Salix Exigua Research Articles

Projected warming disrupts the synchrony of riparian seed release and snowmelt streamflow

Globally, spring phenology and abiotic processes are shifting earlier with warming. Differences in the magnitudes of these shifts may decouple the timing of plant resource requirements from resource availability. In riparian forests across the northern hemisphere, warming could decouple seed release from snowmelt peak streamflow, thus reducing moisture and safe sites for dominant tree recruitment. We combined field observations with climate, hydrology, and phenology models to simulate future change in synchrony of seed release and snowmelt peaks in the South Platte River Basin, Colorado, for three Salicaceae species that dominate western USA riparian forests. Chilling requirements for overcoming winter endodormancy were strongest in Salix exigua, moderately supported for Populus deltoides, and indiscernible in Salix amygdaloides. Ensemble mean projected warming of 3.5°C shifted snowmelt peaks 10-19d earlier relative to S.exigua and P.deltoides seed release, because decreased winter chilling combined with increased spring forcing limited change in their phenology. By contrast, warming shifted both snowmelt peaks and S.amygdaloides seed release 21d earlier, maintaining their synchrony. Decoupling of snowmelt from seed release for Salicaceae with strong chilling requirements is likely to reduce resources critical for recruitment of these foundational riparian forests, although the magnitude of future decoupling remains uncertain.

Using a Mechanistic Model to Develop Management Strategies to Cool Apache Trout Streams under the Threat of Climate Change

AbstractUser‐friendly stream temperature models populated with on‐site data may help in developing strategies to manage temperatures of individual stream reaches that are subject to climate change. We used the field‐tested Stream Segment Temperature model (U.S. Geological Survey) to simulate how altering discharge, groundwater input, channel wetted width, and shade prevents the temperatures of White Mountain, Arizona, stream reaches from exceeding the thermal tolerance of Apache Trout Oncorhynchus apache, both under existing conditions and under a climate change scenario. Simulations suggested increasing shade, either through streamside planting of specific numbers and species of plants or by other means, would be most effective and feasible for cooling the stream reaches we studied. Ponderosa pine Pinus ponderosa and Douglas fir Pseudotsuga menziesii provided the most shade followed in order by Engelman spruce Picea engelmannii, Bebb's willow Salix bebbiana, Arizona alder Alnus oblongifolia, and finally coyote willow Salix exigua. Vegetation survival depends on the appropriateness of site conditions at present and under climate change, and planting in buffer strips minimizes additional water removal from the watershed through evapotranspiration. Alternative shading options, including thick sedge growth, shade cloth, or felled woody vegetation, may be considered when environmental conditions do not support plantings. Increasing groundwater input can cool streams, but additional sources are scarce in the region. Decreasing the width‐to‐depth ratio would succeed best on reaches with widths greater than 2.0 m. Increasing discharge from upstream may lower water temperature on reaches with an initial discharge greater than 0.5 m3/s. Existing models provide suggestions to cool stream reaches. Further development of accessible software packages that incorporate evaporation, fragmentation, and other projected climate change effects into their routines will provide additional tools to help manage climate change effects.

Establishment and potential use of woody species in treatment wetlands

Plant species selection is an important criterion for improving treatment wetland performance. The aim of this work was to evaluate removal efficiency and potential uses of woody species in treatment wetlands during the establishment year. Plant development, removal efficiency and evapotranspiration rate of five woody species (Salix interior, Salix miyabeana, Sambucus canadensis, Myrica gale, Acer saccharinum) and four herbaceous taxa typically used in treatment wetlands (Typha angustifolia, Phragmites australis australis, Phragmites australis americanus, Phalaris arundinacea) were compared in a mesocosm-scale study during one growing season. Woody species showed significantly slower growth, but displayed several characteristics of interest for treatment wetland applications: good adaptation to wetlands conditions; high organic matter removal (76–88%); high nutrient accumulation in tissues and high evapotranspiration capacity. During the establishment year, herbaceous species showed greater biomass development (above- and belowground parts), higher evapotranspiration rate (>3.84 L m−2 d−1 compared to <3.23 L m−2 d−1 for woody species) and overall pollutant removal efficiency. These characteristics confirm the high efficiency of treatment wetlands planted with herbaceous species even in the first growing season. However, given their greater potential biomass development, woody species could represent an excellent alternative for improving treatment wetlands long-term performance.

Facilitating natural succession in a heavily invaded ecosystem

Invasive plants have major impacts on forest ecosystems. Where invasive species alter successional pathways, a site may reach an alternate stable state in which compositional change is unlikely without management intervention. We conducted a restoration experiment designed to alter the successional factors of site availability, species availability, and species performance to disrupt the stable state of invader dominance. In a field dominated by invasive reed canarygrass (Phalaris arundinacea L.), we compared two plot preparation methods (late-season site mulching plus Oust® application, vs. late-season Rodeo® application) to increase site availability and reduce Phalaris performance, and planted native trees and shrubs as seeds and as bare root seedlings at three densities to improve native species availability. We monitored Phalaris growth, other herbaceous species establishment, tree survival, and deer browsing (another influence on species performance) for two growing seasons. Although the mulching plus Oust treatment was initially more successful in terms of its ability to increase site availability (as measured by litter percent cover and depth), this pattern reversed in the second year of the experiment. Throughout the experiment, the Rodeo treatment was superior in terms of its ability to decrease Phalaris performance (as measured by cover and height), and in the second year it also improved the performance of herbaceous plants naturally establishing in the plots (as measured by cover). Volunteer herbaceous plant cover averaged 60% in Rodeo-treated plots by the end of the second growing season. The performance of planted, seeded, and naturally-occurring woody plants was similar across the two herbicide treatments. Overall survival of bare root seedlings was 41%; survival was greater than 70% for both swamp white oak and Dutch elm disease-resistant American elm. Deer preferentially browsed on silver maple seedlings, while demonstrating avoidance of American elm, cottonwood, sandbar willow and swamp white oak. Our results suggest that to promote succession in Phalaris-dominated sites, decreasing Phalaris performance is more important than immediately removing thatch. In terms of species availability, we conclude that propagule limitation was occurring for woody plants but not for herbaceous species; natural tree recruitment was very low, so our alteration of tree species availability was critical in terms of promoting succession to floodplain forest. The restoration approach of stimulating natural succession can be applied to other ecosystems, providing a link between successional theory and management practice.

A prescription for drug-free rivers: uptake of pharmaceuticals by a widespread streamside willow.

Following human excretion and limited removal with wastewater treatment, pharmaceuticals are accumulating in rivers worldwide. These chemicals can challenge the health of fish and aquatic organisms and since rivers provide drinking water sources, there is concern for cumulative exposure to humans. In this study, we discovered that sandbar willow (Salix exigua), a predominant riparian shrub along streams throughout North America, has the capacity to quickly remove pharmaceuticals from aqueous solutions. Our study tracked [3H]- or [14C]-labeled substances including 17α-ethynylestradiol (EE2), a synthetic estrogen in oral contraceptives; the antihypertensive, diltiazem (DTZ); and the anti-anxiety drug, diazepam (DZP); and for comparison, atrazine (ATZ), a root-absorbed herbicide. In growth chambers, willow saplings removed 40-80% of the substances from solutions in 24 h. Following uptake, the EE2 and DTZ were retained within the roots, while DZP and ATZ were partly passed on to the shoots. The absorbed EE2 was unextractable and apparently bound to the root tissue, while DTZ, DZP, and ATZ remained largely soluble (extractable). The uptake and translocation of the pharmaceuticals, reflected in the transpiration stream and root concentration factors, were reasonably predicted from their physicochemical properties, including octanol-water partitioning coefficients. These findings suggest the removal of pharmaceuticals as an unrecognized ecosystem service provided by riparian vegetation and especially the inundation tolerant sandbar willow. This encourages the conservation of riparian willows that line riverbanks, to remove pharmaceuticals and other contaminants. This phytoremediation also encourages the preservation of complex, braided channels and islands, which increase the extent of stream shorelines and riparian willows.

Leaf herbivory by insects during summer reduces overwinter browsing by moose

BackgroundDamage to plants by herbivores potentially affects the quality and quantity of the plant tissue available to other herbivore taxa that utilize the same host plants at a later time. This study addresses the indirect effects of insect herbivores on mammalian browsers, a particularly poorly-understood class of interactions. Working in the Alaskan boreal forest, we investigated the indirect effects of insect damage to Salix interior leaves during the growing season on the consumption of browse by moose during winter, and on quantity and quality of browse production.ResultsTreatment with insecticide reduced leaf mining damage by the willow leaf blotch miner, Micrurapteryx salicifoliella, and increased both the biomass and proportion of the total production of woody tissue browsed by moose. Salix interior plants with experimentally-reduced insect damage produced significantly more stem biomass than controls, but did not differ in stem quality as indicated by nitrogen concentration or protein precipitation capacity, an assay of the protein-binding activity of tannins.ConclusionsInsect herbivory on Salix, including the outbreak herbivore M. salicifoliella, affected the feeding behavior of moose. The results demonstrate that even moderate levels of leaf damage by insects can have surprisingly strong impacts on stem production and influence the foraging behavior of distantly related taxa browsing on woody tissue months after leaves have dropped.

Using prey availability to evaluate Lower Colorado River riparian restoration

The Lower Colorado River Multi‐species Conservation Program (MSCP) is charged with restoring habitat for 26 species such as the southwestern willow flycatcher (Empidonax traillii extimus) impacted by water development projects on the river. As of 2015, the MSCP had spent $200 million to create 1,200 ha of habitat at nine sites, but the benefits to these insectivorous birds and other target species have not been quantified. Many MSCP projects emphasized riparian plantings of willow (Salix exigua, Salix gooddingii) and cottonwood (Populus fremontii) on high terraces disconnected from the river. We documented prey availability for insectivores in constructed habitats as an indicator of restoration effectiveness. Using sticky traps as a proxy to estimate aerial insect flux, we found the number of aquatic insects, proportion of aquatic insects, total number of insects, and number of insect orders were all significantly lower in MSCP plantation sites than at the river's edge. Riparian restoration sites over 100 m from the river had only 4% of the aquatic insects, 20% of the total insects, and only half as many insect orders as sites adjacent to the river. Thus, food availability and overall habitat quality for insectivores are likely low in restoration sites that are distant from the river.

Non-Target Feeding by Galerucella Calmariensis on Sandbar Willow (Salix Interior) in Illinois

Non-Target Feeding by Galerucella Calmariensis on Sandbar Willow (Salix Interior) in Illinois

The Irrigation Effect: How River Regulation Can Promote Some Riparian Vegetation

River regulation impacts riparian ecosystems by altering the hydrogeomorphic conditions that support streamside vegetation. Obligate riparian plants are often negatively impacted since they are ecological specialists with particular instream flow requirements. Conversely, facultative riparian plants are generalists and may be less vulnerable to river regulation, and could benefit from augmented flows that reduce drought stress during hot and dry periods. To consider this 'irrigation effect' we studied the facultative shrub, netleaf hackberry (Celtis reticulata), the predominant riparian plant along the Hells Canyon corridor of the Snake River, Idaho, USA, where dams produce hydropeaking, diurnal flow variation. Inventories of 235 cross-sectional transects revealed that hackberry was uncommon upstream from the reservoirs, sparse along the reservoir with seasonal draw-down and common along two reservoirs with stabilized water levels. Along the Snake River downstream, hackberry occurred in fairly continuous, dense bands along the high water line. In contrast, hackberry was sparsely scattered along the free-flowing Salmon River, where sandbar willow (Salix exigua), an obligate riparian shrub, was abundant. Below the confluence of the Snake and Salmon rivers, the abundance and distribution of hackberry were intermediate between the two upstream reaches. Thus, river regulation apparently benefited hackberry along the Snake River through Hells Canyon, probably due to diurnal pulsing that wets the riparian margin. We predict similar benefits for some other facultative riparian plants along other regulated rivers with hydropeaking during warm and dry intervals. To analyze the ecological impacts of hydropeaking we recommend assessing daily maxima, as well as daily mean river flows.

Salixspecies variation in leaf gas exchange, sodium, and nutrient parameters at three levels of salinity

Leaf gas exchange, Na+, and nutrient parameters were quantified under control (CTL), medium (MST), and high (HST) saline treatments for Salix discolor Muhl. (DIS), Salix eriocephala Michx. (ERI), and Salix interior Rowlee (INT). Net photosynthesis (Pn) increased from CTL to MST for all species but remained unchanged between MST and HST for surviving INT plants in HST. Salix interior had greater water-use efficiency (WUE) than DIS and ERI. Under CTL, INT had 13× the leaf Na+concentration of DIS and ERI, but INT Na+only increased by 17% across each saline treatment, whereas DIS and ERI leaf Na+increased 6.0× from CTL to MST. Salix discolor and ERI had greater cation to Na+ratios than INT; however, INT ratios were stable across saline treatments, whereas the DIS and ERI ratios dropped precipitously. Across species and treatments, Pnhad a significant positive relationship to total aboveground dry mass, supporting the sink regulation of Pntheory. Also, Pnshowed a significant positive relationship to WUE and leaf N and to leaf Na+, which probably reflects greater energy expenditure required to mitigate the higher levels of Na+. The saline tolerance of INT may be due to natural selection pressure in the arid regions of the southwestern United States, where it is believed to have its evolutionary origins.

Maximizing Stake Performance: Storage, Soaking, Scoring, and Auxin as Pre-Planting Techniques for Sandbar Willow (Salix exigua) Stakes

ABSTRACT: Willow (Salix spp.) stakes are used in riparian restoration due to their wetland adaptations, large root systems, and production of adventitious roots. Best practices for maximizing stake performance need to be developed. We tested the effects of storage, scoring, and auxin treatments on the performance of sandbar willow (Salix exigua) stakes. Storage significantly increased height, longest stem length, and biomass. Height and aboveground biomass increased when stakes were stored/soaked. There were no significant effects of scoring or auxin application. Results show storing and soaking significantly improve willow stake performance, which could lead to faster canopy closure and better invasive species control in the field, increasing restoration success.

Distribution of genetic variation in five coppice growth traits among natural populations of seven North American willow (Salix) species

Genetic variation and population structure in biomass yield and coppice growth traits were assessed in seven native North American willow species (Salix amygdaloides (AMY), Salix bebbiana (BEB), Salix discolor (DIS), Salix eriocephala (ERI), Salix humilis (HUM), Salix interior (INT), and Salix nigra (NIG)) established together in common-garden field tests on two sites. Differences in biomass yield, coppice stem number, and average single-stem mass were significant at the site, species, population, and genotype (clonal) levels. There were also species × site interactions. Analyses of variance components for these traits showed that only 3%–5% of the total variation in these traits was due to site differences, whereas genetic variation at the species, population, and genotype levels accounted for approximately 10%–39%, 5%–13%, and 12%–23%, respectively. Populations were a significant source of variation in some willow species (e.g., AMY, DIS, ERI, and INT) but not in other species. Tree willows were less prolific in stem sprout production than shrub willows, and ERI coppices produced by far the highest number of stem sprouts per coppice. This multispecies investigation demonstrated strong species and clonal differences, but variation among populations within a species, although significant, was relatively small, indicating that major growth and yield gains can be made through proper species selection and clonal selection within local populations.

Local biotic adaptation of trees and shrubs to plant neighbors

Natural selection as a result of plant–plant interactions can lead to local biotic adaptation. This may occur where species frequently interact and compete intensely for resources limiting growth, survival, and reproduction. Selection is demonstrated by comparing a genotype interacting with con‐ or hetero‐specific sympatric neighbor genotypes with a shared site‐level history (derived from the same source location), to the same genotype interacting with foreign neighbor genotypes (from different sources). Better genotype performance in sympatric than allopatric neighborhoods provides evidence of local biotic adaptation. This pattern might be explained by selection to avoid competition by shifting resource niches (differentiation) or by interactions benefitting one or more members (facilitation). We tested for local biotic adaptation among two riparian trees,Populus fremontiiandSalix gooddingii, and the shrubSalix exiguaby transplanting replicated genotypes from multiple source locations to a 17 000 tree common garden with sympatric and allopatric treatments along the Colorado River in California. Three major patterns were observed: 1) across species, 62 of 88 genotypes grew faster with sympatric neighbors than allopatric neighbors; 2) these growth rates, on an individual tree basis, were 44, 15 and 33% higher in sympatric than allopatric treatments forP. fremontii, S. exiguaandS. gooddingii, respectively, and; 3) survivorship was higher in sympatric treatments forP. fremontiiandS. exigua. These results support the view that fitness of foundation species supporting diverse communities and dominating ecosystem processes is determined by adaptive interactions among multiple plant species with the outcome that performance depends on the genetic identity of plant neighbors. The occurrence of evolution in a plant‐community context for trees and shrubs builds on ecological evolutionary research that has demonstrated co‐evolution among herbaceous taxa, and evolution of native species during exotic plants invasion, and taken together, refutes the concept that plant communities are always random associations.

Habitat and forage selection by the American beaver (Castor canadensis) on a regulated river in the Chihuahuan Desert

The American beaver (Castor canadensis) has been promoted as a tool for restoring aquatic and riparian ecosystems in Western North America. However, little is known about the ecology of beavers in arid environments. The purpose of this study was to examine selection of habitat and woody forage species during winter along the Rio Grande in southern New Mexico. We compared habitat characteristics at sites where beavers were present and absent and evaluated forage selection of woody plants at presence sites. Beavers occurred at sites that retained water over winter and that had larger pools, higher cover of sedges (Cyperaceae), higher abundance of narrowleaf willow (Salix exigua) stems, and higher diversity of woody stems. For foraging, beavers strongly selected Rio Grande cottonwood (Populus deltoides) and Russian olive (Elaeagnus angustifolia) and used willows slightly more than available proportionately. We concluded that, while cottonwoods might require protection from beaver foraging, beavers were not having a negative impact on willows and did not promote saltcedars via ecological release.

Interactive effects of biochar and an organic dust suppressant for revegetation and erosion control with herbaceous seed mixtures and willow cuttings

AbstractLand reclamation efforts on “non‐soil” substrates frequently involve additions of organic material coupled with soil‐stabilizing dust suppressants to control erosion, but formal experiments, particularly of interactive effects, are lacking. We examined the effects of Entac™, a tall oil pitch emulsion, and pyrolyzed wood waste‐derived biochar on early plant establishment, growth, and survivorship, in 2 factorial greenhouse experiments: 1 using a seed mix widely used for roadside erosion control (the grasses Festuca rubra, Poa pratensis, Lolium perenne, and white clover [Trifolium repens]) and 1 using rooted cuttings of sand bar willow (Salix exigua). Biochar additions of 5, 10, and 20 t/ha enhanced biomass of clover by 14–250%, but had no significant effects on grasses. Entac additions inhibited early establishment and growth of both clover and grasses at all biochar treatment levels. Entac plus biochar treatments significantly enhanced survivorship of willows following a drought treatment in a greenhouse trial. In a field trial, Entac treatments had positive effects on willow diameter growth. Collectively, these results suggest that better soil moisture retention is the principal mechanism responsible for enhanced survivorship and growth of planted willows treated with Entac and biochar on sand substrates. Given Entac's inhibitive effects on early establishment of herbaceous species, and the abilities of Entac and biochar in combination to mitigate drought stress, these treatments may be particularly well suited for ecological restoration efforts using planted tree stock on coarse‐textured substrates and where exposure and ingress of non‐native herbaceous species are of concern.

A Closer Look: Stream Geomorphology and Ecohydrological Interactions in the Minnesota River Basin

A Closer Look: Stream Geomorphology and Ecohydrological Interactions in the Minnesota River Basin

Allometric relationships from coppice structure of seven North American willow (Salix) species

Biomass yield and component coppice growth traits were assessed in up to 20 clones from seven native North American willow species, Salix amygdaloides (SAM), Salix bebbiana (BEB), Salix discolor (DIS), S eriocephala (ERI), Salix humilis (HUM), Salix interior (INT), and Salix nigra (NIG), established together in a clonally replicated common-garden field test. Aboveground mass, coppice stem number, stem length, and stem basal diameter measurements on up to 20 of the largest stems from 2-yr-old coppiced plants showed that ERI had the greatest aboveground mass, followed by INT, and then a close grouping of BEB, DIS, and HUM; the “tree” willows, AMY and NIG, had the lowest yields. The tree willows were not as prolific in coppice stem sprout production as were the shrub willows. The greatest number of stem sprouts was produced by ERI, with one coppice producing 67 2-yr-old stem sprouts, and ERI also showed an atypical, non-negative relationship between stem size and stem number; whereas the other six willows showed a varying but expected negative relationship between coppice stem size and stem number. Species differences in allometric relationships highlight the need to develop species-specific models for more accurate non-destructive biomass yield estimation.

Distribution and Habitat Associations of California Black Rail (Laterallus jamaicensis coturniculus) in the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta

Author(s): Tsao, Danika C.; Melcer, Jr., Ronald E.; Bradbury, Michael | Abstract: Past studies documenting the distribution and status of state “Threatened California black rail (Laterallus jamaicensis coturniculus; hereafter black rail) have largely omitted the Sacramento—San Joaquin Delta (hereafter Delta). During March to May of 2009–2011, we conducted call–playback surveys to assess the status of the species within a wide range of wetland habitats of the central Delta region. We detected black rails at 21 of 107 discrete wetland sites, primarily on in-channel islands with dense cover. To better understand the habitat and land cover characteristics, we developed a model of habitat suitability from these occurrence data and a fine-scale vegetation and land use dataset using MaxEnt. We also evaluated differences in the size of wetlands at sites where black rails were detected versus where they were not. Through surveys and quantitative modeling, we found black rail presence differed from other regions within California and Arizona, in that it was positively associated with tall (1 to 5 m) emergent vegetation interspersed with riparian shrubs. Specific plants correlated with black rail presence included emergent wetland (Bolboschoenus acutus, B. californicus, B. acutus, Typha angustifolia, T. latifolia, Phragmites australis) and riparian (Salix exigua, S. lasiolepis, Rosa californica, Rubus discolor, Cornus sericea) species. Median patch size was significantly larger and perimeter-to-area ratios were significantly lower at wetland sites where black rails were found. These results provide a preliminary characterization of black rail habitat in the Delta region and highlight the need for better understanding of this listed species’ population size and habitat use in the region, in light of anticipated climate change effects and proposed large-scale restoration in the Delta.

Biomass and root stem production of a colony-forming willow (Salix interior) on highly disturbed, low fertility sites

This study describes biomass production, colony formation, and clonal spread via root stems (RS) of a wide-ranging North American willow species, Salix interior Rowlee (INT), one of the few willows that spread via vegetatively reproduced colonies, which can result in hundreds of upright stems arising from a shallow horizontal root network. Eight INT clones were tested in a common-garden experiment on two distinct site types (shale rock overburden and coarse gravel erosion sediments) with very low nitrogen and nutrients on a former coal mine site. Survival, height growth, aboveground biomass, and number of root stems (NRS) were quantified following 3 years of growth after establishment as rootless stem cuttings. Clonal differences were significant for survival and height at age 3. Survival was significantly greater on the coarse gravel outwash than shale rock overburden after the first and third year, but differences were only significant in the first year. There was a significant positive relationship between height growth and survival, both of which are indicators of plant vigor. Analysis of clonal variation in NRS showed an intermediate level of significance (P = 0.083), and a significant clone by site interaction (P = 0.024). On coarse gravel outwash, the more vigorous clones for height growth also produced more RS, indicating the absence of a potential trade-off in carbohydrate resource allocation between height growth of the ortet (mother plant) and its capacity for colony formation and spread via RS. It appears that RS quickly become independent sources of carbohydrate production. However, there was no relationship between clonal height growth and NRS on the rock overburden. Loose sand and gravel outwash deposits promoted a more rapid spread of the shallow horizontal root network than the less penetrable shale rock overburden that dominates this former coal mine site.

Incorporating climate change and exotic species into forecasts of riparian forest distribution.

We examined the impact climate change (CC) will have on the availability of climatically suitable habitat for three native and one exotic riparian species. Due to its increasing prevalence in arid regions throughout the western US, we predicted that an exotic species, Tamarix, would have the greatest increase in suitable habitat relative to native counterparts under CC. We used an ecological niche model to predict range shifts of Populus fremontii, Salix gooddingii, Salix exigua and Tamarix, from present day to 2080s, under five general circulation models and one climate change scenario (A1B). Four major findings emerged. 1) Contrary to our original hypothesis, P. fremontii is projected to have the greatest increase in suitable habitat under CC, followed closely by Tamarix. 2) Of the native species, S. gooddingii and S. exigua showed the greatest loss in predicted suitable habitat due to CC. 3) Nearly 80 percent of future P. fremontii and Salix habitat is predicted to be affected by either CC or Tamarix by the 2080s. 4) By the 2080s, 20 percent of S. gooddingii habitat is projected to be affected by both Tamarix and CC concurrently, followed by S. exigua (19 percent) and P. fremontii (13 percent). In summary, while climate change alone will negatively impact both native willow species, Tamarix is likely to affect a larger portion of all three native species' distributions. We discuss these and other results in the context of prioritizing restoration and conservation efforts to optimize future productivity and biodiversity. As we are accounting for only direct effects of CC and Tamarix on native habitat, we present a possible hierarchy of effects- from the direct to the indirect- and discuss the potential for the indirect to outweigh the direct effects. Our results highlight the need to account for simultaneous challenges in the face of CC.