We use the high disclosure environment for on-market buybacks in Australia to investigate whether detailed disclosure is valuable. We find that company type, buyback duration, and management motivation are all valuable signalling elements in the announcement event. These variables, which are not required in the disclosure rules of many major markets, are useful in discriminating the value of the buyback. They contribute 50% of the available explanatory power even after allowing for traditional determinants such as economic undervaluation, information signalling and lack of growth opportunities. We further consider whether firms’ actual repurchase activity communicates additional information. We find a negative relation between actual repurchases and the marginal post-announcement returns, which we interpret as evidence of strategic trading by management. Actual repurchases occur when post-announcement returns are poor, mainly as an immediate response to share price deterioration, rather than being due to any continued signalling benefit.