SUMO E1 Research Articles

Discovery of a First-In-Class Covalent Allosteric Inhibitor of SUMO E1 Activating Enzyme

SUMOylation is a post-translational modification with important roles in normal physiology and whose dysregulation is associated with human diseases. In this issue of Cell Chemical Biology, Li etal. (2019) describe a covalent, allosteric inhibitor of the SUMO E1 enzyme and demonstrate its anti-tumor activity in preclinical models of colorectal cancer.

Molecular mechanism of a covalent allosteric inhibitor of SUMO E1 activating enzyme

E1 enzymes activate ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like modifiers (Ubls) in the first step of Ub/Ubl conjugation cascades and represent potential targets for therapeutic intervention in cancer and other life-threatening diseases. Here, we report the crystal structure of the E1 enzyme for the Ubl SUMO in complex with a recently discovered and highly specific covalent allosteric inhibitor (COH000). The structure reveals that COH000 targets a cryptic pocket distinct from the active site that is completely buried in all previous SUMO E1 structures and that COH000 binding to SUMO E1 is accompanied by a network of structural changes that altogether lock the enzyme in a previously unobserved inactive conformation. These structural changes include disassembly of the active site and a 180° rotation of the catalytic cysteine-containing SCCH domain, relative to conformational snapshots of SUMO E1 poised to catalyze adenylation. Altogether, our study provides a molecular basis for the inhibitory mechanism of COH000 and its SUMO E1 specificity, and also establishes a framework for potential development of molecules targeting E1 enzymes for other Ubls at a cryptic allosteric site.

PIAS1 protects against myocardial ischemia-reperfusion injury by stimulating PPAR\u03b3 SUMOylation

BackgroundMyocardial ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI) has become one of the most serious complications after reperfusion therapy in patients with acute myocardial infarction. Small ubiquitin-like modification (SUMOylation) is a reversible process, including SUMO E1-, E2-, and E3-mediated SUMOylation and SUMO-specific protease-mediated deSUMOylation, with the latter having been shown to play a vital role in myocardial IRI previously. However, little is known about the function and regulation of SUMO E3 ligases in myocardial IRI.ResultsIn this study, we found dramatically decreased expression of PIAS1 after ischemia/reperfusion (I/R) in mouse myocardium and H9C2 cells. PIAS1 deficiency aggravated apoptosis and inflammation of cardiomyocytes via activating the NF-κB pathway after I/R. Mechanistically, we identified PIAS1 as a specific E3 ligase for PPARγ SUMOylation. Moreover, H9C2 cells treated with hypoxia/reoxygenation (H/R) displayed reduced PPARγ SUMOylation as a result of down-regulated PIAS1, and act an anti-apoptotic and anti-inflammatory function through repressing NF-κB activity. Finally, overexpression of PIAS1 in H9C2 cells could remarkably ameliorate I/R injury.ConclusionsCollectively, our findings demonstrate the crucial role of PIAS1-mediated PPARγ SUMOylation in protecting against myocardial IRI.

Shigella entry unveils a calcium/calpain-dependent mechanism for inhibiting sumoylation.

Disruption of the sumoylation/desumoylation equilibrium is associated with several disease states such as cancer and infections, however the mechanisms regulating the global SUMO balance remain poorly defined. Here, we show that infection by Shigella flexneri, the causative agent of human bacillary dysentery, switches off host sumoylation during epithelial cell infection in vitro and in vivo and that this effect is mainly mediated by a calcium/calpain-induced cleavage of the SUMO E1 enzyme SAE2, thus leading to sumoylation inhibition. Furthermore, we describe a mechanism by which Shigella promotes its own invasion by altering the sumoylation state of RhoGDIα, a master negative regulator of RhoGTPase activity and actin polymerization. Together, our data suggest that SUMO modification is essential to restrain pathogenic bacterial entry by limiting cytoskeletal rearrangement induced by bacterial effectors. Moreover, these findings identify calcium-activated calpains as powerful modulators of cellular sumoylation levels with potentially broad implications in several physiological and pathological situations.

SUMOylation and ubiquitination reciprocally regulate α-synuclein degradation and pathological aggregation.

α-Synuclein accumulation is a pathological hallmark of Parkinson's disease (PD). Ubiquitinated α-synuclein is targeted to proteasomal or lysosomal degradation. Here, we identify SUMOylation as a major mechanism that counteracts ubiquitination by different E3 ubiquitin ligases and regulates α-synuclein degradation. We report that PIAS2 promotes SUMOylation of α-synuclein, leading to a decrease in α-synuclein ubiquitination by SIAH and Nedd4 ubiquitin ligases, and causing its accumulation and aggregation into inclusions. This was associated with an increase in α-synuclein release from the cells. A SUMO E1 inhibitor, ginkgolic acid, decreases α-synuclein levels by relieving the inhibition exerted on α-synuclein proteasomal degradation. α-Synuclein disease mutants are more SUMOylated compared with the wild-type protein, and this is associated with increased aggregation and inclusion formation. We detected a marked increase in PIAS2 expression along with SUMOylated α-synuclein in PD brains, providing a causal mechanism underlying the up-regulation of α-synuclein SUMOylation in the disease. We also found a significant proportion of Lewy bodies in nigral neurons containing SUMO1 and PIAS2. Our observations suggest that SUMOylation of α-synuclein by PIAS2 promotes α-synuclein aggregation by two mutually reinforcing mechanisms. First, it has a direct proaggregatory effect on α-synuclein. Second, SUMOylation facilitates α-synuclein aggregation by blocking its ubiquitin-dependent degradation pathways and promoting its accumulation. Therefore, inhibitors of α-synuclein SUMOylation provide a strategy to reduce α-synuclein levels and possibly aggregation in PD.

Role of SUMO activating enzyme in cancer stem cell maintenance and self-renewal.

Cancer stem cells (CSCs) have key roles in treatment resistance, tumour metastasis and relapse. Using colorectal cancer (CC) cell lines, patient-derived xenograft (PDX) tissues and patient tissues, here we report that CC CSCs, which resist chemoradiation, have higher SUMO activating enzyme (E1) and global SUMOylation levels than non-CSCs. Knockdown of SUMO E1 or SUMO conjugating enzyme (E2) inhibits CC CSC maintenance and self-renewal, while overexpression of SUMO E1 or E2 increases CC cell stemness. We found that SUMOylation regulates CSCs through Oct-1, a transcription factor for aldehyde dehydrogenases (ALDHs). ALDH activity is not only a marker for CSCs but also important in CSC biology. SUMO does not modify Oct-1 directly, but regulates the expression of TRIM21 that enhances Oct-1 ubiquitination and, consequently, reducing Oct-1 stability. In summary, our findings suggest that SUMOylation could be a target to inhibit CSCs and ultimately to reduce treatment resistance, tumour metastasis and relapse.

Small-molecule activation of SERCA2a SUMOylation for the treatment of heart failure.

Decreased activity and expression of the cardiac sarcoplasmic reticulum calcium ATPase (SERCA2a), a critical pump regulating calcium cycling in cardiomyocyte, are hallmarks of heart failure. We have previously described a role for the small ubiquitin-like modifier type 1 (SUMO-1) as a regulator of SERCA2a and have shown that gene transfer of SUMO-1 in rodents and large animal models of heart failure restores cardiac function. Here, we identify and characterize a small molecule, N106, which increases SUMOylation of SERCA2a. This compound directly activates the SUMO-activating enzyme, E1 ligase, and triggers intrinsic SUMOylation of SERCA2a. We identify a pocket on SUMO E1 likely to be responsible for N106's effect. N106 treatment increases contractile properties of cultured rat cardiomyocytes and significantly improves ventricular function in mice with heart failure. This first-in-class small-molecule activator targeting SERCA2a SUMOylation may serve as a potential therapeutic strategy for treatment of heart failure.

Determination of SUMO1 and ATP affinity for the SUMO E1by quantitative FRET technology.

SUMOylation plays important roles in many key physiological and pathological processes. The SUMOylation cascade involves a heterodimer of activating enzyme, E1 (Aos1/Uba2); a conjugating enzyme, E2 (Ubc9); and many ligase enzymes, E3. Focusing on the activation step of the SUMOylation process, we examined the interaction of E1 with its substrates. Previous studies reported the Km of E1 enzymes in ubiquitin and other ubiquitin-like pathways, but the Km of the SUMO paralogs (SUMO2 and SUMO3) is unknown. Here, by using quantitative FRET to measure the SUMO E1 enzyme kinetics of SUMO1, 2, and 3 and ATP under steady state conditions, we found that the enzyme kinetics from the quantitative FRET method are comparable to those from conventional radioactive assays. Additionally, the kinetic constants, Km , of SUMO2 (3.418 ± 0.9131 μM) and SUMO3 (2.764 ± 0.75 μM) [FW1] are approximately four to five times higher than that of SUMO1 Km (0.7458 ± 0.1105 μM). These results demonstrate the advantages of FRET technology for determining Km , including the ability to monitor reaction progress in real-time with high-throughput and high-sensitivity in an environmentally friendly manner. The processes discussed here extend the utility of quantitative FRET in characterizing protein-protein interactions and enzyme kinetics.

Abstract 21: Quantitative FRET technology for SUMOylation cascade and high-throughput screening assay for SUMOylation inhibitor in cancer drug discovery

Abstract The ubiquitin–proteasome system and ubiquitin-like protein pathways, such as SUMOylation, are critical in protein homeostasis and activities in vivo and are emerging as a new strategy to treat many acute and chronic human diseases, such as cancers. Although various kinase inhibitors have been developed as target-based therapy, solid tumors are still challenges in clinical therapy because various resistant are developed after kinase inhibitor treatments, and therapeutic agents with novel mechanisms are urgently needed. SUMO has been shown to modify various critical proteins, such as p53, MDM2, Estrogen receptor and androgen receptors. More recently, a genome-wide siRNA screening shown that inhibition of SUMO E1 ligases can lead to synergistically lethality of c-Myc overexpressed breast cancer cells. However, so far, specific inhibitor of SUMOylation is still not available for the community. Fig. 1. SUMOylation in human diseases and quantitative systems biology approach for basic and translational research of SUMOylation. We developed a novel quantitative Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) technology platform for both basic kinetics parameter determinations and high-through screening(HTS) assays for SUMOylation cascade. The novel theoretical and experimental procedures for protein interactions affinity(Kd) determinations in the SUMOylation cascade, including the interaction between SUMO1 and its E2 ligase, Ubc9, E1 heterodimers(Aos1 and Uba2), E1 and E2 interactions(Uba2 and Ubc9), and E2 and substrate interactions(Ubc9 and RanGap1c) and protease kinetics, Kcat/KM of SENP1 endopeptidase activity have been developed in a systems biology manner. The data are in good agreement with traditional methods. Multiple FRET-based HTS assays have also been developed and HTS campaigns have led to very promising hit that can preferentially kill Non-small cell lung cancer cells. The novel SUMOylation inhibitor can be used for cancer treatments by synergistically lethality strategy. Citation Format: Jiayu Liao, Hilda Wiryawan, Yang Li, Yang Song, Yan Liu, Jiacong You, Ling Jiang, Harbani Kaur Malik, Amanda N. Saavedra, Sophie Qu. Quantitative FRET technology for SUMOylation cascade and high-throughput screening assay for SUMOylation inhibitor in cancer drug discovery. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference: Cancer Susceptibility and Cancer Susceptibility Syndromes; Jan 29-Feb 1, 2014; San Diego, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2014;74(23 Suppl):Abstract nr 21. doi:10.1158/1538-7445.CANSUSC14-21

Identification of quinazolinyloxy biaryl urea as a new class of SUMO activating enzyme 1 inhibitors

SUMO activating enzyme 1 (SUMO E1) is the first enzyme in sumoylation pathway and an important cancer drug target. However, only a few inhibitors were reported up to now that includes three natural products, semi-synthetic protein inhibitors and one AMP mimic. Here, we report the identification of quinazolinyloxy biaryl urea as a new class of SUMO E1 inhibitors. The most active compound of this class inhibited the in vitro sumoylation with an IC50 of 13.4μM. This compound inhibits sumoylation by blocking the formation of SUMOE1-SUMO thioester intermediate. The biological activity of the most active compound is comparable to previously reported inhibitors with properties suitable for medicinal chemistry optimization for potency and druggability.

Abstract A39: Quantitative FRET technology for SUMOylation cascade and high-throughput screening assay for SUMOylation inhibitor in cancer drug discovery

Abstract The ubiquitin—proteasome system and ubiquitin-like protein pathways, such as SUMOylation, are critical in protein homeostasis and activities in vivo and are emerging as a new strategy to treat many acute and chronic human diseases, such as cancers. Although various kinase inhibitors have been developed as target-based therapy, solid tumors are still challenges in clinical therapy because various resistant are developed after kinase inhibitor treatments, and therapeutic agents with novel mechanisms are urgently needed. SUMO has been shown to modify various critical proteins, such as p53, MDM2, Estrogen receptor and androgen receptors. More recently, a genome-wide siRNA screening shown that inhibition of SUMO E1 ligases can lead to synergistically lethality of c-Myc overexpressed breast cancer cells. However, so far, specific inhibitor of SUMOylation is still not available for the scientific or pharmaceutical communities. We developed a novel quantitative Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) technology platform for both basic kinetics parameter determinations and high-through screening (HTS) assays for SUMOylation cascade. The novel theoretical and experimental procedures for protein interactions affinity (Kd) determinations in the SUMOylation cascade, including the interaction between SUMO1 and its E2 ligase, Ubc9, E1 heterodimers(Aos1 and Uba2), E1 and E2 interactions(Uba2 and Ubc9), and E2 and substrate interactions(Ubc9 and RanGap1c) and protease kinetics, Kcat/KM of SENP1 endopeptidase activity have been developed in a systems biology manner. The data are in good agreement with traditional methods. Multiple FRET-based HTS assays have also been developed and HTS campaigns have led to very promising hit that can preferentially kill Non-small cell lung cancer cells. The novel SUMOylation inhibitor can be used for cancer treatments by synergistically lethality strategy. Note: This abstract was not presented at the conference. Citation Format: Jiayu Liao, Hilda Wiryawan, Yang Song, Yan Liu, Ling Jiang, Harbani Kaur Malik, Amanda N. Saaredra. Quantitative FRET technology for SUMOylation cascade and high-throughput screening assay for SUMOylation inhibitor in cancer drug discovery. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Precision Medicine Series: Synthetic Lethal Approaches to Cancer Vulnerabilities; May 17-20, 2013; Bellevue, WA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Mol Cancer Ther 2013;12(5 Suppl):Abstract nr A39.

Identification of Sumoylation Activating Enzyme 1 Inhibitors by Structure-Based Virtual Screening

SUMO activating enzyme 1 (SUMO E1) is responsible for the activation of SUMO in the first step of the sumoylation cascade. SUMO E1 is linked to many human diseases including cancer, thus making it a potential therapeutic target. There are few reported SUMO E1 inhibitors including several natural products. To identify small molecule inhibitors of SUMO E1 with better drug-like properties for potential therapeutic studies, we have used structure-based virtual screening to identify hits from the Maybridge small molecule library for biological assay. Our virtual screening protocol involves fast docking of the entire small molecule library with rigid protein and ligands followed by redocking of top hits using a method that incorporates both ligand and protein flexibility. Subsequently, the top-ranking compounds were prioritized using the molecular dynamics simulation-based binding free energy calculation. Out of 24 compounds that were acquired and tested using in vitro sumoylation assay, four of them showed more than 85% inhibition of sumoylation with the most active compound showing an IC50 of 14.4 μM. A similarity search with the most active compound in the ZINC database has identified three more compounds with improved potency. These compounds share a common phenyl urea scaffold and have been confirmed to inhibit SUMO E1 by in vitro SUMO-1 thioester bond formation assay. Our study suggests that these phenyl urea compounds could be used as a starting point for the development of novel therapeutic agents.

E2‐binding surface on Uba3 β‐grasp domain undergoes a conformational transition

The covalent attachment of ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like (Ubl) proteins to various eukaryotic targets plays critical roles in regulating numerous cellular processes. E1-activating enzymes are critical, because they catalyze activation of their cognate Ub/Ubl protein and are responsible for its transfer to the correct E2-conjugating enzyme(s). The activating enzyme for neural-precursor-cell-expressed developmentally downregulated 8 (NEDD8) is a heterodimer composed of APPBP1 and Uba3 subunits. The carboxyl terminal ubiquitin-like β-grasp domain of human Uba3 (Uba3-βGD) has been suggested as a key E2-binding site defining E2 specificity. In crystal structures of free E1 and the NEDD8-E1 complex, the E2-binding surface on the domain was missing from the electron density. However, when complexed with various E2s, this missing segment adopts a kinked α-helix. Here, we demonstrate that Uba3-βGD is an independently folded domain in solution and that residues involved in E2 binding are absent from the NMR spectrum, indicating that the E2-binding surface on Uba3-βGD interconverts between multiple conformations, analogous to a similar conformational transition observed in the E2-binding surface of SUMO E1. These results suggest that access to multiple conformational substates is an important feature of the E1-E2 interaction.

Largazole and Its Derivatives Selectively Inhibit Ubiquitin Activating Enzyme (E1)

Protein ubiquitination plays an important role in the regulation of almost every aspect of eukaryotic cellular function; therefore, its destabilization is often observed in most human diseases and cancers. Consequently, developing inhibitors of the ubiquitination system for the treatment of cancer has been a recent area of interest. Currently, only a few classes of compounds have been discovered to inhibit the ubiquitin-activating enzyme (E1) and only one class is relatively selective in E1 inhibition in cells. We now report that Largazole and its ester and ketone analogs selectively inhibit ubiquitin conjugation to p27Kip1 and TRF1 in vitro. The inhibitory activity of these small molecules on ubiquitin conjugation has been traced to their inhibition of the ubiquitin E1 enzyme. To further dissect the mechanism of E1 inhibition, we analyzed the effects of these inhibitors on each of the two steps of E1 activation. We show that Largazole and its derivatives specifically inhibit the adenylation step of the E1 reaction while having no effect on thioester bond formation between ubiquitin and E1. E1 inhibition appears to be specific to human E1 as Largazole ketone fails to inhibit the activation of Uba1p, a homolog of E1 in Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Moreover, Largazole analogs do not significantly inhibit SUMO E1. Thus, Largazole and select analogs are a novel class of ubiquitin E1 inhibitors and valuable tools for studying ubiquitination in vitro. This class of compounds could be further developed and potentially be a useful tool in cells.

The Defective Nuclear Lamina in Hutchinson-Gilford Progeria Syndrome Disrupts the Nucleocytoplasmic Ran Gradient and Inhibits Nuclear Localization of Ubc9

The mutant form of lamin A responsible for the premature aging disease Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome (termed progerin) acts as a dominant negative protein that changes the structure of the nuclear lamina. How the perturbation of the nuclear lamina in progeria is transduced into cellular changes is undefined. Using patient fibroblasts and a variety of cell-based assays, we determined that progerin expression in Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome inhibits the nucleocytoplasmic transport of several factors with key roles in nuclear function. We found that progerin reduces the nuclear/cytoplasmic concentration of the Ran GTPase and inhibits the nuclear localization of Ubc9, the sole E2 for SUMOylation, and of TPR, the nucleoporin that forms the basket on the nuclear side of the nuclear pore complex. Forcing the nuclear localization of Ubc9 in progerin-expressing cells rescues the Ran gradient and TPR import, indicating that these pathways are linked. Reducing nuclear SUMOylation decreases the nuclear mobility of the Ran nucleotide exchange factor RCC1 in vivo, and the addition of SUMO E1 and E2 promotes the dissociation of RCC1 and Ran from chromatin in vitro. Our data suggest that the cellular effects of progerin are transduced, at least in part, through reduced function of the Ran GTPase and SUMOylation pathways.

Role of the Zn2+ Motif of E1 in SUMO Adenylation

Post-translational modifications by ubiquitin-like proteins are among the most important mechanisms for regulating a wide variety of cellular functions. In these modifications an E1 enzyme activates each ubiquitin-like protein (Ubl) by adenylation of the Ubl C-terminal COOH group and then forms a thioester bond with the adenylated C-terminal COOH group of the Ubl. Previous x-ray crystallography studies revealed a conserved zinc motif in the SUMO and NEDD8 E1; however, the function of this Zn(2+) motif is unclear. In this study, using quantitative ATP:PPi isotope exchange assays in combination with site-directed mutagenesis, we show that the conserved Zn(2+) motif in the SUMO E1 is important for SUMO adenylation and is critical for the E1 pseudo-ordered substrate binding mechanism. Furthermore, Zn(2+) motif mutants showed significantly reduced k(cat) values for ATP:PPi isotope exchange assays, suggesting that the Zn(2+) motif is important in binding and preventing SUMO adenylate from dissociating from E1 before formation of the thioester conjugate. Because the Zn(2+) motif is located in a cross-over loop that is known to have conformational flexibility, the results described here suggest that this cross-over loop interacts with Ubl in the multistep, dynamic process of Ubl activation by E1s.

And Yet It Moves: Active Site Remodeling in the SUMO E1

The activation of ubiquitin and ubiquin-like proteins is catalyzed by E1 enzymes via consecutive adenylation and thioesterification reactions involving two apparently distant active sites. Olsen et al. (2010) uncover dramatic conformational changes in the SUMO E1 that spatially merge the adenylation and thioesterification active sites, including a > 30 A movement of the active site cysteine.

Active site remodelling accompanies thioester bond formation in the SUMO E1

E1 enzymes activate ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like (Ubl) proteins in two steps by carboxy-terminal adenylation and thioester bond formation to a conserved catalytic cysteine in the E1 Cys domain. The structural basis for these intermediates remains unknown. Here we report crystal structures for human SUMO E1 in complex with SUMO adenylate and tetrahedral intermediate analogs at 2.45 Å and 2.6 Å, respectively. These structures show that side chain contacts to ATP·Mg are released after adenylation to facilitate a 130 degree rotation of the Cys domain during thioester bond formation that is accompanied by remodeling of key structural elements including the helix that contains the E1 catalytic cysteine, the cross-over and re-entry loops, and refolding of two helices that are required for adenylation. These changes displace side chains required for adenylation with side chains required for thioester bond formation. Mutational and biochemical analyses suggest these mechanisms are conserved in other E1s.

Transformative encounters

Researchers have met the challenge of capturing transient states of the SUMO E1 activating enzyme. Their pictures show radically different crystal structures for two of the steps in this enzyme's activity.

Designed Semisynthetic Protein Inhibitors of Ub/Ubl E1 Activating Enzymes

Semisynthetic, mechanism-based protein inhibitors of ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like modifier (Ubl) activating enzymes (E1s) have been developed to target E1-catalyzed adenylation and thioesterification of the Ub/Ubl C-terminus during the processes of protein SUMOylation and ubiquitination. The inhibitors were generated by intein-mediated expressed protein ligation using a truncated Ub/Ubl protein (SUMO residues 1-94; Ub residues 1-71) with a C-terminal thioester and synthetic tripeptides having a C-terminal adenosine analogue and an N-terminal cysteine residue. SUMO-AMSN (4a) and Ub-AMSN (4b) contain a sulfamide group as a nonhydrolyzable mimic of the phosphate group in the cognate Ub/Ubl-AMP adenylate intermediate in the first half-reaction, and these constructs selectively inhibit SUMO E1 and Ub E1, respectively, in a dose-dependent manner. SUMO-AVSN (5a) and Ub-AVSN (5b) contain an electrophilic vinyl sulfonamide designed to trap the incoming E1 cysteine nucleophile (Uba2 Cys173 in SUMO E1; Uba1 Cys593 in Ub E1) in the second half-reaction, and these constructs selectively, covalently, and stably cross-link to SUMO E1 and Ub E1, respectively, in a cysteine nucleophile-dependent manner. These inhibitors are powerful tools to probe outstanding mechanistic questions in E1 function and can also be used to study the biological functions of E1 enzymes.