Protein Conformational Ensembles Research Articles

Understanding the Directed Evolution of a Natural-like Efficient Artificial Metalloenzyme.

The artificial metalloenzyme containing iridium in place of iron along with four directed evolution mutations C317G, T213G, L69V, and V254L in a natural cytochrome P450 presents an important milestone in merging the extraordinary efficiency of biocatalysts with the versatility of small molecule chemical catalysts in catalyzing a new-to-nature carbene insertion reaction. This is a show-stopper enzyme, as it exhibits a catalytic efficiency similar to that of natural enzymes. Despite this remarkable discovery, there is no mechanistic and structural understanding as to why it displays extraordinary efficiency after the incorporation of the four active site mutations by directed evolution methods, which so far has been intractable to any experimental methods. In this study, we have deciphered how directed evolution mutations gradually alter the protein conformational ensemble to populate a catalytically active conformation to boost a multistep catalysis in a natural-like artificial metalloenzyme using large-scale molecular dynamics simulations, rigorous quantum chemical (QM), and multiscale quantum chemical/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations. It reveals how evolution precisely positions the cofactor-substrate in an unusual but effective orientation within a reshaped active site in the catalytically active conformation stabilized by C-H···π interactions from more ordered mutated L69V and V254L residues to achieve preferential transition state stabilization compared to the ground state. This work essentially tracks down in atomistic detail the shift in the conformational ensemble of the highly active conformation from the less efficient single mutant to the most efficient quadruple mutant and offers valuable insights for designing better enzymes. The active conformation correctly reproduces the experimental barrier height and also accounts for the catalytic effect, which is in good agreement with experimental observations. Moreover, this conformation features an unusual bonding interaction in a metal-carbene species that preferentially stabilizes the rate-determining formation of an iridium porphyrin carbene intermediate to render the observed high catalytic rate acceleration. Our study provides crucial insights into the underlying rationale for directed evolution, reports the major catalytic role of nonelectrostatic interactions in enzyme catalysis different from the electrostatic model, and suggests a crucial principle toward designing enzymes with natural efficiency.

Predicting Mutation-Induced Allosteric Changes in Structures and Conformational Ensembles of the ABL Kinase Using AlphaFold2 Adaptations with Alanine Sequence Scanning.

Despite the success of AlphaFold2 approaches in predicting single protein structures, these methods showed intrinsic limitations in predicting multiple functional conformations of allosteric proteins and have been challenged to accurately capture the effects of single point mutations that induced significant structural changes. We examined several implementations of AlphaFold2 methods to predict conformational ensembles for state-switching mutants of the ABL kinase. The results revealed that a combination of randomized alanine sequence masking with shallow multiple sequence alignment subsampling can significantly expand the conformational diversity of the predicted structural ensembles and capture shifts in populations of the active and inactive ABL states. Consistent with the NMR experiments, the predicted conformational ensembles for M309L/L320I and M309L/H415P ABL mutants that perturb the regulatory spine networks featured the increased population of the fully closed inactive state. The proposed adaptation of AlphaFold can reproduce the experimentally observed mutation-induced redistributions in the relative populations of the active and inactive ABL states and capture the effects of regulatory mutations on allosteric structural rearrangements of the kinase domain. The ensemble-based network analysis complemented AlphaFold predictions by revealing allosteric hotspots that correspond to state-switching mutational sites which may explain the global effect of regulatory mutations on structural changes between the ABL states. This study suggested that attention-based learning of long-range dependencies between sequence positions in homologous folds and deciphering patterns of allosteric interactions may further augment the predictive abilities of AlphaFold methods for modeling of alternative protein sates, conformational ensembles and mutation-induced structural transformations.

In cell NMR reveals cells selectively amplify and structurally remodel amyloid fibrils.

Amyloid forms of α-synuclein adopt different conformations depending on environmental conditions. Advances in structural biology have accelerated fibril characterization. However, it remains unclear which conformations predominate in biological settings because current methods typically not only require isolating fibrils from their native environments, but they also do not provide insight about flexible regions. To address this, we characterized α-syn amyloid seeds and used sensitivity enhanced nuclear magnetic resonance to investigate the amyloid fibrils resulting from seeded amyloid propagation in different settings. We found that the amyloid fold and conformational preferences of flexible regions are faithfully propagated in vitro and in cellular lysates. However, seeded propagation of amyloids inside cells led to the minority conformation in the seeding population becoming predominant and more ordered, and altered the conformational preferences of flexible regions. The examination of the entire ensemble of protein conformations in biological settings that is made possible with this approach may advance our understanding of protein misfolding disorders and facilitate structure-based drug design efforts.

Mitogen signaling strength and duration can control cell cycle decisions.

Decades ago, mitogen-promoted signaling duration and strength were observed to be sensed by the cell and to be critical for its decisions: to proliferate or differentiate. Landmark publications established the importance of mitogen signaling not only in the G1 cell cycle phase but also through the S and the G2/M transition. Despite these early milestones, how mitogen signal duration and strength, short and strong or weaker and sustained, control cell fate has been largely unheeded. Here, we center on cardinal signaling-related questions, including (i) how fluctuating mitogenic signals are converted into cell proliferation-differentiation decisions and (ii) why extended duration of weak signaling is associated with differentiation, while bursts of strong and short induce proliferation but, if too strong and long, induce irreversible senescence. Our innovative broad outlook harnesses cell biology and protein conformational ensembles, helping us to define signaling strength, clarify cell cycle decisions, and thus cell fate.

Are Protein Conformational Ensembles in Agreement with Experimental Data? A Geometrical Interpretation of the Problem.

The conformational variability of biological macromolecules can play an important role in their biological function. Therefore, understanding conformational variability is expected to be key for predicting the behavior of a particular molecule in the context of organism-wide studies. Several experimental methods have been developed and deployed for accessing this information, and computational methods are continuously updated for the profitable integration of different experimental sources. The outcome of this endeavor is conformational ensembles, which may vary significantly in properties and composition when different ensemble reconstruction methods are used, and this raises the issue of comparing the predicted ensembles against experimental data. In this article, we discuss a geometrical formulation to provide a framework for understanding the agreement of an ensemble prediction to the experimental observations.

Integration of a Randomized Sequence Scanning Approach in AlphaFold2 and Local Frustration Profiling of Conformational States Enable Interpretable Atomistic Characterization of Conformational Ensembles and Detection of Hidden Allosteric States in the ABL1 Protein Kinase.

Despite the success of AlphaFold methods in predicting single protein structures, these methods showed intrinsic limitations in the characterization of multiple functional conformations of allosteric proteins. The recent NMR-based structural determination of the unbound ABL kinase in the active state and discovery of the inactive low-populated functional conformations that are unique for ABL kinase present an ideal challenge for the AlphaFold2 approaches. In the current study, we employ several adaptations of the AlphaFold2 methodology to predict protein conformational ensembles and allosteric states of the ABL kinase including randomized alanine sequence scanning combined with the multiple sequence alignment subsampling proposed in this study. We show that the proposed new AlphaFold2 adaptation combined with local frustration profiling of conformational states enables accurate prediction of the protein kinase structures and conformational ensembles, also offering a robust approach for interpretable characterization of the AlphaFold2 predictions and detection of hidden allosteric states. We found that the large high frustration residue clusters are uniquely characteristic of the low-populated, fully inactive ABL form and can define energetically frustrated cracking sites of conformational transitions, presenting difficult targets for AlphaFold2. The results of this study uncovered previously unappreciated fundamental connections between local frustration profiles of the functional allosteric states and the ability of AlphaFold2 methods to predict protein structural ensembles of the active and inactive states. This study showed that integration of the randomized sequence scanning adaptation of AlphaFold2 with a robust landscape-based analysis allows for interpretable atomistic predictions and characterization of protein conformational ensembles, providing a physical basis for the successes and limitations of current AlphaFold2 methods in detecting functional allosteric states that play a significant role in protein kinase regulation.

Protein Ensemble Generation Through Variational Autoencoder Latent Space Sampling.

Mapping the ensemble of protein conformations that contribute to function and can be targeted by small molecule drugs remains an outstanding challenge. Here, we explore the use of variational autoencoders for reducing the challenge of dimensionality in the protein structure ensemble generation problem. We convert high-dimensional protein structural data into a continuous, low-dimensional representation, carry out a search in this space guided by a structure quality metric, and then use RoseTTAFold guided by the sampled structural information to generate 3D structures. We use this approach to generate ensembles for the cancer relevant protein K-Ras, train the VAE on a subset of the available K-Ras crystal structures and MD simulation snapshots, and assess the extent of sampling close to crystal structures withheld from training. We find that our latent space sampling procedure rapidly generates ensembles with high structural quality and is able to sample within 1 Å of held-out crystal structures, with a consistency higher than that of MD simulation or AlphaFold2 prediction. The sampled structures sufficiently recapitulate the cryptic pockets in the held-out K-Ras structures to allow for small molecule docking.

FRETpredict: a Python package for FRET efficiency predictions using rotamer libraries

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a widely-used and versatile technique for the structural characterization of biomolecules. Here, we introduce FRETpredict, an easy-to-use Python software to predict FRET efficiencies from ensembles of protein conformations. FRETpredict uses a rotamer library approach to describe the FRET probes covalently bound to the protein. The software efficiently and flexibly operates on large conformational ensembles such as those generated by molecular dynamics simulations to facilitate the validation or refinement of molecular models and the interpretation of experimental data. We provide access to rotamer libraries for many commonly used dyes and linkers and describe a general methodology to generate new rotamer libraries for FRET probes. We demonstrate the performance and accuracy of the software for different types of systems: a rigid peptide (polyproline 11), an intrinsically disordered protein (ACTR), and three folded proteins (HiSiaP, SBD2, and MalE). FRETpredict is open source (GPLv3) and is available at github.com/KULL-Centre/FRETpredict and as a Python PyPI package at pypi.org/project/FRETpredict.

Data-Efficient Generation of Protein Conformational Ensembles with Backbone-to-Side-Chain Transformers.

Excitement at the prospect of using data-driven generative models to sample configurational ensembles of biomolecular systems stems from the extraordinary success of these models on a diverse set of high-dimensional sampling tasks. Unlike image generation or even the closely related problem of protein structure prediction, there are currently no data sources with sufficient breadth to parametrize generative models for conformational ensembles. To enable discovery, a fundamentally different approach to building generative models is required: models should be able to propose rare, albeit physical, conformations that may not arise in even the largest data sets. Here we introduce a modular strategy to generate conformations based on "backmapping" from a fixed protein backbone that (1) maintains conformational diversity of the side chains and (2) couples the side-chain fluctuations using global information about the protein conformation. Our model combines simple statistical models of side-chain conformations based on rotamer libraries with the now ubiquitous transformer architecture to sample with atomistic accuracy. Together, these ingredients provide a strategy for rapid data acquisition and hence a crucial ingredient for scalable physical simulation with generative neural networks.

Predicting protein conformational ensembles using deep generative models

Predicting protein conformational ensembles using deep generative models

Determining protein conformational ensembles by combining machine learning and small-angle scattering

Determining protein conformational ensembles by combining machine learning and small-angle scattering

Effects of hydrophobic sequence patterns on disordered protein conformational ensembles

Effects of hydrophobic sequence patterns on disordered protein conformational ensembles

Approximating Projections of Conformational Boltzmann Distributions with AlphaFold2 Predictions: Opportunities and Limitations.

Protein thermodynamics is intimately tied to biological function and can enable processes such as signal transduction, enzyme catalysis, and molecular recognition. The relative free energies of conformations that contribute to these functional equilibria evolved for the physiology of the organism. Despite the importance of these equilibria for understanding biological function and developing treatments for disease, computational and experimental methods capable of quantifying the energetic determinants of these equilibria are limited to systems of modest size. Recently, it has been demonstrated that the artificial intelligence system AlphaFold2 can be manipulated to produce structurally valid protein conformational ensembles. Here, we extend these studies and explore the extent to which AlphaFold2 contact distance distributions can approximate projections of the conformational Boltzmann distributions. For this purpose, we examine the joint probability distributions of inter-residue contact distances along functionally relevant collective variables of several protein systems. Our studies suggest that AlphaFold2 normalized contact distance distributions can correlate with conformation probabilities obtained with other methods but that they suffer from peak broadening. We also find that the AlphaFold2 contact distance distributions can be sensitive to point mutations. Overall, we anticipate that our findings will be valuable as the community seeks to model the thermodynamics of conformational changes in large biomolecular systems.

Exploring conformational landscapes and binding mechanisms of convergent evolution for the SARS-CoV-2 spike Omicron variant complexes with the ACE2 receptor using AlphaFold2-based structural ensembles and molecular dynamics simulations.

In this study, we combined AlphaFold-based approaches for atomistic modeling of multiple protein states and microsecond molecular simulations to accurately characterize conformational ensembles evolution and binding mechanisms of convergent evolution for the SARS-CoV-2 spike Omicron variants BA.1, BA.2, BA.2.75, BA.3, BA.4/BA.5 and BQ.1.1. We employed and validated several different adaptations of the AlphaFold methodology for modeling of conformational ensembles including the introduced randomized full sequence scanning for manipulation of sequence variations to systematically explore conformational dynamics of Omicron spike protein complexes with the ACE2 receptor. Microsecond atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations provide a detailed characterization of the conformational landscapes and thermodynamic stability of the Omicron variant complexes. By integrating the predictions of conformational ensembles from different AlphaFold adaptations and applying statistical confidence metrics we can expand characterization of the conformational ensembles and identify functional protein conformations that determine the equilibrium dynamics for the Omicron spike complexes with the ACE2. Conformational ensembles of the Omicron RBD-ACE2 complexes obtained using AlphaFold-based approaches for modeling protein states and MD simulations are employed for accurate comparative prediction of the binding energetics revealing an excellent agreement with the experimental data. In particular, the results demonstrated that AlphaFold-generated extended conformational ensembles can produce accurate binding energies for the Omicron RBD-ACE2 complexes. The results of this study suggested complementarities and potential synergies between AlphaFold predictions of protein conformational ensembles and MD simulations showing that integrating information from both methods can potentially yield a more adequate characterization of the conformational landscapes for the Omicron RBD-ACE2 complexes. This study provides insights in the interplay between conformational dynamics and binding, showing that evolution of Omicron variants through acquisition of convergent mutational sites may leverage conformational adaptability and dynamic couplings between key binding energy hotspots to optimize ACE2 binding affinity and enable immune evasion.

Model-Dependent Solvation of the K-18 Domain of the Intrinsically Disordered Protein Tau.

A known imbalance between intra-protein and protein-water interactions in many empirical force fields results in collapsed conformational ensembles of intrinsically disordered proteins in explicit solvent simulations that disagree with experiments. Multiple strategies have been introduced in the literature to modify protein-water interactions, which improve agreement between experiments and simulations. In this work, we combine simulations with standard and modified force fields with a spatially resolved analysis of solvation free energy contributions and compare the consequences of each strategy. We find that enhanced Lennard-Jones (LJ) interactions between protein atoms and water oxygens primarily improve the solvation of nonpolar functional groups of the protein. In contrast, modified electrostatics in the water model or strengthened LJ interactions between the protein and water hydrogens mainly affect the hydration of polar functional groups. Modified electrostatics further impact the average orientation of water molecules in the hydration shell. As a result, protein-water interactions with the first hydration layers are strengthened, while interactions with water molecules in higher hydration shells are weakened. Hence, distinct strategies to balance intra-protein and protein-water interactions in simulations have qualitatively different effects on protein solvation. These differences are not necessarily captured by comparisons to experiments that report on global parameters describing protein conformational ensembles, e.g., the radius of gyration, but will influence the tendency of a protein to form aggregates or phase-separated droplets.

EnGens: a computational framework for generation and analysis of representative protein conformational ensembles.

Proteins are dynamic macromolecules that perform vital functions in cells. A protein structure determines its function, but this structure is not static, as proteins change their conformation to achieve various functions. Understanding the conformational landscapes of proteins is essential to understand their mechanism of action. Sets of carefully chosen conformations can summarize such complex landscapes and provide better insights into protein function than single conformations. We refer to these sets as representative conformational ensembles. Recent advances in computational methods have led to an increase in the number of available structural datasets spanning conformational landscapes. However, extracting representative conformational ensembles from such datasets is not an easy task and many methods have been developed to tackle it. Our new approach, EnGens (short for ensemble generation), collects these methods into a unified framework for generating and analyzing representative protein conformational ensembles. In this work, we: (1) provide an overview of existing methods and tools for representative protein structural ensemble generation and analysis; (2) unify existing approaches in an open-source Python package, and a portable Docker image, providing interactive visualizations within a Jupyter Notebook pipeline; (3) test our pipeline on a few canonical examples from the literature. Representative ensembles produced by EnGens can be used for many downstream tasks such as protein-ligand ensemble docking, Markov state modeling of protein dynamics and analysis of the effect of single-point mutations.

Single-molecule visualization determines conformational substate ensembles in β-sheet–rich peptide fibrils

An understanding of protein conformational ensembles is essential for revealing the underlying mechanisms of interpeptide recognition and association. However, experimentally resolving multiple simultaneously existing conformational substates remains challenging. Here, we report the use of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) to analyze the conformational substate ensembles of β sheet peptides with a submolecular resolution (in-plane <2.6 Å). We observed ensembles of more than 10 conformational substates (with free energy fluctuations between several k B T s) in peptide homoassemblies of keratin (KRT) and amyloidal peptides (−5Aβ42 and TDP-43 341–357). Furthermore, STM reveals a change in the conformational ensemble of peptide mutants, which is correlated with the macroscopic properties of peptide assemblies. Our results demonstrate that the STM-based single-molecule imaging can capture a thorough picture of the conformational substates with which to build an energetic landscape of interconformational interactions and can rapidly screen conformational ensembles, which can complement conventional characterization techniques.

Evolving Mutational Buildup in HIV-1 Protease Shifts Conformational Dynamics to Gain Drug Resistance.

Drug resistance in antiviral treatments is a serious public health problem. Viral proteins mutate very fast, giving them a way to escape drugs by lowering drug binding affinity but with compromised function. Human immunodeficiency virus type I (HIV-1) protease, a critical antiretroviral therapeutic target, represents a model for such viral regulation under inhibition. Drug inhibitors of HIV-1 protease lose effectiveness as the protein evolves through several variants to become more resistant. However, the detailed mechanism of drug resistance in HIV-1 protease is still unclear. Here, we test the hypothesis that mutations throughout the protease alter the protein conformational ensemble to weaken protein-inhibitor binding, resulting in an inefficient protease but still viable virus. Comparing conformational ensembles between variants and the wild type helps detect these function-related dynamical changes. All analyses of over 30 μs simulations converge to the conclusion that conformational dynamics of more drug-resistant variants are more different from that of the wild type. Distinct roles of mutations during viral evolution are discussed, including a mutation predominantly contributing to the increase of drug resistance and a mutation that is responsible (synergistically) for restoring catalytic efficiency. Drug resistance is mainly due to altered flap dynamics that hinder the access to the active site. The mutant variant showing the highest drug resistance has the most ″collapsed″ active-site pocket and hence the largest magnitude of hindrance of drug binding. An enhanced difference contact network community analysis is applied to understand allosteric communications. The method summarizes multiple conformational ensembles in one community network and can be used in future studies to detect function-related dynamics in proteins.

PROTHON: A Local Order Parameter-Based Method for Efficient Comparison of Protein Ensembles.

The comparison of protein conformational ensembles is of central importance in structural biology. However, there are few computational methods for ensemble comparison, and those that are readily available, such as ENCORE, utilize methods that are sufficiently computationally expensive to be prohibitive for large ensembles. Here, a new method is presented for efficient representation and comparison of protein conformational ensembles. The method is based on the representation of a protein ensemble as a vector of probability distribution functions (pdfs), with each pdf representing the distribution of a local structural property such as the number of contacts between Cβ atoms. Dissimilarity between two conformational ensembles is quantified by the Jensen-Shannon distance between the corresponding set of probability distribution functions. The method is validated for conformational ensembles generated by molecular dynamics simulations of ubiquitin, as well as experimentally derived conformational ensembles of a 130 amino acid truncated form of human tau protein. In the ubiquitin ensemble data set, the method was up to 88 times faster than the existing ENCORE software, while simultaneously utilizing 48 times fewer computing cores. We make the method available as a Python package, called PROTHON, and provide a GitHub page with the Python source code at https://github.com/PlotkinLab/Prothon.

Environmentally Ultrasensitive Fluorine Probe to Resolve Protein Conformational Ensembles by 19F NMR and Cryo-EM.

Limited chemical shift dispersion represents a significant barrier to studying multistate equilibria of large membrane proteins by 19F NMR. We describe a novel monofluoroethyl 19F probe that dramatically increases the chemical shift dispersion. The improved conformational sensitivity and line shape enable the detection of previously unresolved states in one-dimensional (1D) 19F NMR spectra of a 134 kDa membrane transporter. Changes in the populations of these states in response to ligand binding, mutations, and temperature correlate with population changes of distinct conformations in structural ensembles determined by single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). Thus, 19F NMR can guide sample preparation to discover and visualize novel conformational states and facilitate image analysis and three-dimensional (3D) classification.