Morris was “no longer treated in himself” (132) by Communist intellectuals of the 1930s, who attempted primarily “to deploy him as an aid to facilitate the swaying of public opinion” (132). Weinroth seems unwilling to “deploy” Morris in even so reified a fashion; he “in himself” or as represented by his works is, quite simply, left unaccounted for. p e t e r sinnem a / York University Frances Hoffman and Ryan Taylor, Much To Be Done: Private Life in On tario from Victorian Diaries (Toronto: Natural Heritage/Natural History Inc., 1996). vi, 278. $19.95 paper. Carl Ballstadt, Elizabeth Hopkins, and Michael A. Peterman, eds., I Bless You in My Heart: Selected Correspondence of Catharine Parr Traill (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1996). xxi, 437. $39.95 cloth. Much To Be Done is probably best described as a series of linked essays on private life in nineteenth-century Ontario that are based on “diaries, a few extracts from letters, in addition to quotations from other publications” (vi) written chiefly during the reign of Queen Victoria (1837-1901). Each essay highlights a different aspect of domesticity in the British North Amer ican province called sequentially during this period Upper Canada, Canada West, and Ontario. Although the authors intended originally to include “only writings from the diaries of women living in Victorian Ontario ... , as the pleasure of discovering and reading diaries progressed, it became clear that there would be some input from men” (v). As a result, the essays are drawn from the works of “fifty women” and “six men” (v), whose lives are summarized briefly in a section on “Biography.” Their writings are listed in the “Bibliography” that concludes Much To Be Done along with “Ac knowledgements,” “Notes,” an “Index,” and an entry “About the Authors,” Frances Hoffman, an “oral historian” (277) at the Kitchener Public Library, and Ryan Taylor, a librarian who “began the oral history programme” (278) at this library. The National Library of Canada catalogued this volume under “OntarioSocial conditions-19th century.” It is, however, a slightly awkward produc tion, somewhere between history and literature, life documents and critical interpretation, and data, in so far as diaries and other similar writings report facts, and opinions. Yet its contents and the modesty of its presentation kept me reading and in the end gave me both instruction and delight. I was particularly intrigued by details on such topics as “Illness,” “Fu nerals and Mournings,” and “Celebrations and Holidays.” A diarist, for 105 example, who visits Lakefield, Ontario, in 1891 and meets Catharine Parr Traill, records reservations that the “venerated author” held about “current medical practice: She is 91 years old. Had Grippe [influenza] last winter and was recom mended during convalescence to take brandy and water, which she did not do. Explained afterwards to Mrs Tate that she was afraid of contracting a bad habit. (172) The Victorians’ “fear of being buried alive” was the reason, according to the authors, that a “noisy wake was considered to be a good precautionary measure” (189). Their inclusion from Sara Jeannette Duncan’s The Imperi alist (1904) of her description of “The Queen’s Birthday” and the “ ‘rhyme about it — The Twenty-fourth of May Is the Queen’s Birthday If you don’t give us a holiday, W e’ll all run away’ ” (232) took me back to my own childhood in London, Ont., where we all cheerfully chanted the ditty to honour the day — not the weekend — that still “marked the beginning of summer, when light-coloured clothes could first be worn” (232). These essays, then, provide not only glimpses “into a bygone era” (vi) but also points of departure for the postmodern and multicultural Ontario that we are today. As it happens, Much To Be Done also provides contexts for I Bless You in My Heart. This volume includes one hundred and thirty-six of the “nearly five hundred” (ix) letters of Catharine Parr Traill that are known to be ex tant. When the editors chose the letters to be published, their “immediate aim” was to “make Catharine’s personality, experiences, and interests acces sible to general as well as specialist readers” (ix). Certainly, from this point of view the...
Read full abstract