Post-thaw Embryo Research Articles

Cryopreservation of Rat Blastocysts: A Comparative Study of Different Cryoprotectants and Freezing/Thawing Methods

Cryopreservation has proved to be a highly successful method for long-term storage of viable embryos. The objective of this study on rat blastocysts was to define conditions for their cryopreservation. Three cryoprotectants, dimethyl sulfoxide, glycerol, and plopanediol/sucrose, were compared in two cooling programs (to -30 or -80°C) and two thawing protocols. The cooling was followed by immersion in liquid nitrogen. Programmed thawing was at the rate of 8°C per minute; fast thawing consisted of direct exposure of the frozen embryos to the ambient laboratory temperature. The survival after the freeze/thaw was assessed from the post-thaw embryo morphology and ability to develop into apparently normal offspring in uteri of foster mothers (embryonic survival). The best method for preservation of rat blastocysts proved to be programmed cooling to - 80°C followed by fast thawing with glycerol as cryoprotectant (embryonic survival of 28.1%). In all the experimental groups, the proportion of embryos with good to excellent preservation of morphology was high. With dimethyl sulfoxide, after programmed cooling to -80deg;C, embryonic survival was 9.9%'(programmed thawing) and 17.5% (fast thawing). No embryos survived after programmed cooling to -30°C. However, when the cryoprotectant was propanediol/sucrose, no difference was observed between programmed cooling to - 80°C with either method of thawing and programmed cooling to - 30°C and fast thawing (12.3, 6.2, and 8.0%, respectively).

Status of cryopreservation of embryos from domestic animals

The discovery of glycerol as an effective cryoprotectant for spermatozoa led to research on cryopreservation of embryos. The first successful offspring from frozen-thawed embryos were reported in the mouse and later in other laboratory animals. Subsequently, these techniques were applied to domestic animals. Research in cryopreservation techniques have included studies concerning the type and concentration of cryoprotectant, cooling and freezing rates, seeding and plunging temperatures, thawing temperatures and rates, and methods of cryoprotectant removal. To date, successful results based on pregnancy rates have been obtained with cryopreserved cow, sheep, goat, and horse embryos but no success has been reported in swine. Post-thaw embryo survival has been shown to be dependent on the initial embryo quality, developmental stage, and species. The freezing techniques most frequently used in research and by commercial companies are identified as “equilibrium” cryopreservation. In this technique the embryos are placed in a concentrated glycerol solution (1.4 M in PBS supplemented with BSA) at room temperature and the glycerol is allowed to equilibrate for a 20-min period. During the cooling process the straws are seeded (−4 to −7 °C) and cooling is continued at a rate of 0.3 to 0.5 °C/min to −30 °C when bovine embryos may be plunged into LN 2. Sheep embryos are successfully frozen with ethylene glycol (1.5 M) or DMSO (1.5 M) rather than with glycerol. Horse embryos have been frozen in 0.5 rather than 0.25 cc straws but with cooling rates and seeding and plunging temperatures similar to those used with bovine embryos. Swine embryos have shown a high sensitivity to temperature and cryoprotectants probably due to their high lipid content and a temperature decrease to 15 or 10 °C causes a dramatic increase in the percentage of degenerated embryos. However, a recent study has shown that hatched pig blastocysts survived exposure below 15 °C. Recent research has shown that embryos may also be frozen by a “nonequilibrium” method. This rapid freezing by vitrification consists of dehydration of the embryo at room temperature by a very highly concentrated vitrification media (3.5 to 4.0 M) and a very rapid freeze that avoids the formation of ice allowing the solution to change from a liquid to a glassy state. Vitrification solutions consist of combinations of sucrose, glycerol, and propylene glycol. With this technique, 50% pregnancy rates have been reported with the bovine blastocyst.

Analysis of cryoprotectant, cooling rate and in situ dilution using conventional freezing or vitrification for cryopreserving sheep embryos

Two studies were conducted to evaluate the influence of cryoprotectant, cooling rate, container and cryopreservation procedure on the post-thaw viability of sheep embryos. In Study 1, late morula- to blastocyst-stage embryos were exposed to 1 of 10 cryoprotectant (1.5 M, glycerol vs propylene glycol)-plunge temperature treatments. Embryos were placed in glass ampules and cooled at 1°C/min to −5°C, seeded and further cooled at 0.3°C/min to −15, −20, −25, −30 and −35°C before rapid cooling by direct placement in liquid nitrogen (LN 2). Post-thaw embryo viability was improved (P<0.01) when embryos were cooled to at least −30°C before LN 2 plunging. Although there were no overt differences in embryo viability between cryoprotectant treatments (each resulted in live offspring after embryo transfer), there was a lower (P<0.01) incidence of zona pellucida damage using propylene glycol (4%) compared to glycerol (40%). In Study 2, embryos were equilibrated in 1.5 M propylene glycol or glycerol or a vitrification solution (VS3a). Embryos treated in propylene glycol or glycerol were divided into ampule or one-step ® straw treatments, cooled to −6°C at 1°C/min, seeded, cooled at 0.5°C/min to −35°C, held for 15 minutes and then transferred to LN 2. Embryos vitrified in the highly concentrated VS3a (6.5 M glycerol + 6% bovine serum albumin) were transferred from room air to LN 2 vapor, and then stored in LN 2. Propylene glycol- and glycerol-treated embryos in straws experienced lower (P<0.05) degeneration rates (27%) and yielded more (P<0.05) hatched blastocysts (73 and 60%, respectively) at 48 hours of culture and more (P<0.05) trophoblastic outgrowths (67 and 53%, respectively) after 1 week than vitrified embryos (47, 40 and 20%, respectively). In vitro development rate for VS3a-treated embryos was similar (P>0.10) to that of ampule controls, which had fewer (P<0.05) expanded blastocysts compared to similar straw treatments. Live offspring were produced from embryos cryopreserved by each straw treatment (propylene glycol, 3 of 7; glycerol, 1 of 7; VS3a, 2 of 7). In summary, freeze-preservation of sheep embryos was more effective in one-step straws than glass ampules and propylene glycol tended to be the optimum cryoprotectant. Furthermore, these findings demonstrate, for the first time, the biological competence of sheep embryos cryopreserved using the simple and rapid procedure of vitrification.

Cooling and freezing tolarances in embryos of the Pacific oyster, Crassostrea gigas: methanol and sucrose effects

Cooling and freezing tolerances were determined for Pacific oyster, Crassostrea gigas, embryos at the 2–4-cell stage of development with or withour the addition of cryoprotective agents. Survival of embryos cooled in sea water without cryoprotectant decreased as the temperature of exposure was lowered and the exposure duration was lengthened. However, cooling tolerance varied according to embryo quality. After cooling at 0°C for 25 min, the ultrastructural arrangement of plasma membrane and the organization of organelles within the cytoplasm were disrupted. The addition of sucrose up to 0.50 M concentration to the cooled embryos slightly enhanced cooling tolerance and reduced cooling damage. In 0.50 M methanol supplemented with 0.25 M sucrose, a large quantity (46.9±0.4%) of cooled embryos survived 15 min at −6°C. At 0.50 or 1.00 M methanol concentrations with 0.25 M sucrose, a few embryos survived at −10°C and −20°C. After preservation in liquid nitrogen, most of the post-thaw embryos were damaged, regardless of methanol and sucrose concentrations, but a few were able to develop into D larvae after incubation.

Effects of equilibration time, precooling and developmental stage on the survival of mouse embryos cryopreserved by vitrification

Factorial experiments were carried out to examine the effects of equilibration time, precooling and developmental stage on the postthaw in vitro survival of vitrified mouse embryos. Eight-cell embryos, compacted morulae, or blastocysts were cryopreserved using vitrification Solution 1 (VS1; 10% glycerol + 20% propylene glycol), and vitrification Solution 2 (VS2; 25% glycerol + 25% propylene glycol) in phosphate buffered saline + 10% calf serum. Each embryo stage group was first equilibrated in VS1 for 5, 10 or 20 min and then exposed to either a precooled (∼4°C) or nonprecooled (∼20°C) VS2 in a 0.25-ml straw before they were plunged directly into liquid nitrogen. Results of this study showed an interaction between precooling, equilibration time and developmental stage which affect significantly post-thaw embryo survival (P< 0.05). High survival rates were obtained after 10 min equilibration in VS1 irrespective of the embryo developmental stage. Precooling of the VS2 significantly improved the survival mainly of blastocysts. However, eight-cell and morula-stage embryos also showed high survival rates when they were exposed to precooled VS2 after 5 min equilibration in VS1. It was further observed that morulae usually exhibit high survival rates, and vitrification conditions are more critical for early and advanced stage embryo development.

Pregnancy rates after cervical transfer of biopsied bovine embryos

Data on biopsied, sexed and cryopreserved in vitro produced (IVP) bovine embryos, and their in vivo developmental competence are very limited. Two preliminary studies were conducted before the primary study. In Experiment 1, post-thaw in vitro developmental competence of biopsied and vitrified IVP embryos was evaluated using re-expansion as an endpoint. In Experiment 2, the pregnancy rates of biopsied fresh, frozen or vitrified embryos following single embryo transfer were compared. Since vitrified embryos resulted in a higher pregnancy rate than frozen-thawed embryos, in the primary study (Experiment 3), all IVP embryos were vitrified following biopsy and sexing (by DNA fingerprinting). In Experiment 3, we compared pregnancy initiation and calving results of heifers in the following treatments: 1) artificial insemination (AI); 2) AI plus contralateral transfer of a single embryo (AI+SET); 3) ipsilateral transfer of single embryo (SET); or 4) bilateral transfer of two embryos (DET). Birth weights, gestation lengths and dystocia scores were recorded. In Experiment 1, post-thaw reexpansion rate of biopsied and vitrified embryos was 85% (7082). In Experiment 2, pregnancy rates (90 d) were 44% (716), 23% (313), and 50% (714) for vitrified, frozen and fresh embryos, respectively (P<0.10). In Experiment 3, pregnancy rates of AI and SET were 65% (2031) and 40% (1640), respectively (P<0.05). The pregnancy rate of AI+SET was 75% (2736) with 11 carrying twins, and the pregnancy rate of DET was 72% (2636) with 10 carrying twins. All AI fetuses were carried to term, but only half the SET fetuses were carried to term. Similar calving rates were observed in the AI+SET and DET groups, 76 and 70%, respectively, of those pregnant at Day 40. Mean birth weight, dystocia score and gestation length of AI calves were not different from those of SET calves. Mean birth weight and dystocia score of single-born calves were greater than those of twin born calves (P<0.05). These data demonstrate that biopsied IVP bovine embryos can be successfully cryopreserved by vitrification and following post-thaw embryo transfer, acceptable rates of offspring with normal birth weights can be obtained without major calving difficulties.

Viability of frozen-thawed mouse embryos is affected by genotype.

Embryos from mice of five different genotypes were evaluated for their ability to survive cryopreservation as measured by post-thaw in vitro development. In Study 1, ovulation was induced with a standardized pregnant mares' serum gonadotropin (PMSG)/human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) regimen, after which females were mated with males of the same genotype to produce incrossed embryos. Four- to 8-cell embryos were frozen in 1.5 M dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) at a rate of 0.5 degrees C/min to -80 degrees C and stored in liquid nitrogen. Following thawing at room temperature, embryos were cultured and development was evaluated 24 h later. The mean (+/- SEM) number of 4- to 8-cell embryos/pregnant female by stock/strain were: N:NIH(S), 6.8 +/- 0.8; N:NIH(S)-B, 5.8 +/- 0.5; N:GP(S), 6.5 +/- 0.6; C57BL/6N, 9.7 +/- 1.0; C3H/HeN MTV-, 9.5 +/- 0.9 (P less than 0.05). Post-thaw in vitro development was related to genetic background; the proportion of embryos culturing after thawing was: N:NIH(S), 49%; N:NIH(S)-B, 61%; N:GP(S), 66%; C57BL/6N, 75%; C3H/HeN MTV-, 56% (P less than 0.05). Study 2 was conducted to evaluate the influence of mating various females to males of a genotype known to have a lower post-thaw embryo survival rate. N:NIH(S)-B, N:GP(S), C57BL/6N, and C3H/HeN MTV- female mice were mated with N:NIH(S) males to produce hybrid embryos. Post-thaw embryo survival was reduced (P less than 0.05) in three of the four hybrid groups. Fresh incrossed and hybrid embryos from each study were cultured for 24 h and yielded culture rates ranging from 95% to 99% (P greater than 0.05) among all groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of ice seeding and of freezing and thawing rate on the development of sheep embryos stored at −196°C

The discovery of glycerol as an effective cryoprotectant for spermatozoa led to research on cryopreservation of embryos. The first successful offspring from frozen-thawed embryos were reported in the mouse and later in other laboratory animals. Subsequently, these techniques were applied to domestic animals. Research in cryopreservation techniques have included studies concerning the type and concentration of cryoprotectant, cooling and freezing rates, seeding and plunging temperatures, thawing temperatures and rates, and methods of cryoprotectant removal. To date, successful results based on pregnancy rates have been obtained with cryopreserved cow, sheep, goat, and horse embryos but no success has been reported in swine. Post-thaw embryo survival has been shown to be dependent on the initial embryo quality, developmental stage, and species. The freezing techniques most frequently used in research and by commercial companies are identified as “equilibrium” cryopreservation. In this technique the embryos are placed in a concentrated glycerol solution (1.4 M in PBS supplemented with BSA) at room temperature and the glycerol is allowed to equilibrate for a 20-min period. During the cooling process the straws are seeded (−4 to −7 °C) and cooling is continued at a rate of 0.3 to 0.5 °C/min to −30 °C when bovine embryos may be plunged into LN2. Sheep embryos are successfully frozen with ethylene glycol (1.5 M) or DMSO (1.5 M) rather than with glycerol. Horse embryos have been frozen in 0.5 rather than 0.25 cc straws but with cooling rates and seeding and plunging temperatures similar to those used with bovine embryos. Swine embryos have shown a high sensitivity to temperature and cryoprotectants probably due to their high lipid content and a temperature decrease to 15 or 10 °C causes a dramatic increase in the percentage of degenerated embryos. However, a recent study has shown that hatched pig blastocysts survived exposure below 15 °C. Recent research has shown that embryos may also be frozen by a “nonequilibrium” method. This rapid freezing by vitrification consists of dehydration of the embryo at room temperature by a very highly concentrated vitrification media (3.5 to 4.0 M) and a very rapid freeze that avoids the formation of ice allowing the solution to change from a liquid to a glassy state. Vitrification solutions consist of combinations of sucrose, glycerol, and propylene glycol. With this technique, 50% pregnancy rates have been reported with the bovine blastocyst.