Reviewed by: International Human Rights: A Survey by Cher Weixia Chen & Alison Dundes Renteln Siobhán McInerney-Lankford (bio) Cher Weixia Chen & Alison Dundes Renteln, International Human Rights: A Survey (Cambridge University Press 2022), ISBN 9781108484865, 590 pages. The term “tour de force” is overused, but in the case of Chen and Renteln’s International Human Rights: A Survey, it is an entirely appropriate description of the work. The book delivers on its title: it provides an incisive and thoroughly modern account of international human rights today. It is an impressive work in both its breadth and depth, charting the outer boundaries of international human rights with respect to both what is covered, how it is enforced, and the manner in which it is studied. It offers a comprehensive resource on all aspects of the international human rights framework, covering substantive, procedural, and cultural perspectives. It is remarkable both in the detail and analytical rigor it brings to the subject, tackling the normative architecture, the contextual dimensions, and the cultural complexities and controversies, as well as a thoroughgoing analysis of the institutions, processes, and actors whose purpose is to uphold and enforce human rights law. The Survey draws from a broad range of regional contexts and considers legal provisions and practice at the international, regional, domestic, and local levels. Although clearly motivated by a deep commitment to human rights, Chen and Renteln’s work doesn’t read as pure advocacy. It is written in a sophisticated yet accessible style and handles controversial issues with sensitivity and subtlety. It maintains a tone that is critical while remaining balanced and steadfastly hopeful. In terms of methodological approach, it goes beyond the standard legal analysis of human rights, to embrace perspectives from other disciplines, including moral philosophy, history, anthropology, and sociology. While clearly rooted in the normative foundations of international human rights and providing a thorough analysis of international human rights law, it adopts a confident interdisciplinary approach. This is particularly welcome since human rights legal scholarship has [End Page 342] been critiqued for being insufficiently concerned with methodology, metrics, and impacts. The Survey appears at a crucial time when the COVID-19 pandemic has created new and compounded vulnerabilities for many groups and when the international rule of law—upon which human rights depends—is under sustained threat, particularly with the ongoing war in Ukraine. In these respects, it both captures the Zeitgeist of international human rights, reflecting on its most profound challenges, as well as its most important contributions. A unique feature of international human rights law as a special regime of public international law is that it introduces legal obligations that operate both horizontally (between states parties) and vertically (between the state party and its citizens). That vertical application introduces a particular type of legal accountability between states parties as duty-bearers and citizens as rights-holders. That feature permits international scrutiny of the behavior of states towards their citizens and of the relationship between a sovereign and its subjects; this forms the foundation of international human rights accountability. The quest for that accountability pervades Chen and Renteln’s work, which underscores the central importance of human rights accountability of all actors: states, non-state actors, international organizations, and private sector actors. It also describes the diversity of issues subject to human rights accountability today and the increasingly varied constituencies that now claim their rights and demand respect and protection. Human rights accountability requires the mediation of a perennial tension between the principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity on the one hand, and the respect, protection, promotion, and fulfillment of human rights on the other. This is a recurring theme that the book addresses effectively through its conceptual and substantive chapters. In addition to tackling some of today’s most contentious human rights issues such as racism, abortion and reproductive rights, female genital mutilation, and head coverings and honor killings, the Survey takes on broader challenges facing international human rights law, including those related to ethics, culture, and politics, as well as interpretative and enforcement challenges. The Survey begins with an analysis of the philosophical foundations of international human rights law (IHRL), analyzing the historical background, political traditions, and normative...
Read full abstract