Background: Red light photodynamic therapy (PDT) is an effective option for actinic keratosis (AK) lesions. However, stinging pain during illumination limits utility. Objective: To compare three modified red-light PDT regimens (short incubation, whole-face application, no occlusion) and to determine whether these can reduce pain yet still provide significant AK lesion clearance. Methods: Patients in this randomized clinical trial (n = 30) were randomized into one of three groups [incubation with 10% ALA gel, illumination with red-light]: Group A: 10 min, 20 min (75 J/cm2); Group B: 20 min, 10 min (37 J/cm2); Group C: 1 hour, 10 min (37 J/cm2). Two PDT treatments were administered 8 weeks apart. Lesions were counted at each visit, and pain was recorded on a scale from 0 – 10. Results: Patients Groups A and B (shorter incubations) experienced significantly less pain during illumination than Group C. After one treatment, the AK lesion reduction in Group A (59%) was statistically non-inferior to Group C (43%), with a noninferiority margin of ±15%. Final lesion counts after two PDT treatments showed a reduction from baseline by 82% in Group C, 76% in Group A, and 74% in Group B. Groups A and B did not meet the statistical non-inferiority endpoint relative to Group C after two treatments. Limitations: Small sample size, which limited the ability to reach statistical significance after 2 PDT treatments. Conclusion: Two short/modified red light PDT regimens were essentially painless, and all three provided AK lesion clearances comparable to conventional regimens.
Read full abstract