Probable Effect Concentration Research Articles

Spatial and seasonal assessment of heavy metal contamination in Golden Horn sediments, İstanbul, Türkiye: Ecological impacts, human health risks, and environmental monitoring.

Assessing spatial patterns and ecological risks to coastal ecotourism: A case study from the Bohai Sea.

A century of tailings migration from silver mining reduced biodiversity in a Boreal Shield lake.

Sediment quality and ecological risk assessment in Mediterranean harbors of Occitanie, France: implications for sustainable dredged material management.

Heavy metal toxicity risk assessments in sediments often rely on pseudototal concentrations, despite the higher theoretical predictive potential of bioavailable fractions. This study introduces the Bioavailable Fraction Toxicity Factor (BTf) and the Bioavailable Fraction Toxicity Index (BTI) to evaluate metal toxicity risks using a bioavailable fraction calculated as the sum of the first two steps of the Tessier sequential extraction procedure. Investigating heavy metal pollution (Cd, Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb, Zn) in the Vetas River catchment, a critical freshwater source in the Santurbán Páramo within the Tropical Andes biodiversity hotspot, the study identified artisanal and small-scale mining as the primary driver of contamination. Water and sediment of mining areas, particularly La Baja Creek and El Volcán Village, exhibited the highest concentrations of metals, with some sediment levels being categorized as strongly contaminated by the Geoaccumulation Index and Pollution Load Index and exceeding the Probable Effect Concentration threshold. Bioavailable fraction of metals in sediments were measured. Bioavailable fractions were higher in mining-affected areas, suggesting greater potential for metal release under acidic conditions. The BTf and BTI provided a more nuanced understanding of metal toxicity risks compared to pseudototal concentrations, with higher BTI values in mining-influenced sites. These findings underscore the need for mitigation measures to address heavy metal pollution and highlight the ecological importance of the Santurbán Páramo. Further research into bioremediation potential using local flora is recommended to support sustainable management practices.

The present study focuses on the sources and spatial distribution of potentially toxic elements (PTEs) and organic pollutants in water, canal bed sediment, and soil in the Versiliana urban park, an inclusive green area near the coast in the densely populated Versilia Plain of Tuscany. Surface water and bed sediments from canals crossing the urban park were collected at 10 stations during four different surveys to account for hydrological seasonality. Groundwater was collected in a survey through 10 piezometers. Eleven shallow soil samples were also collected, with the aim of evaluating the potential release of pollutants. Groundwater ranged from Ca-HCO3, to NaCl, CaCl2, and Na-HCO3 water types, indicating conservative mixing and cation exchange processes during seawater intrusion. Most waters from canals belonged to the Ca-HCO3 hydrofacies; a salinization shift, due to hydraulic connection with saline groundwater and soil sea salt dissolution, is observed. The concentration of most PTEs in groundwater and canal water is below Italian regulatory thresholds, with the only exception being As, which exceeds the legal limit in some samples. In most sediments, Ni, Cr, Zn, and As exceed the threshold effect concentration, and in some cases, the probable effect concentration. Geogenic PTE sources are attributed to metalliferous mineralization that characterizes the upstream Versilia River basin catchment. However, local PTE inputs from vehicular emissions and local industrial activities have been highlighted. Arsenic in sediments originated from geogenic sources and from arsenical pesticides, as indicated by the analysis of organic compounds, highlighting the legacy of the use of organic pesticides that have settled in bed sediments, in particular malathion and metalaxyl. The arsenic risk-based screening level in soil is lower compared with the regulatory threshold and with the measured concentration.

ABSTRACT A comprehensive analysis of eight metals (Fe, Mn, Cu, Ni, Zn, Cr, Pb, and Cd) in 38 surface sediment samples from the Henan region of the Yellow River was conducted to describe the grade, risk assessment, and sources of heavy metals (HMs) contamination. The average concentration of HMs was Fe> Mn> Zn> Cr> Ni> Cu> Pb> Cd. The enrichment factor (EF) and geological accumulation index (Igeo) both indicated significant accumulation of Cd. Cd levels reached moderately contaminated, while other HMs remained uncontaminated. Potential risks were evaluated using ecological risk factors (Er), and the risk index (RI) indicated that Cd concentrations posed a threat to aquatic organisms. The Yellow River can be seen as a nontoxic region for other HMs in Henan. The Sediment quality indicators (SQGs) revealed that the area was affected by the toxic effects of multiple HMs. The overall mean probable effect concentration quotients (MPECQs) approach the threshold, which warrants attention. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) revealed three components that accounted for 93.72% of the variance. The PCA and Cluster Analysis (CA) indicated that Fe, Mn, Cu, Cr, and Ni were sourced from nature, while Zn and Pb were mainly caused by human activity. A small portion of Cd can be linked to various human factors.

Sediments are a dire part of the aquatic ecosystems, and their contamination is a global concern. Therefore, this study evaluates sediment quality in the Niger Delta region of Nigeria based on heavy metal-contamination. To achieve this, three set of sediment samples were collected, two were sampled from areas with history of crude oil spills, and a control sample was collected from an area with no history of crude oil spills. Sediment sampling covered three different sites. For site 1, the mean concentrations of heavy metal were 0.49, 14.70, 7.35, 8.72, 13.92, and 38.06 mg/kg for cadmium, chromium, copper, nickel, lead, and zinc, respectively. These concentrations were below the threshold effect concentration, and probable effect concentration. These are both environment risk guidelines. Similarly, for site 2, the mean concentrations of heavy metals were 1.92, 30.61, 19.41, 20.05, 22.99, and 102.28 mg/kg for the heavy metal order above. The concentration of cadmium (1.92) is above the threshold effect concentration value (0.99 mg/kg), which implies adverse effect is expected to occur. The concentration values of the rest heavy metals were below both the threshold effect concentration and probable effect concentration guideline values. For site 3, the mean concentration values following the heavy metal order were 0.29, 36.45, 20.20, 16.25, 21.51, and 62.14 mg/kg, respectively. These values are all below the two specified guideline values. The control samples all had concentrations below the guideline values of the two specified guidelines, indicating that the high concentration values were due to crude oil spills in the area. However, since heavy metals are known for their bioaccumulation and biomagnifications potentials, and degradation resistance, there is need for sediment quality analysis in the region to safeguard our aquatic ecosystems.

This research reports heavy metal pollution in riverine sediments from River Kabul, Pakistan, which could endanger human health and ecology via the food web. The results revealed a substantial special variation in the average contents (mg/kg) of chromium (Cr), manganese (Mn), cobalt (Co), nickel (Ni), copper (Cu), zinc (Zn), cadmium (Cd), mercury (Hg), lead (Pb), iron (Fe), and aluminum (Al) in riverine sediments, in the order of Fe (20,234.51) > Al (17,550.86) > Mn (375.45) > Zn (149.08) > Ni (89.11) > Cr (83.36) > Pb (45.29) > Cu (19.86) > Cd (7.48) > Co (6.28) > Hg (0.81). Among the heavy metals, Cd exhibited the highest degree of pollution along the river, followed by Hg > Ni > Zn > Pb > Al > Cr > Mn > Fe > Cu > Co. The overall contamination factor (CF) values for the sum of heavy metals were highest at monitoring site S-9, followed by S-8 > S-10 > S-6 > S-5 > S-7 > S-1 > S-4 > S-12 > S-3 > S-2 > S-1 with pollution load index (PLI) > 1, whereas the geo-accumulation index (Igeo) values of Cd and Hg fluctuated between Levels 3, 4, and 6, suggesting moderate to extreme pollution in the river. The correlation statistics determined the fate and distribution of heavy metals by establishing significant positive correlations between the specific metals of bounded sediments. The cluster analysis separates the correlated metals into Groups A and B, and Groups 1 and 2. While the principal component analysis evaluates the qualitative behavior of clustering by discerning industrial, agrochemicals, mining, and domestic wastewater discharges, leakages of lubricants along with multiple geogenic inputs, erosion of mafic and ultramafic rocks, and minimal atmospheric deposition are all potential sources of Cr, Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Cd, Hg, Pb, Fe, and Al contamination. In terms of risk, the contaminations of Mn, Co, Cu, Zn, and Pb in riverine sediments were 85, 100, 100, 17, and 11%, respectively, representing a rare biological influence because their value is less than their corresponding threshold effect concentrations (TECs), whereas the levels of Mn, Ni, Cd, and Hg were above their probable effect concentrations (PECs) of 100, 100, 81, and 52%, respectively, representing prominent adverse biological influence. Based on consensus-based TECs and PECs, the contamination levels of Cr, Mn, Zn, Cd, Hg, and Pb were 100, 85, 83, 19, 48, and 90%, respectively, indicating occasionally exhibited adverse biological effects on the riverine population. Besides, the overall potential ecological risk index (PERI) of Cd and Hg, in particular, exhibited the maximum pollution level ( ≥ 320), suggesting a very high potential ecological risk in the drainage that requires special attention from pollution control authorities.

Assessment of recent lake sediment conditions in the conterminous U.S.

The western coastal area of Alexandria City, Egypt, faces significant environmental challenges due to heavy metal (HM) contamination in beach sediments, driven by intensive urbanization, tourism, commercial harbors, and industrial activities. Therefore, this study focuses on geochemically assessing HM levels in sediment samples from 28 sites and employed various descriptive and multivariate statistical approaches, pollution indices, and sediment quality guidelines (SQGs) to identify pollution hotspots, define contamination grades, and assess the quality of beach sediments. The average concentrations of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Pb, and Zn were 25.7, 30, 2.2, 7.5, 2.9, and 8.0 times, respectively, compared to the geochemical background (carbonate sedimentary rocks). et al.-Hanuvil Beach, relatively elevated contents of these metals were recorded. In addition, samples showed Zn levels higher than the corresponding probable effect concentration (PEC) and effect range medium (ERM) values, suggesting adverse impacts on biota. The principal component (PC) analysis revealed the anthropogenic origin of Cd, Co, and Pb in PC1, the mixed origin of Cr, Cu, Mn, and Zn in PC2, and the natural source of Fe in PC3. According to the applied single pollution indices, HM contamination grades were ranked in ascending order of Mn < Fe < Cr < Cd < Cu < Pb < Zn < Co. In conclusion, the HMs (Cu, Zn, Cd, Co, Pb, and Cr) in the study area are anthropogenic, attributed mainly to untreated discharge of municipal and industrial wastewater and solid wastes, atmospheric deposition of air pollutants, and tourism activities.

Source-risk and uncertainty assessment of trace metals in surface sediments of a human-dominated seaward catchment in eastern China

Contamination of depressional wetlands in the Mpumalanga Lake District of South Africa near a global emission hotspot

Since the establishment of a free economic zone and a simultaneous increase in the population of the QwaQwa region, aquatic systems of the area were expected to undergo an increase in metal contamination. The aims of this study were to assess the quality of sediments from the Metsi-Matsho, Namahadi and Elands Rivers of the QwaQwa region, and to investigate their impact on the survival and reproduction of the collembolan Folsomia candida. Due to the lack of freshwater sediment quality guidelines in South Africa, metal contents of the sediments were analysed and critically interpreted using the national action list for the screening of dredged sediment proposed for marine disposal, and international sediment quality guidelines (SQGs). In the laboratory, F. candida was exposed to 0, 50, 75 and 100% of the sediment samples for 28 days at 20 °C. Sediments were variably contaminated with Cr, with the Namahadi River middle site having the highest concentration (569 mg.kg−1, dry weight) followed by the lower site on the Elands River (529 mg.kg−1, dry weight), both above the recommended prohibition level of 500 mg Cr.kg−1. According to the consensus-based SQGs, only the concentrations of Cr and Ni (upper reach of Metsi-Matsho River) were higher than probable effect concentration, denoting that harmful effects of those metals are likely to occur. Of the two endpoints assessed, reproduction was the most sensitive with the upper reach of the Metsi-Matsho River (half maximal effective concentration, EC50 = 24% sediment) being the most deleterious site to the reproduction of F. candida. Ecotoxicological bioassays using F. candida could be suitable complements to chemical analysis in the assessment of the ecological risks of freshwater sediments as this collembolan species is sensitive to sediments with variable ranges of metal contamination.

This research is focused on the assessment of the pollution status of river and lake sediments near Pb, Zn, and Cu mines and tailings in the southeastern part of Serbia-Krajište area. The study is based on hypothesis that investigated rivers and lakes in the Krajište area could be polluted by potentially toxic elements (PTEs) and that these elements could pose considerable ecological risk to the studied surface water environment. High PTE contents are detected in studied river sediments (up to 7892mgkg-1 for Zn, 3224mgkg-1 for Cu, 36,790mgkg-1 for Pb, 64.2mgkg-1 for Cd, and 1444mgkg-1 for As). Given that the contents of the studied elements in most of the river sediments exceeded the background values, values prescribed by regulations of the Republic of Serbia, as well as probable effect concentration (PEL), it is possible to conclude that sediments were heavily polluted and that detrimental effects can be expected. Contamination indices including the enrichment factor (EF), contamination factor (CF), index of geoaccumulation (Igeo), potential ecological risk index (Eri), ecological risk index (RI), pollution load index (PLI), and aggregative toxicity index (ATI) were used to assess the degree of pollution by PTEs. The ecological risk assessment revealed that there is a significant risk observed for toxic elements (primarily Pb, Cu, Cd, and As) at this moment. The highest contamination indices (EF, Igeo, CF, PLI, and ATI) are mainly associated with historical and current mining activities. The Monte Carlo analysis based on the risk assessment indices was used to evaluate the uncertainty. The most pronounced toxic risk is found for the Pb, Cu, Cd, and As which assessment was in the range of high and extremely high-risk probabilities. The obtained results suggest that levels of toxic elements pose a significant ecological risk to the surface water environment near Pb, Zn, and Cu mines in the Krajište area. The methodology applied in this paper could be very useful for other researchers dealing with the problem of environmental pollution by toxic elements.

Source apportionment and source-specific risk assessment of bioavailable metals in river sediments of an anthropogenically influenced watershed in China

Abstract The aim of the research was to assess the quality of topsoils and stream sediments in the districts of the Katowice City of southern Poland in the Upper Silesian Industrial Agglomeration, influenced primarily by the exploitation of hard coal deposits and metallurgy. The task was carried out using indicators used to assess anthropogenic soil contamination (contamination factor CF and the Igeo geoaccumulation index), as well as ecotoxicological indicators used to determine the quality of stream sediments (Threshold Effect Concentration TEC and Probable Effect Concentration PEC). In order to indicate the most polluted areas, geochemical maps of selected elements in soil and stream sediments were developed. The material comes from the top layer of soil (0.0–0.3 m) and stream sediments located in the districts of the Katowice City. The work took into account selected potentially harmful elements (PHEs). The concentrations of elements were measured using the ICP-AES method, except for Hg (the CV-AAS method). The values of the CF and Igeo indicators allowed for the indication of high concentrations of most metals, arsenic, and sulfur in the topsoil layer, significantly exceeding the geochemical background values caused by the historical exploitation of Zn-Pb and zinc ores and ferrous metallurgy. The values of the TEC and PEC indicators classify the sediments into categories that may threaten the environment and living organisms.

Receptor model-based source apportionment and ecological risk assessment of metals in sediment of river Ganga, India

This study examined the spatio-temporality of heavy metal concentrations (Al, Cd, Co, Cr, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) in the sediments of Lake Bafa, one of the most important wetlands of Turkey’s Aegean region. The study evaluated sediment quality according to threshold effect concentration (TEC) and probable effect concentration (PEC) values based on sediment quality guidelines (SQG), and provided a potential ecological risk assessment (PERI) along with indices such as geoaccumulation index (NIgeo), enrichment factor (EF), contamination factor (CF), and pollution load index (PLI). For this purpose, surface sediment from 10 different points and core samples from three different points were seasonally collected and the concentrations of nine heavy metals were determined by ICP-MS. The findings indicated the following accumulation order of heavy metals in the sediment: Fe &gt; Al &gt; Mn &gt; Ni &gt; Cr &gt; Zn &gt; Pb &gt; Co &gt; Cd, with concentrations of Al, Mn, and Ni being high in the surface sediment samples. According to the NIgeo, surface sediment and core samples were very slightly polluted with Cr, Mn, and Co at most stations, while five stations were slightly polluted with Cd. Regarding EF, the lake was at risk in terms of Al and Pb accumulation. The CF results indicated that the lake was under pressure in terms of heavy metal pollution. The PLI results indicated a significant pollution hazard at all stations, while the PERI analysis indicated moderate risk of heavy metal pollution at some stations. As one of the most comprehensive studies applying such indices to Lake Bafa, the results are very significant in terms of evaluating the lake’s ecological sustainability.

Introduction:Unioniade is a species-rich family of freshwater mussels with an almost worldwide distribution. In Central European rivers Unio crassus, Unio tumidus and Unio pictorum have relatively high populations. In order to characterize the habitats of these suspension feeders, their nutrient supply and potential metal contaminants were investigated in near-bottom suspended (NBS) sediments and bottom sediments (BS) collected at four sampling locations along the Tisza River.Methods: The grain size distribution of sediments was determined by laser-diffraction technique. The total organic carbon (TOC) and the total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TN) were measured by a TOC analyzer and automated colorimetry, respectively. The phosphorous and metal concentrations were determined by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry following a microwave assisted acidic extraction of sediments with aqua regia.Results: The NBS sediments contained smaller grains than the BS samples, with roughly 85%–90% of the particles being less than 60 μm, allowing these mussels to catch them. Contrarily, only 2.47%–51.8% of BS samples were less than 60 μm. The NBS sediments contained 30, 23, and 15% more organic carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorous, respectively, than the BS samples. The rounded C:N:P molar ratios in the NBS sediments were 60:4:1, whereas they were 45:3:1 in the bottom sediments. The concentration of metals was also greater in the NBS sediments with the exception of Zn at Tokaj and Fe, Al, Mn, and Cr at Szeged, where prior contaminations transported by the tributaries Bodrog and Maros are stored in the top 10 cm of BS.Discussion: On basis of the measured C:N:P molar ratios it can be stated that soil-derived organic materials are the main sources of the nutrient elements in the habitats of suspension feeders in the Tisza River. The finer NBS sediments have higher specific surface area than the BS and thereby contain more biofilms on the grains resulting in higher proportion of organic nutrients and metal ions bounded as complexes or chelates. Comparing the measured metal concentrations of sediments with the concentration limits summarized in the Consensus-Based Sediment Quality Guidelines developed for evaluation of potential risk of metal contaminants in sediments for the benthic-dwelling organisms, it can be established that only the Hg concentration exceeded the probable effect concentration.