In order to clarify the differences in reactivity between cation radicals and dications, the kinetics and mechanisms were analysed in detail for the reactions of the electrogenerated 2,3,7,8-tetramethoxythianthrene cation radical (TMT˙+) and of the dication (TMT2+) with methanol and pyridine derivatives by using a pulse-electrolysis stopped-flow method. From the rate law determined for each reaction, the reaction mechanisms were elucidated, though they are different depending on the couples in the reactions. The reactions of TMT˙+ proceeded by multi-step reactions including the electron transfer of another TMT˙+ to generate TMT before the rate-determining step (rds). In contrast, in the reactions of TMT2+, it was found that the rds was the first or the second step of the reaction; i.e. the unstable cationic intermediate seems to be formed directly, not by the electron transfer. In addition to the excessive charge present in the dicationic state, a mechanism in which TMT2+ is easily accessible to the rds also seems to explain the high reactivity of TMT2+. The differences in the reaction mechanism depending on the nucleophiles were also supported by observing the substituent effects of pyridine derivatives on the reactions.
Read full abstract