ObjectivesThe purpose of the study was to evaluate the integrity of dentine type I collagen after self-etching (SE) treatments with strong and mild universal adhesives. MethodsCoronal dentine specimens (n=10/product) were imaged by optical microscopy and analyzed by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy before and after treatment with 32% phosphoric acid gel (PA-negative control), 17% neutral EDTA (ED-positive control) conditioners and Adhese Universal (AD), Clearfil Universal Bond Quick (CQ), G-Premio Bond (GP), Prelude One (PR) and Scotchbond Universal (SB) adhesives. From the spectroscopic analysis the following parameters were determined: a) Extent of dentine demineralization (DM%) and b) percentage area of the Amide I curve-fitted components of β-turns, 310-helix/β-turns, α-helix, random coils, β-sheets and collagen maturation (R) index. Statistical analysis was performed by one-way ANOVA (DM%), paired t-test/Wilcoxon test (Amide I components) and Spearman correlation coefficient (DM% vs Amide I components) at an a=0.05 level. ResultsPA, ED and GP removed the smear-layer and opened tubule orifices, whereas all other treatments removed only the intratubular smear-layer fraction. The ranking of the statistically significant differences in DM% was PA>GP>ED>AD, SB, CQ, PR, with AD being significantly different from PR. Regarding the Amide I components, PA demonstrated a significant reduction in β-turns, α-helices and an increase in β-sheets, GP a reduction in β-turns, AD an increase in β-turns and random coils, and CQ an increase in β-turns. PR, SB and ED showed insignificant differences in all the Amide I components. Significant correlations were found between DM%-random coils and DM%-R. SignificanceThe universal adhesives used in the SE mode induced none to minimal changes in dentine collagen structure, without evidence of the destabilization pattern observed after conventional phosphoric acid treatments.
Read full abstract