Sequence Alignment Techniques Research Articles

The evolutionary origin of proinsulin: Amino acid sequence homology with the trypsin-related serine proteases detected and evaluated by new statistical methods

Proinsulins and pancreatic serine proteases were analyzed for possible amino acid sequence similarity, using an adapted version of the nucleotide sequence alignment technique of Sankoff (1972). The technique allowed us to determine simultaneously the statistical significance of both the sequence alignment and the number of gaps necessary to achieve that alignment. In the course of this work, it was realized that a rigorous analysis required non-parametric statistics. For the B-chain (amino-terminal) of insulin a highly significant gap-free sequence alignment with the serine proteases was found. For the A-chain (carboxy-terminal) of insulin a sequence alignment of modest statistical significance with two gaps could be obtained, while the search for a corresponding alignment for the C-peptide remained unsuccessful. Presumably the rapid evolution of the C-peptide has obscured its origin. Reconstruction of ancestral sequences was of no help. In contrast to the amino acid sequences, three-dimensional structures of the two protein families are quite different. Considering current histophysiological understanding of ontogeny and phylogeny of exocrine and endocrine pancreas, the observed sequence similarity of proinsulins and serine proteases was interpreted to mean that the two protein families have diverged from a common genetic ancestor. Moreoever, from the organismic distribution of these proteins it was concluded that at least one serine protease existed first, and that proinsulin was generated after duplication of a serine protease gene and subsequent drastic modification, such as a large deletion. Thus proinsulin, basically an anabolic hormone, is derived from a serine protease, an enzyme involved in digestion. This constitutes a refinement of a similar proposal by Steiner et al. (1973). The emergence of proinsulin seems to have occurred after coelenterates diverged, and possibly before most other major animal phyla diverged from the line leading to vertebrates, i.e. 520 to 700 million years ago. The evolution of proinsulin seems to have paralleled the evolution of endocrine cells. Homology of the secreted products of endocrine and exocrine cells was most readily reconciled with a common embryological and phylogenetic origin of the two cell types, as considered by Pictet & Rutter (1972).