Reviews Wild Pitch. By A. B. Guthrie, Jr. (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1973. 224 pages, $5.95.) I believe Guthrie had a good time writing this story. It has a relaxed, comfort able gait that makes it a very readable book. Just so long as the reader does not begin this novel anticipating another serious encounter with the development and history of the great Northwest, he should not be disappointed. To expect another The Big Sky, the Way West, These Thousand Hills, or Aifive, however, is to ask for disappointment. The book makes no pretense o f being a continuation of this series. It is frankly and openly a light, entertaining mystery yarn, told with characteristic Guthrie good sense, compassion for the human situation, and masculine humor. The story, set in a present-day western cattle town, population 1500, is narrated by seventeen-year-old Jason Beard (Huck-Holden-Nick), sheriffs helper and star pitcher for the town baseball team. The relationship between Jason and the sheriff, Chick Charleston, is a squire-to-knight one, with genuine regard and affection on both sides. It is this association, in fact, which is one o f the informing principles o f the novel, a rather refreshing variation on the youth-age, Huck Finn-Jim, son-father relationship. Chick, not unlike TV ’s McCloud in dress, manner, and western horse-sense, solves two murders by use of his shrewd insight into human nature. Jason describes him: “He looked like justice or law or clean order, and all of them tallied up. Habitually he wore polished boots and white, fitted shirts, often with a string tie, and a sandcolored stockman’s hat and frontier jacket and pants.” His methods, of course, are unsophisticated by modern detective standards, and because o f his apparent inefficiency in solving the crimes, a state criminal investigator is brought in to unravel the mystery with his superior training and technique. The result is predictable. Gewald, the trained state investigator, is shown up as a fool, the city slicker thus yielding to the local common-sense westerner. To further enhance the image o f the sheriff, he succeeds in winning the affections of the young and beautiful daughter of one of the suspects, much 76 Western American Literature to the chagrin o f the youthful Jason, who feels that age should not have the needed hormones to receive the attentions of such a beautiful filly. Charleston’s position in the town and relationship with its citizens is not unlike another TV sheriff, Andy Griffith o f Mayberry. (Guthrie’s town is named Midbury.) At times, in fact, the novel seems somewhere just this side o f parody and caricature, whether intentional or unintentional. For example, the various village characters fill roles that have become commonly associated with the small town; and the comic, often alliterative names serve to exaggerate this function. Besides the sheriff and his side-kick, the cast includes the town doctor, Old Doc Yak, old-fashioned but effective; the village idiot, Otto Dacey; the local telephone operator, Mabel Main, who knows everybody’s business; the resident drunk, well-treated and well-fed in the town jail; the local judge; and assorted characters: Oscar Oliphant, Loose Lancaster, Plenty Toogood, Dr. Ulysses Pierpont . And, curiously, it is this exaggerated identification with small-town America that finally defines the book. Forjudged by the standards for a first-rate detective story, the book would be no more than average — although it does have a number of plausible red herrings and an exciting episode in which the murderer is apprehended (which, incidentally, involves the title, a term associated with baseball). Beneath the surface o f the rather ordinary mystery plot, if one looks for it, lies something quite fundamental — so fundamental, in fact, that the book does, contradicting what I said earlier, have a basic thematic relationship with Guthrie’s previous novels. Guthrie’s continuing theme, disguised in various costumes, is nostalgia and regret for a vanishing America — the fur trapper, the pioneer, the cowboy, and now the village sheriff. For could not Chick Charleston, born in an earlier day, have been a Boone Caudill, a Dick Summers, a Lije Evans? He...
Read full abstract