Organotin Contamination Research Articles

The Spatial Variation in Organotin Contamination in Different Environmental Media: A Case of the Lower Yangtze River in China

The Spatial Variation in Organotin Contamination in Different Environmental Media: A Case of the Lower Yangtze River in China

Determination of organotin compounds in marine sediments from Arctic Svalbard and West Antarctic Fildes Peninsula

This study investigated the contamination levels of five typical organotin compounds in Arctic and Antarctic marine sediments. Organotin total concentrations ranged from not detected (ND) to 37.9 ng Sn/g dw and from ND to 34.0 ng Sn/g dw in surface sediments of Svalbard and Fildes Peninsula, respectively. Dibutyltin accounted for 11.3 %–100 % of butyltins in Arctic sediments, whilst diphenyltin was the predominant phenyltin species in both Arctic and Antarctic. However, the concentrations of tributyltin and triphenyltin were lower than low-substituted organotins in the study areas, indicating the effectiveness of international ban on the use of triorganotin-based antifouling paints. No significant difference in organotin contamination was found between Arctic and Antarctic, although the time suffered from human interference was shorter in the Antarctic. Overall, these data can provide a diagnosis of recent organotin inputs in polar regions and serve as a baseline for future study assessing their local applications.

Occurrence of organotin compounds in food: increasing challenge of phenyltin compounds

Concentrations and distribution for 16 organotin compounds were studied in all kinds of foods, including seafood, agricultural products, and wine. Meanwhile, the degradation of the TBT or TPhT was also evaluated. Concentrations of total organotins in seafood, agricultural products, and wine were 1047.2, 469.4, and 13.5 μg Sn/kg. Meanwhile, the most frequently detected organotin in three kinds of samples were TPhT, MPhT, and MPhT, respectively. The results demonstrated that phenyltin may probably become an emerging organotin pollutant. Regarding seafood, organotin concentrations of fish and mollusks were much higher than those of crustaceans. At the same time, a significant positive correlation was observed between the concentrations of TBT and MBT (p < 0.05), and between DBT and MBT(p < 0.0001). Moreover, TPhT was significantly and positively associated with DPhT (p < 0.0001), suggesting that TPhT was the precursor of DPhT. Apart from the likely illegal use of OTs as biocides in antifouling paints for ships, anthropogenic activity like agricultural activity or industrial activity also caused organotin contamination. Further research and more effective measures should be formulated to protect the food safety. Meanwhile, monitoring of the organotin contamination should not only in Qinhuangdao, but also expand to the cities along Bohai Bay.

Grazer gastropods as alternative species for monitoring butyltins contamination in harbors

Butyltin contamination was monitored in seven Tunisian harbors using soft tissue of three grazer gastropods (the Mediterranean limpet Patella caerulea, the turbinate monodont Phorcus turbinatus and the false-limpet Siphonaria pectinata), as well as sediments from the rocky substratum. The results revealed that butyltins (BuTs) were still present in the study sites three years after the Tunisian authorities banned their use. Tributyltin (TBT) concentrations in the substratum ranged from 1.5 to 5.7 ngSn/g dw (dry weight), dibutyltin (DBT) from 2.5 to 8.3, and monobutyltin (MBT) from 6.0 to 15.7. Higher concentrations were found in gastropods, ranging from 1.2 to 6.75 ngSn/g dw for TBT, 2.6 to 42.7 ngSn/g for DBT and 2.4 to 78.5 ngSn/g dw for MBT. The species P. caerulea and P. turbinatus accumulated TBT within the same range and at a higher level than S. pectinata, making them more appropriate for monitoring organotin contamination. Furthermore, DBT and MBT accumulated markedly in P. caerulea, up to 5–8 times the concentration recorded in the other two gastropods, suggesting further utility of this species as a good bioaccumulator of BuTs. Among the seven harbors studied, Zarzouna was the most contaminated whereas Zarat was the least polluted. The contamination is directly related to vessel traffic and shipyard activity at the studied harbors. The temporal comparison with previous studies shows that BuTs contamination is decreasing and that Tunisia's prohibition of TBT is effective in terms of environmental recovery.

Organotin contamination in seafood from the Yucatán Peninsula, Mexico: Is there a potential risk for the health of consumers?

Since seafood is considered an important source of organotin compounds (OTCs), the present study assessed the potential risk to human health of ingesting butyltins (BTs) and phenyltins (PhTs) along with this type of food. Seafood samples were collected at five fishing sites in the Yucatán Peninsula (Mexico) during February and March 2018. In general, organotins were detected in all samples, suggesting a widespread occurrence of these compounds in the investigated region. The average concentration of total organotins in the muscle of demersal fish (Lutjanus synagris, Lutjanus campechanus, Calamus pennatula, Haemulon plumierii, Rhomboplites aurorubens), pelagic fish (Euthynnus alletteratus, and Opisthonema oglinum), gastropods (Melongena bispinosa and Strombus pugilis), oyster (Crassostrea virginica) and shrimp (Penaeus duorarum) was 146.7 ± 76.2, 93.1 ± 92.6, 61.0 ± 53.0, 76.7 ± 2.6, and 28.8 ± 2.7 ng Sn g−1 dry weight, respectively. Overall, MPhT among PhTs was the dominant compound in fish, while TBT among BTs was the dominant compound in shellfish. Regarding the toxic OTCs, TBT followed by DBT were the predominant compounds in all seafood species, while TPhT was below the quantification limit in most samples. The estimated daily intake values were lower than the tolerable daily intake (TDI) for the sum of organotins established by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Furthermore, the hazard quotients (HQ) and hazard indices (HI) values were all lower than 1, suggesting that daily exposure to these levels of organotins is unlikely to cause any harm to the human health of seafood consumers at the Yucatán Peninsula. Thus, consumers may not be at risk through the inclusion of these investigated seafood species in their normal diet. However, due to the increasing coastal urbanization, maritime activities, and the likely illegal use of tin-based paints in Mexico, additional monitoring is needed to assess organotin levels in other regions along the Mexican coastal zone and using other seafood species.

Organotin Contamination in Seafood from the Yucatán Peninsula, Mexico: Is There a Potential Risk for the Health of Consumers?

Organotin Contamination in Seafood from the Yucatán Peninsula, Mexico: Is There a Potential Risk for the Health of Consumers?

Tributyltin: A Bottom–Up Regulator of the Crangon crangon Population?

The restrictions and the concerted action of the global ban on the use and presence of tributyltin (TBT) in marine applications to protect ecosystems in the marine environment in 2008 was mainly based on the economic impact on shellfish industries and the dramatic extinction of local mollusc populations in the past. In contrast to the vast datasets on effects on molluscs, the knowledge on impacts on species from other taxa remained in the uncertain until almost two decades ago. The assumption on a long-term TBT-mediated pernicious metabolic bottom-up regulation of the crustacean Crangon crangon population was provoked by the outcome of an EU-project ‘Sources, Consumer Exposure and Risks of Organotin Contamination in Seafood’. This study reported high TBT body burdens in C. crangon in 2003, at the start of the transition period to the global ban. Experimental research on the TBT impact in C. crangon focused on agonistic interference with natural ecdysteroid hormones at the metabolic pathways regulating growth and reproduction and the biogeochemical distribution of the chemical. In this paper, metabolic, topical and population-relevant biological endpoints in C. crangon and other crustaceans are evaluated in relation to the temporal and spatial trends on TBT’s occurrence and distribution in the field during and after the introduction of the tributyltin restrictions and endocrine-related incidents. Arguments are forwarded to relate the German Bight incident on growth and reproduction failure in the C. crangon population, despite the lack of direct evidence, to the pernicious impact of tributyltin in 1990/91 and previous years. The extreme occurrence of TBT in C. crangon from other parts of the southern North Sea and evidence on the high body burdens as dose metrics of exposure also feeds the suspicion on detrimental impacts in those areas. This paper further demonstrates the complexity of distinguishing and assessing the individual roles of unrelated stressors on a population in an integrated evaluation at the ecosystem level.

A review of organotin contamination in arctic and subarctic regions

Abstract Organotin (OT) compounds are of continued Arctic concern as they are still widely used despite the most well-studied OT, tributyl tin (TBT), being restricted from use on marine vessels to prevent fouling by marine organisms. The highest OT concentrations found in Arctic fauna are in regions associated with human activity especially shipping. There is an overall trend of declining butyl tin (BT) concentrations in Arctic fauna especially molluscs which are the subject of a limited number of long-term monitoring studies. The incidence of imposex has likewise generally declined in molluscs in response to declining TBT concentrations. There are a number of knowledge gaps in OT occurrence and transport in the Arctic that warrant continued monitoring. OTs, in particular octyl tins, are heavily used in the production of plastic, hence leaching from plastic may be an unrecognized source to Arctic regions. This review also found several studies reporting volatile tin species in the atmosphere suggesting atmospheric transport of volatile tins to the Arctic is possible. Relative to other more well know persistent organic pollutants, there are few reports of OTs in marine mammals and temporal tend studies are needed to define trends in BTs and search for the occurrence of other tin species.

Organotin contamination in commercial and wild oysters from China: Increasing occurrence of triphenyltin

Organotin contamination in marine environment has been a public concern for many years due to its adverse impacts on biota and human health. This study investigated levels, distribution and health risks of six organotin compounds: tributyltin (TBT), dibutyltin (DBT), monobutyltin (MBT), triphenyltin (TPhT), diphenyltin (DPhT) and monophenyltin (MPhT) in commercial and wild oysters in China. The total organotin in commercial oysters ranged from 251 to 1949 ng Sn g−1 dw (dry weight) >. Two endocrine disruptors TBT and TPhT were detected in these samples with the highest level of 68.1 ± 20.1 ng Sn g−1 dw and 747 ± 7.3 ng Sn g−1 dw, respectively. For wild oysters, the concentrations of total organotins varied from 33.3 to 2671 ng Sn g−1 dw. Butyltins were dominated by TBT with the mean level of 26.1 ± 30.0 ng Sn·g−1 dw and showed no significant spatial variation between the southern and northern coastal zones (p > 0.05). However, compared with the north, phenyltin levels especially TPhT were much higher in the south coastline (246–1484 ng Sn·g−1 dw) due to the wider use of TPhT-based biocides in local mariculture and agriculture. Health risk assessment indicated that a daily exposure of TPhT-contaminated oysters (including commercial and wild ones) may pose adverse threats to human particularly children as the risk quotients (RQ) were higher than 1. Organotin contamination (e.g., TPhT) still occurs in the South China's coastal zones after the TBT ban, which deserves future research and effective measures to protect the marine ecosystem and human health.

Organotin Contamination in Sediments and Aquatic Organisms from the Yangtze Estuary and Adjacent Marine Environments

Abstract Organotin compounds are man-made metallic tin complexes with hydrocarbon substituents with broad applications in food packages, pesticides, wood preservatives, antifouling, and anticorrosion paints. Marine environments near harbors often act as sinks receiving various pollutants from urban runoff, industrial discharge, and atmospheric deposition. This study presented a pioneer analysis of butyltins (BTs) and phenyltins (PhTs) in the Yangtze estuary near one of the largest harbor regions in China. The studied estuary has extensive commercial cargo activities and underdetermined distribution and levels of organotin in sediments and different biota species. Evaluating these factors is essential for determining the risk of exposure and development of future mitigation and possible preventive measures. Seventy-two surface sediments and 13 fish and crab species samples were collected from the Yangtze estuary and its adjacent East China Sea in 2014. BTs and PhTs extracted from samples with ultrasonicati...

Population dynamics of the rock shell Reishia clavigera associated with different degrees of organotin contamination in Hong Kong

Application of organotins in antifouling systems on ship hulls has been globally prohibited by the International Maritime Organization since September 2008. It is, therefore, anticipated that there is a recovery of imposex-affected gastropod populations worldwide. We studied the population dynamics of the rock shell Reishia clavigera in six locations around Hong Kong's coastal waters, covering different degrees of organotin contamination for 25months (2011−2013). Abundance and density of R. clavigera were higher in clean sites, while they tended to grow faster in polluted sites. Over time, we observed recruitments in clean sites while recruitments in polluted sites were limited. The results suggested that the lack of apparent recovery of the local R. clavigera populations was probably due to the prevalence of organotin contamination, especially triphenyltin, in this region. This study, therefore, calls for mitigation and long-term monitoring of organotin contamination in marine environments of Hong Kong and South China.

Spatiotemporal distribution and risk assessment of organotins in the surface water of the Three Gorges Reservoir Region, China

The water quality security of the Three Gorges Reservoir during different operating periods has been a subject of recent concern. This study is the first to report the spatiotemporal variability of organotins (OTs) in surface water under dynamic water level conditions in the Three Gorges Reservoir Region (TGRR). TGRR surface water was collected during three monitoring campaigns to analyze butyltins (BTs) and phenyltins (PTs) using a gas chromatography–mass spectrometry system. Our results showed that TGRR surface water was polluted by BTs and PTs, with mono-OTs being the dominant species. A wide range of BTs and PTs concentrations was observed across the study area, but tributyltin (TBT) displayed extensive spatial distribution, and the highest concentrations consistently occurred in the downstream region of the TGRR study area, with a maximum of 393.35 ng Sn/L in Zigui (S27). The total OTs contamination level decreased over time. The diphenyltin concentration exhibited significant seasonal variation, while other OTs showed seasonal changes only during two monitoring campaigns, with the exception of dibutyltin. An ecological risk assessment indicated that both TBT and triphenyltin posed risks to aquatic organisms in TGRR surface water. We urgently recommend continuous monitoring and further measures to prevent and control OTs pollution in the TGRR.

Imposex status associated with organotin contamination in Reishia clavigera after reciprocal transplantation between clean and polluted sites in Hong Kong

Recent biomonitoring studies have showed that contaminations of triphenyltin (TPT), relative to levels of tributyltin, have become more serious in Hong Kong and other South China coasts. However, there is a lack of field-based evidence to demonstrate the casual relationship between TPT and imposex development in the rock shell Reishia clavigera in this region. This study aimed to investigate the temporal changes of imposex development and tissue concentration of six organotins (OTs) in tissues of R. clavigera after their reciprocal transplantation between relatively clean and polluted sites in Hong Kong for six months. The results revealed a significant increase of tissue concentration of total OTs, in particular TPT, in the rock shells transplanted from a clean site to a polluted site, while a decrease of tissue OT concentrations was observed in those treated conversely. Vas Deferens Sequence Index, one of the imposex indices, only increased slightly for rock shells transplanted from clean to polluted sites, while Relative Penis Size Index elevated remarkably for the same treatments. In general, the rock shells had lower tissue concentrations of OTs in winter than that in summer, though the exact mechanism is still unknown. This study has further confirmed that OT contamination is still prevalent in Hong Kong’s coastal marine waters, which necessitates tightened management controls on this group of chemicals especially on TPT compounds.

Long-Term Spatio-Temporal Trends of Organotin Contaminations in the Marine Environment of Hong Kong.

Hong Kong imposed a partial restriction on application of organotin-based antifouling paints in 1992. Since September 2008, the International Maritime Organization prohibited the use of such antifouling systems on all sea-going vessels globally. Therefore, it is anticipated a gradual reduction of organotin contamination in Hong Kong’s marine waters. Using the rock shell Reishia clavigera as a biomonitor, we evaluated the organotin contamination along Hong Kong’s coastal waters over the past two decades (1990–2015). In 2010 and 2015, adult R. clavigera were examined for imposex status and analysed for tissue concentrations of six organotins. We consistently found 100% imposex incidence in female R. clavigera across all sites. Tissue triphenyltin (TPT) concentrations were high in most samples. A probabilistic risk assessment showed that there were over 69% of chance that local R. clavigera would be at risk due to exposure to phenyltins. Comparing with those of previous surveys (2004–2010), both imposex levels and tissue concentrations of organotins did not decline, while the ecological risks due to exposure to organotins were increasing. We also observed high concentrations of monobutyltin and TPT in seawater and sediment from locations with intense shipping activities and from stormwater or sewage discharge. Overall, organotins are still prevalent in Hong Kong’s marine waters showing that the global convention alone may be inadequate in reducing organotin contamination in a busy international port like Hong Kong. Appropriate management actions should be taken to control the use and release of organotins in Hong Kong and South China.

Levels and assessment of organotin contamination at Futian Mangrove Wetland in Shenzhen, China

The concentrations of organotins (OTs) were measured in the surface sediments, mollusks and mudskippers at Futian Mangrove Wetland in Shenzhen, China, an ecologically important wetland that serves as a wintering ground and a stop-over point for migrating birds. The average concentrations of tributyltin (TBT), dibutyltin (DBT), triphenyltin (TPhT) and diphenyltin (DPhT) were 2.42, 9.11, 1.10 and 13.99 ng Sn⋅g−1 (dry weight, dw) in sediments respectively, 1.19, 5.19, 14.41 and 6.11 ng Sn⋅g−1 dw in organisms respectively. Contamination by OTs in the wetland was considered low and concentrations appeared to be declining; this decline presumably comes on the heels of China adopting in 2011, the International Convention on the Control of Harmful Anti-fouling Systems on Ships (AFS convention). However, the biota-sediment accumulation factor of TPhT was relatively high in mollusks and mudskippers. The potential ecotoxicological risk of OTs contamination to the benthic biota and those organisms at higher trophic levels, especially endangered waterfowl inhabiting wetlands, should be of concern. Further, the present study confirmed the accuracy, high stability and time-saving procedure in determination of TBT, DBT, TPhT and DPhT in sediment and organisms through the use of a high-performance liquid chromatography-inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (HPLC-ICP-MS), which may potentially be useful to a wider application in environmental monitoring with limitations of the analytical method for analysis of monobutyltin (MBT) and monophenyltin (MPhT).

Organotin contamination in seafood and its implication for human health risk in Hong Kong

Organotins (OTs) have caused widespread adverse effects on marine organisms, while they can also induce health problems to humans via consumption of contaminated seafood. This study aimed to quantify the tissue concentrations of OTs in 11 seafood species in Hong Kong, and assess the human health risk for consuming these species. The tongue sole Paraplagusia blochii had the highest concentration of total OTs. Triphenyltin (TPT) accounted for 56–97% of total OTs. The highest hazard quotient (HQ) for TPT was 1.41 in P. blochii, while the HQs for butyltins were much less than 1. The results indicated that it is likely to have certain health risks for consuming P. blochii due to its high TPT contamination. Therefore, TPT should be a priority pollutant of concern. Appropriate management actions should be taken to control its use and release in the region in order to safeguard the marine ecosystem and human health.

Imposex reduction and residual butyltin contamination in southern Brazilian harbors

The imposex incidence was appraised in South American gastropods, considering the scenario before and after the global ban of tributyltin (TBT). A statistically significant reduction in imposex indexes was observed in Stramonita haemastoma collected in 2006 and 2010 from areas under the influence of four coastal harbors from southern Brazil. This reduction may be because of the effectiveness of the global ban issued by the International Maritime Organization, although the restrictions on TBT-based antifouling paints in Brazil might also have helped. Even so, a residual organotin contamination was still detected in female tissues (levels ranged from 7.6 to 164.9 ng Sn/g for TBT; from <2 to 214.5 ng Sn/g for dibutyltin; from <3.5 to 178.8 ng Sn/g for monobutyltin; and from <1.5 to 53 ng Sn/g for triphenyltin). Thus, although a reduction in imposex and environmental levels of organotins is expected in every ocean worldwide soon after the implementation of national and international restriction regulations, this will depend on the effectiveness of the global TBT ban; the effectiveness of local restrictions on producing, selling, and using TBT-based antifouling paints; and specific characteristics of local sediments, because metabolization rates and sorption/desorption of TBT previously deposited might affect its environmental bioavailability. Therefore, the reduction trend detected in the present study cannot be extrapolated to other Brazilian or South American coastal areas.

Baseline of organotin pollution in fishes, clams, shrimps, squids and crabs collected from the west coast of India

Organotins, especially tributyltins (TBT) are highly toxic to many marine organisms. These compounds are introduced in marine waters by ship trafficking, ship scrapping activities, as antifouling compounds and sewage disposal. Marine fishes, crustaceans and molluscans are easily prone to organotins contamination. In view of this, a baseline monitoring study was conducted in order to establish the levels of organotins in edible marine fishes, bivalves, shrimps, squids and crabs collected from Mumbai, Goa and Karwar on the west coast of India. At these locations average organotin concentration found in fishes, clams, shrimps, squids and crabs was 108, 852, 179, 70 and 89ngSng−1dw, respectively. In all the samples butyltins dominated over phenyltins. The levels of organotins suggest that all the organisms were contaminated with organotins and their consumption may pose health problems to humans.

Assessment of organotin (butyltin species) contamination in marine biota from the Eastern Aegean Sea, Turkey

The marine environment continues to be adversely affected by tributyltin (TBT) release from maritime traffic. Therefore the concentrations of TBT, dibutyltin (DBT) and monobutyltin (MBT) were measured in barnacles, mussels and fish along the Eastern Aegean coastline. The average concentrations of TBT ngSng−1 were found to be 235 in fish, 116 in mussels and 635 in barnacles. The highest concentrations of TBT, DBT and MBT were observed in the barnacles which had been sampled in marinas and harbors. All mussels sampled showed values of TBT+DBT, which were below the “tolerable average residue level (TARL)” as currently accepted. This indicates a lack of risk to the consumer. However, 7 out of the 15 fish sampled displayed TBT+DBT levels above the TARL, which indicates that a fish consumer group may be at risk. Barnacles have high potential as biomonitors for the presence of organotin in the Aegean Sea.

Organotin contamination in South American coastal areas

Organotin compounds (OTs) were used in antifouling paints for more than four decades. However, due to their widespread intensive use and high toxicity, undesirable effects in non-target marine organisms have been detected since the early 1980s. Consequently, the International Maritime Organization banned new maritime applications of these products on January 1, 2003 and their presence on ship hulls from January 1, 2008. Although extensively studied in Europe, North America, Oceania, and Asia, environmental levels and effects of organotin contamination are still poorly known for South America. Thus, the current review aimed to present the actual status of this problem in South America by summarizing and comparing the available data in the literature. An overview of the OTs concentrations in sediment and biota and their effects, mainly imposex in marine gastropods, are presented. This work showed that in Atlantic coastal areas of South America there are "hot spots" of OTs contamination, similar to that observed in industrialized countries of Northern Hemisphere. On the other hand, the number of accomplished studies in the Pacific coast is extremely low. Despite the limitation on studies about OTs environmental levels and their related effects, the available data pointed out for a widespread TBT contamination along the South American coastal areas. Therefore, the establishment of baselines of organotin contamination in the Pacific coast and the implementation of temporal trend studies in the South American coastal areas is crucial to verify the effectiveness of local regulations and OTs global ban, and to map the most sensitive areas related to present and future antifouling impacts.