This article concerns comparing the grain size distribution functions of mineral powder samples and analyzes errors obtained by various measurement methods. The research used three standard and currently most frequently used methods: sieve analysis, laser diffraction analysis and vision analysis. The most important research, from the point of view of unification of results, consisted in performing precise analyses of the grain size of mineral powders (fly ash, gneiss, quartz sand and Cu ore) in various grain classes. The measurement techniques used in the research and issues related to measurement analytics were characterized. The distribution functions of the grain size distributions of the tested material samples were obtained by different measurement methods and the measurement errors were compared. Using the coefficient of variation CV calculated for characteristic particle diameters, the accuracy of measurements made using various methods was analyzed. It has been shown that different particle size measurement techniques give significantly different particle size distributions for the same material, with the grain size distribution of the measured samples having a greater impact on the results than the material itself. The lowest values of the coefficients of variation were obtained for wet sieve analysis and the highest for laser diffraction. Reliable data informing about grain size distributions were generated for further model calculations necessary to standardize the results between measurement methods.
Read full abstract