Few studies have evaluated the differential benefits of breastfeeding on infant neurodevelopment at varying levels of prenatal alcohol exposure (PAE). This study examined whether the association between breastfeeding and neurodevelopment is modified by prenatal drinking pattern. The study included 385 infants from Ukraine born to women prospectively enrolled in a cohort study during pregnancy. Neurodevelopment was assessed at six and 12 months using the Bayley Scales of Infant Development II (BSID-II) Mental Developmental Index (MDI) and Psychomotor Developmental Index (PDI). Linear regression modeling with interaction terms and stratification by PAE group was used to determine the relationship between breastfeeding, PAE, and neurodevelopment. A significant interaction between PAE and breastfeeding was observed for the MDI and PDI at six and 12 months. Infants with high PAE who were breastfed at least four months had BSID-II scores 14 or more points higher compared to those never breastfed. Counterintuitively, those with moderate PAE had poorer performance on the BSID-II at 12 months when breastfed longer. There was a significant joint effect of PAE and breastfeeding on infant neurodevelopment at six and 12 months. Breastfeeding may provide distinct benefits to infants exposed to high levels of PAE. We found a positive effect of breastfeeding on infant neurodevelopment among infants with prenatal alcohol exposure (PAE), particularly those exposed to higher levels during gestation. This study is one of the first to evaluate whether breastfeeding mitigates harm caused by PAE. Breastfeeding may provide distinct benefits to infants with higher levels of PAE.