To evaluate the results of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) for translocations. 52 USA-based IVF centers referring PGD samples to a single reference PGD laboratory. Cycles of PGD for translocations from 1995 to February 2005 were included in the study. Samples from 52 IVF centers were received in our PGD laboratories the same or next day after biopsy. All results were provided within 30 hours after sample arrival. FISH methods evolved during this period, and included polar body biopsy using painting probes, breakpoint-spanning probes in interphase blastomeres, and the last and preferred method, the use of telomeric and proximal probes in interphase blastomeres. A total of 539 cycles were performed, with an average maternal age of 34.0 years (compared to 37.5 for PGD of aneuploidy), involving the analysis of 4,597 embryos, of which only 19.0% were normal, and the rest unbalanced. Reciprocal translocations produced 15% normal embryos while Robertsonian translocations produced 28% normal embryos. Of the 539 cycles, 422 received a replacement (78%), with an average of 1.3 normal embryos replaced. 117 cycles had no replacement as all embryos were found to be abnormal. Information regarding pregnancy results was obtained from 462 pick ups, of which 138 became pregnant with the presence of a fetal heart, producing a pregnancy rate of 30% per pick- up, and 40% per replacement. The pregnancy rate, however, varied depending on the IVF center and the etiology of patients visiting each clinic, from a low 0% to 52% per oocyte retrieval. Also it varied depending on the type of translocation, with 25% and 40% pregnancy rate per oocyte retrieval in Reciprocal and Robertsonian translocations, respectively. In total, there were 176 fetal heartbeats. Of those, 1 was ectopic, 15 spontaneously aborted (9%), 7 were elective reduced due to multiple pregnancy, 40 are still ongoing, and 113 delivered . These patients had aborted previously 88% of their pregnancies compared to 9% after PGD (p<0.001). There have not been any misdiagnoses in this group to date. PGD has been shown in the past to reduce spontaneous abortions in patients with translocations. We have confirmed this observation with the largest dataset so far on PGD of translocations. The pregnancy rate obtained is dependent on the type of translocation but also it is proportionally linked to the overall pregnancy rate of each clinic and their experience in performing embryo biopsy, indicating the presence of a learning curve in the procedure. Some European PGD laboratories emphasize biopsy of two cells rather than one to further reduce the error rate, but clearly a very acceptable error rate can be attained with only 1 cell biopsied with the advantage of a reduction personnel time and stress upon the growing embryo.
Read full abstract