Sirs: Oberndorfer et al. report a patient with the full clinical picture of a hereditary acute hepatic porphyria whose brain MRI was normal [1]. They conclude that a secondary abnormality of porphyrin metabolism should be the origin of their patient’s symptoms although secondary alterations of porphyrin metabolism are reported not to produce any porphyria-like symptoms [2]. We here present the case of another patient in whom we presume a secondary porphyrinuria was the cause of a neurological disorder mimicking the clinical and neuroradiological picture of a hereditary porphyria [3–5]. A 45 year old female was admitted to our neurological intensive care unit with an acute right-sided hemiparesis combined with aphasia. Cardiovascular risk factors could not be determined, her medical history included a series of generalized epileptic seizures before her admission to our hospital and an alcohol-dependency. Further medical history was not known as the patient was living alone. On admission, cerebral CT showed no abnormalities, especially no signs of a cerebral ischemia. On cerebral MRI in proton density and diffusion-weighted images a diffuse signal change was found bifrontally, in the left-hemispheric cortex and thalamus as well as in the right cerebellar cortex, FLAIR sequences showed corresponding changes. MR-Angiography was not tolerated by the patient as she was in an agitated state. Correlating with MRI findings, cerebral perfusion of the left hemisphere and the rightsided cerebellar hemisphere was diminished as shown on perfusion-SPECT while EEG showed diffuse slowing with a left frontotemporal theta-delta-focus without epileptic discharges. Cardiovascular investigations (Ultrasound-examination of cervical vessels, echocardiography, and ECG) showed no specific abnormalities; transcranial Doppler sonography could not be performed owing to the thickness of the temporal bone squama. Cerebrospinal fluid was normal as well, whereas liver-enzymes were elevated (Bili. tot. 13.53 mg/dl [0.00–1.10], Bili. dir. 11.87 mg/dl [0.00–0.25]; ASAT/GOT 348 U/l [10–50]; ALAT/GPT 295 U/l [10–50]; AP 386 U/l [40–129]; GGT 610 U/l [0–66]; LDH 647 U/l [135–225]; CK 1025 U/l [0–174], CK-MB 30 U/l [0–24]; normal values for creatinine.) As the patient was known to be an alcoholic and presented with seizures, elevated liver enzymes and dark urines, we checked for porphyrin abnormalities. During these investigations elevated urinary uroand coproporphyrins and total porphyrins were found (coproporphyrin 415 μg/d (< 120), uroporphyrin 113 μg/d (< 33), heptacarboxyporphyrin 17 μg/d (< 10), calculated total porphyrins 551 μg/d (< 170), normal values for hexacarboxyporphyrin and pentacarboxyporphyrin. In the course we found normal values for liver enzymes in 24h-urine for deltaaminolaevulic-acid, porphobilinogen, total porphyrins, porphobilinogen deaminase). We interpreted these laboratory findings as signs of cholestasis and the porphyrins as secondary coproporphyrinuria with a disturbed decarboxylation during cholestasis. Abdominal ultrasound showed an intrahepatic biliary obstruction causative for cholestasis. During her stay on our intenLETTER TO THE EDITORS
Read full abstract