same problems through the eyes of a pediatrician in the second half? For example, the evaluation of fetal growth and fetal age is first encountered in the obstetric section. The pediatric presentation of the same problem, with the same chart, reappears 75 pages later. Although this may be the most complete discussion in the book the statement in the obstetric chapter with cross-reference to the pediatric chapter does not satisfactorily fulfill any definition of perinatology. Those concerned about the modern newborn nursery also recognize the need to break down the barriers which arbitrarily separate the members of the health team caring for the infant through the perinatal period. If this is in fact a realistic goal then the goal is not achieved by the discussion which divides the in¬ tensive of the newborn infant under the headings of physician care and nursing responsibility. The second edition has increased by 60% in both size and price over the previous edition. A resume of the ad¬ ditions to this edition provides a re¬ vealing tally of the changes that have occurred in fetal and neonatal man¬ agement between 1966 and 1971. The discussions of intrauterine and post¬ natal assessment of fetal growth, evaluation of fetal distress, prenatal detection of genetic defects, and management of erythroblastosis have either been added or expanded vastly. New additions include discussions of assisted respiration, intravenous hyperalimentation, arterial puncture, umbilical artery catheterization and phototherapy. The current and impor¬ tant topics of regional neonatal in¬ tensive and transportation of the critically ill newborn are passed over lightly and deserve greater promi¬ nence. The introduction of a discus¬ sion of pulmonary oxygen toxicity and the expanded discussion of retrolental fibroplasia provide a word of caution which is self-evident. The in¬ creased concern regarding sequelae of prematurity, the responsibilities of the social worker, and the prevention of prematurity with a discussion of problems of planned pregnancies and abortion broaden the perspective of the total problem of newborn care. The presentation itself maintains the format of the previous edition, with information presented in didac¬ tic tabular form. This is not a book which answers the question why but addresses itself to the question how. Although objection to this ap¬ proach has previously been raised, its widespread acceptance indicates that the need for such a book exists. Hav¬ ing accepted this format the need for accuracy then becomes essential, and is the single basis on which the merits of this book must be judged. Errors of omission and of fact are unaccep¬ table. Unfortunately the optimal man¬ agement for all clinical problems can¬ not always be defined. To be concise requires an objective synthesis of cur¬ rent knowledge when it is available, combined with mature personal judg¬ ment of unsettled questions. Dis¬ agreement with recommendations in these uncertain areas is permissible and cannot be viewed as a con¬ demnation. As examples, many read¬ ers may disagree with the recommen¬ dations that infants with meconium aspiration require treatment with an¬ tibiotics, or that antibiotic ointment should be applied to the umbilical stump following umbilical catheter¬ ization, or that vitamin E should be added daily to the formula, or that al¬ bumin should be administered before and after exchange transfusion, or that hydrocortisone is indicated in the treatment of sclerema. The con¬ clusion that current intensive in¬ cubators offer the protective environ¬ ment necessary for optimal is certainly questionable. More serious objections can be raised regarding omissions and inaccuracies of more firmly established recommendations. The discussions of life-threatening but curable illnesses such as polycythemia, twin-to-twin transfusion, narcotic withdrawal, and hypogly¬ cemia are either scattered so dif¬ fusely throughout the book or are so scanty as to be of little help to the uninitiated for whom this book is in¬ tended. The role of cord blood screen¬ ing for elevated macroglobulin levels is barely mentioned. Examples of factual errors include statements in¬ dicating that no placental lesions diagnostic of cytomegalic inclusion disease have been described; the ad¬ ministration of chloramphenicol to a patient with glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6-PD) deficiency may induce megaloblastic anemia; chlor¬ amphenicol may induce fetal hepatotoxicity; excluding drug related re¬ sponses, the effect of maternal hyperthyroidism on fetal thyroid function is ignored; when term is reached the conjugating mechanism of the fetus for bilirubin is mature. Finally the typographical errors are a nuisance and at times could be confusing or
Read full abstract