidic metals, with very few examples of H-bonding counterparts of organic systems having been systematically studied. This paper develops strategies for enhancing the anion binding properties of phosphazanes of the type [(RNH)(E)P(μ-N tBu)]2 (E = O, S, Se) which are bench-stable, H-bond receptors that can be regarded as inorganic analogues of squaramides (a key class of organic anion receptor). The distinct advantages of these inorganic receptors over organic counterparts is the ease by which their functionality and electronic character can be altered (by means of the R group, chalcogenide, or metal present). Se substitution at the P centers, the presence of electron-withdrawing R groups, and metal coordination to the soft donor centers can be used to modulate and enhance anion binding. The water stability and superior anion binding properties of the seleno-phosph(V)azanes give them applications as synthetic anion transporters through phospholipid layers.

Anion carriers as potential treatments for cystic fibrosis: transport in cystic fibrosis cells, and additivity to channel-targeting drugs.

Defective anion transport is a hallmark of the genetic disease cystic fibrosis (CF). One approach to restore anion transport to CF cells utilises alternative pathways for transmembrane anion transport, including artificial anion carriers (anionophores). Here, we screened 22 anionophores for biological activity using fluorescence emission from the halide-sensitive yellow fluorescent protein. Three compounds possessed anion transport activity similar to or greater than that of a bis-(p-nitrophenyl)ureidodecalin previously shown to have promising biological activity. Anion transport by these anionophores was concentration-dependent and persistent. All four anionophores mediated anion transport in CF cells, and their activity was additive to rescue of the predominant disease-causing variant F508del-CFTR using the clinically-licensed drugs lumacaftor and ivacaftor. Toxicity was variable but minimal at the lower end. The results provide further evidence that anionophores, by themselves or together with other treatments that restore anion transport, offer a potential therapeutic strategy for CF.

Fluorinated Bambusurils as Highly Effective and Selective Transmembrane Cl−/HCO3− Antiporters

Summary The exchange of chloride and bicarbonate across lipid bilayers is an important biological process. Synthetic molecules can act as mobile carriers for these anions, although most show little selectivity. Here we report on three bambus[6]uril macrocycles functionalized with fluorinated benzyl groups, which are able to exchange Cl− and HCO3− efficiently. Remarkably, rates for Cl−/NO3− exchange are two orders of magnitude lower. The higher rates of Cl−/HCO3− transport can be explained by the ability of the bambusurils to complex Cl− and HCO3− simultaneously, facilitating their exchange at the bilayer interface. Furthermore, the exceptionally high affinity and selectivity of these systems for NO3− appear to contribute to the poor Cl−/NO3− exchange. This work not only demonstrates the importance of anion binding characteristics on anion transport but also the potential relevance of bambusurils for anion transport applications considering the high rate observed for Cl−/HCO3− exchange.

Diphenylethylenediamine-Based Potent Anionophores: Transmembrane Chloride Ion Transport and Apoptosis Inducing Activities.

Synthetic anion transporters have been recognized as one of the potential therapeutic agents for the treatment of diseases including cystic fibrosis, myotonia, and epilepsy that originate due to the malfunctioning of natural Cl- ion transport systems. Recent studies showed that the synthetic Cl- ion transporters can also disrupt cellular ion-homeostasis and induce apoptosis in cancer cell lines, leading to a revived attention for synthetic Cl- ion transporters. Herein, we report the development of conformationally controlled 1,2-diphenylethylenediamine-based bis(thiourea) derivatives as a new class of selective Cl- ion carrier. The strong Cl- ion binding properties ( Kd = 3.87-6.66 mM) of the bis(thiourea) derivatives of diamine-based compounds correlate well with their transmembrane anion transport activities (EC50 = 2.09-4.15 nM). The transport of Cl- ions via Cl-/NO3- antiport mechanism was confirmed for the most active molecule. Perturbation of Cl- ion homeostasis by this anion carrier induces cell death by promoting the caspase-mediated intrinsic pathway of apoptosis.