The ascriptive properties of and sex in structuring the formation of status aspirations have recently been analyzed and typically reveal that models do not work for blacks as compared to whites. A recent interpretation, termed here the race convergence hypothesis, suggests that gross SES differentials between races found in most samples yield the greater advantages observed for whites, and that blacks whose situation most closely approximates that of whites will construct aspirations and reach attainments in a similar manner as whites. Using data collected in 1975 from a sample where gross differences in SES are reduced by design, the present analysis assesses this hypothesis for high school students of low socioeconomic background. The most general findings are that many differentials in the aspiration-formation process disappear, and even reverse, at this level of the socioeconomic distribution. Where differences in status origins are nil, blacks, rather than whites, enjoy parental status advantages in educational decisions. Blacks are encouraged for further schooling by parents on the basis of performance in school as much as are whites. The socialization model generally yields equal predictive power for both races, and sex differences reported elsewhere are not as pronounced. The hypothesis is moderately supported.
Read full abstract