The purpose of this paper is to review 5 cases of thyroid cancer in children followed for more than ten years. These cases were first reported by one of us (1) (H.F.H.) in February 1937. At that time, 6 patients had been studied, 5 of whom were then alive and are still living and well ten years later. Cancer of the thyroid in children is a rare disease. We have seen a total of 6 histologically proved cases in addition to the 6 cases originally reported. Some of these patients were seen only in consultation and were not treated at the Clinic. Langmann and Bruch (2) reviewed the literature in 1938 and found a total of 20 cases of cancer of the thyroid in children, to which they added one of their own. Seventeen of these patients were living, the longest survival being nine years after diagnosis and operation. These writers concluded that thyroid cancer in children runs a more benign course than the same condition in adults. This is in accordance with our experience and the observations of others. Since the article by Langmann and Bruch, few authentic cases have been recorded. Martin (3) observed thyroid cancer in 3 patients, aged nine, fifteen and thirteen years, 2 of whom were still alive one to two years after roentgen and surgical therapy; the third had just begun treatment at the time of the report. In a review of 774 cases of malignant thyroid lesions, Pemberton (4) found 4 in patients under ten years of age; all 4 patients were girls and the youngest was seven years of age. The series included also 13 patients in the second decade of life, of whom 8 were girls. Thus, 17 patients under twenty years of age constituted 2.2 per cent of the total number of cases. Williams (5), of the Cardiff Royal Infirmary, reported 2 cases of carcinoma of the thyroid in children fifteen years of age and added 1 case of small-cell sarcoma in a girl of eleven years, who died six months after diagnosis of pulmonary metastases. Scotti (6), among 64 cases of cancer in children, encountered Grade I carcinoma of the thyroid in an 11-year-old boy, who died three days following surgical intervention. Congenital teratomas should be included in any discussion of malignant disease of the thyroid in children. These lesions are usually recognized in infancy. Sutton and Gibbs (7) reviewed the literature in March 1944 and reported the thirty-first authentic case of congenital teratoma. In the same year Munro and Waldapfel (8) added another case, which was cured by operation. Hürthle-cell tumors of the thyroid gland have been reported in infants. A review by Morrow (9) indicates that by December 1945, 23 cases of Hürthle-cell tumor had been recorded, 3 of which had been recognized in infants. In these 3 cases the tumor had been regarded as adenomatous, but definite conclusions were unavailable as to whether or not it was malignant.
Read full abstract