To the Editor: In their recent article, Managing chronic headaches in the clinic (Int J Clin Pract 2004; 58(12):1142–51), Dowson et al. suggest that some types of headaches may not be well recognized or well treated. They discuss management algorithms, and state that ‘principles can be customized to the headache subtype by the selection of appropriate therapies’. Successful personalized treatment is a highly desirable, attainable goal that is dependent on accurate evaluation of the problem. Engineers know that the type of a problem's source predicts its appropriate type of solution: chemical problems respond best to chemical solutions, and mechanical problems respond best to mechanical solutions. Many chronic daily headache (CDH) cases have a mechanical source, and as such, cannot be treated effectively with biochemical medications. Therefore, an effective management algorithm includes the directive: obtain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of CDH patients to identify treatable structural causes. Case in point: since 1999, with the publication of ‘Chiari 1 malformation redefined: clinical and radiographic findings for 364 symptomatic patients’ (Neurosurgery 1999; 44(5): 1005–17), a landmark study by Milhorat et al., it has become very clear that many chronic headaches are the result of compression of the hindbrain. A volumetrically small posterior fossa crowded with a normal-sized brain restricts cerebrospinal fluid flow dynamics, as measurable by both cine MRI and colour Doppler ultrasonography (CDU). Patients with such flow restrictions and tissue compression suffer from an increased intracranial pressure, and from impaired function of affected, compressed brain parts, most notably the cerebellum, occipital lobe and brainstem. (Symptoms number into the several dozen.) Additionally, many of these patients also develop subarachnoid adhesions and abnormal cranial vasculature, and a smaller subset has tonsils that are wrapped around or tethered to the brainstem or spinal cord. Hydrocephalus is not required for the diagnosis, and, in fact, is less common than other equally symptomatic manifestations. In the US, between 200,000 and 2 million people suffer from this clearly mechanical cause of CDH. The vast majority of them are undiagnosed for months or years, and typically are misdiagnosed with migraine, tension headaches, multiple sclerosis, lupus, fibromyalgia or psychiatric disturbances. This would not happen if more primary care physicians, neurologists and pain specialists were very familiar with the devastating manifestations of mechanical hindbrain compression. The treatment for severely symptomatic posterior fossa compression is physical removal of the obstruction(s), creation of adequate space for the brain and restoration of proper CSF flow dynamics. This is accomplished surgically through the widening of the cranial–cervical junction, construction of artificial cisterna magna with attention paid to establishing a 3–5 cm/second bidirectional CSF flow at the cervicomedullary junction, and a collection volume of 8–10 cc of CSF in the new cisterna magna. The recent introduction of the intraoperative use of CDU has made this feat possible and provable. See the article ‘Tailored operative technique for Chiari type I malformation using intraoperative colour Doppler ultrasonography’ (Neurosurgery 2003; 53(4): 899–906). In addition, see http://www.thechiariinstitute.com/chiari_techniques.html. In future explorations within the realm of chronic daily headache, we hope that primary care physicians, neurologists and pain specialists will join forces with their equally dedicated counterparts in the neurosurgical world, and offer a complete picture of possible causes and matching solutions to the many headache sufferers who cross their doorsteps.
Read full abstract