Sir, My interest was piqued by Yel et al. [1] with their fascinating article titled, “Osteomusculocutaneous Xap for clavicular reconstruction: a case report.” The authors reported a case of persistent clavicular nonunion after pathologic fracture because of necrotic Wbrosis due to radiation for breast cancer therapy. They managed it with compound riblatissimus dorsi osteomusculocutaneous Xap and a 4 cm segment of the sixth rib. Clavicle orientation is found to rotate from a primarily craniocaudal orientation at the sternum to a primarily anteroposterior orientation at the acromion. Although it appears almost straight when viewed from the front, when viewed from above, the clavicle appears as an S-shaped double curve that is concave ventrally on its outer half and convex ventrally on its medial half. In cases of total excision of clavicle, reconstructive surgery should be considered if shoulder function is decreased. But is diYcult to restore the normal shape of clavicle, by the use of bone interposition graft, because of its particular shape. However, an anatomic reconstruction may oVer normal function of the shoulder, prevent luxation of the clavicle and satisfy cosmetic demands. Total replacement of the clavicle with vascularised and osteotomised Wbula has been already reported once [2]. Three fragments of double osteotomised Wbula with appropriate angulations were plated with two titanium compression plates and resulted to a neoclavicle, with good results to be mentioned after 2 years of follow up. But no X-rays have been provided after the follow up to conWrm the anatomical restoration of the neoclavicle. Probably with this operative technique, the shape of clavicle is restored almost anatomically in this way. This suggestion became strong when a malunion of humerus fracture resulted in S-shape, was observed in our institution. Recently, a 30-year-old man was admitted to our hospital because of a malunion of proximal humerus. He was presented with his upper extremity internally rotated. Surprisingly, his olecranon was in the front side of his upper extremity. According to his history, he was sustained a fracture of proximal diaphysis of humerus before 25 years, after a traYc accident. Because of other fatal injuries such splenic rupture, Xail chest and lung contusions, the humerus fracture was misdiagnosed. Finally, his fracture was malunited with his humerus rotated about 180°. Clinical examination was revealed a humerus which was concave ventrally on its half and a normal shoulder. His X-ray showed an S-shaped humerus like the shape of clavicle. Immediately, we hypothesized that rotation instability may be responsible for an S-shape of a long bone. As a matter of fact rotation instability leads to scoliosis deformity also. In X-rays the normal thoracic or lumbar spine it appears straight when viewed from the front, but it appears as an S-shaped in scoliosis. It is well known that idiopathic scoliosis is a threedimensional deformity of the spine combining lateral curvature with vertebral body rotation [3]. The essential lesion lies in the sagittal plane in the nature of lordosis. It has been showed that the spinal deformity in pinealectomized chickens developed rotational lordoscoliosis similar to human idiopathic scoliosis [4]. In similar way after B. Saccomanni (&) Orthopaedic and Traumatologic Surgery, University of Chieti, Via dei Vestini, 66013 Chieti Scalo, Italy e-mail: bernasacco@yahoo.it
Read full abstract