Recent advances in animal socioecology stress the importance of kinship and group living in the evolution of social behavior (see Wilson 1975). Although many animals exhibit a relatively simple social system in which individuals disperse and breed upon reaching maturity, among some higher vertebrate species certain individuals regularly delay breeding beyond normal physiological maturity and live for long periods in extended family groups. Group breeding, in which nonbreeding individuals help care for the young of a breeding pair, is now documented for a great variety of birds (Rowley 1976). Of special interest to evolutionary biologists is the question: Why do certain individuals seem to forfeit their own reproductive efforts to assist others with their breeding? Typical of the group breeders studied to date is close genetic relatedness between the helpers and the young they help raise (Brown 1974, Gaston 1976, Hardy 1976, MacRoberts and MacRoberts 1976, Maynard Smith and Ridpath 1972, Rowley 1965, Woolfenden 1975). Furthermore, the presence of helpers has been shown to increase the number of offspring produced by the resident breeders, who usually are parents of the helpers (Rowley 1965, Woolfenden 1975). Thus, by helping to raise kin, a nonbreeder may increase the representation of its own genes in the population without being a parent (Hamilton 1964, West Eberhardt 1975). This has led to the conclusion that kin selection underlies the evolution of helping behavior (Brown 1974, Wilson 1975). Our preliminary work with Florida scrub jays (Aphelocoma c. coerulescens), plus certain data available for other group-breeding birds, suggests the possibility of additional, more direct benefits to the helpers from delaying breeding and helping. Many group-breeding species studied to date occupy mature, often relict habitats, and show many characteristics of intense K-selection (sensu MacArthur and Wilson 1967; Brown 1974, 1975). Competition for space appears to be paramount among these characteristics. This observation, together with the data presented herein, leads us to hypothesize in this paper that, in certain species, remaining home and helping represents a strategy used by nonbreeders to inherit the space necessary for breeding.
Read full abstract