OmpF Channel Research Articles

Molecular Mechanism of Ciprofloxacin Translocation Through the Major Diffusion Channels of the ESKAPE Pathogens Klebsiella pneumoniae and Enterobacter cloacae.

Experimental studies on the translocation and accumulation of antibiotics in Gram-negative bacteria have revealed details of the properties that allow efficient permeation through bacterial outer membrane porins. Among the major outer membrane diffusion channels, OmpF has been extensively studied to understand the antibiotic translocation process. In a few cases, this knowledge has also helped to improve the efficacy of existing antibacterial molecules. However, the extension of these strategies to enhance the efficacy of other existing and novel drugs require comprehensive molecular insight into the permeation process and an understanding of how antibiotic and channel properties influence the effective permeation rates. Previous studies have investigated how differences in antibiotic charge distribution can influence the observed permeation pathways through the OmpF channel, and have shown that the dynamics of the L3 loop can play a dominant role in the permeation process. Here, we perform all-atom simulations of the OmpF orthologs, OmpE35 from Enterobacter cloacae and OmpK35 from Klebsiella pneumoniae. Unbiased simulations of the porins and biased simulations of the ciprofloxacin permeation processes through these channels provide insight into the differences in the permeation pathway and energetics. In addition, we show that similar to the OmpF channel, antibiotic-induced dynamics of the L3 loop are also operative in the orthologs. However, the sequence and structural differences, influence the extent of the L3 loop fluctuations with OmpK35 showing greater stability in unbiased runs and subdued fluctuations in simulations with ciprofloxacin.

The nonlinear concentration scaling of OmpF channel gating

The nonlinear concentration scaling of OmpF channel gating

Antibiotic Charge Profile Determines the Extent of L3 Dynamics in OmpF: An Expedited Passage for Molecules with a Positive Charge.

Efficient permeation into Gram-negative bacterial cells is a much-desired property in the design of antibacterial agents. The goal is to arrive at one or more chemical modifications of molecules that improve their uptake into the cell while maintaining a good binding affinity to the intracellular target. Previously, we proposed a mechanistic rationale for the fast permeation of bulky antibiotics that involves induced conformational dynamics in the constriction loop L3 of the OmpF channel. This flexibility is caused by the perturbation of a hydrogen bond network stabilizing the L3 loop due to the strong interactions of the positively charged moiety on the antibiotic with the residues of the L3 loop. In the present work, we examine how differences in the charge profile of antibiotic molecules can affect the permeation process, in particular, the L3 dynamics. To this end, we have performed all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to study the permeation process of molecules with differences in the net charge through the Escherichia coli OmpF channel. The results from these simulations suggest that a positively charged moiety on the antibiotic is responsible for strong interactions with the negatively charged residues of the L3 loop, promoting conformational dynamics in the L3 loop. In contrast, antibiotics without a positively charged moiety are unable to initiate such a dynamic response in the L3 loop. This distinct behavior of the L3 loop in the presence of molecules with different charge characteristics provides a plausible mechanism whereby large molecules with an appropriate charge distribution can leverage an L3 dynamic-dependent pathway to permeate efficiently. The results are relevant to the structure-based design of molecules with improved uptake properties achieved through systematic chemical modifications that effectively engage the L3 loop.

Beta-Barrel Channel Response to High Electric Fields: Functional Gating or Reversible Denaturation?

Ion channels exhibit gating behavior, fluctuating between open and closed states, with the transmembrane voltage serving as one of the essential regulators of this process. Voltage gating is a fundamental functional aspect underlying the regulation of ion-selective, mostly α-helical, channels primarily found in excitable cell membranes. In contrast, there exists another group of larger, and less selective, β-barrel channels of a different origin, which are not directly associated with cell excitability. Remarkably, these channels can also undergo closing, or “gating”, induced by sufficiently strong electric fields. Once the field is removed, the channels reopen, preserving a memory of the gating process. In this study, we explored the hypothesis that the voltage-induced closure of the β-barrel channels can be seen as a form of reversible protein denaturation by the high electric fields applied in model membranes experiments—typically exceeding twenty million volts per meter—rather than a manifestation of functional gating. Here, we focused on the bacterial outer membrane channel OmpF reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers and analyzed various characteristics of the closing-opening process that support this idea. Specifically, we considered the nearly symmetric response to voltages of both polarities, the presence of multiple closed states, the stabilization of the open conformation in channel clusters, the long-term gating memory, and the Hofmeister effects in closing kinetics. Furthermore, we contemplate the evolutionary aspect of the phenomenon, proposing that the field-induced denaturation of membrane proteins might have served as a starting point for their development into amazing molecular machines such as voltage-gated channels of nerve and muscle cells.

Influence of Membrane Asymmetry on OmpF Insertion, Orientation and Function.

The effect of asymmetric membranes containing lipopolysaccharides (LPS) on the outer membrane protein F (OmpF) reconstitution, channel orientation, and antibiotic permeation across the outer membrane was investigated. After forming an asymmetric planar lipid bilayer composed of LPS on one and phospholipids on the other side, the membrane channel OmpF was added. The ion current recordings demonstrate that LPS has a strong influence on the OmpF membrane insertion, orientation, and gating. Enrofloxacin was used as an example of an antibiotic interacting with the asymmetric membrane and with OmpF. The enrofloxacin caused the blockage of the ion current through the OmpF, depending on the side of addition, the transmembrane voltage applied, and the composition of the buffer. Furthermore, the enrofloxacin changed the phase behavior of the LPS-containing membranes, demonstrating that its membrane activity influences the function of OmpF and potentially the membrane permeability.

Single-Molecule Imaging of Lateral Mobility and Ion Channel Activity in Lipid Bilayers using Total Internal Reflection Fluorescence (TIRF) Microscopy.

High-resolution imaging techniques have shown that many ion channels are not static, but subject to highly dynamic processes, including the transient association of pore-forming and auxiliary subunits, lateral diffusion, and clustering with other proteins. However, the relationship between lateral diffusion and function is poorly understood. To approach this problem, we describe how lateral mobility and activity of individual channels in supported lipid membranes can be monitored and correlated using total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF) microscopy. Membranes are fabricated on an ultrathin hydrogel substrate using the droplet interface bilayer (DIB) technique. Compared to other types of model membranes, these membranes have the advantage of being mechanically robust and suitable for highly sensitive analytical techniques. This protocol measures Ca2+ ion flux through single channels by observing the fluorescence emission of a Ca2+-sensitive dye in close proximity to the membrane. In contrast to classical single-molecule tracking approaches, no fluorescent fusion proteins or labels, which can interfere with lateral movement and function in the membrane, are required. Possible changes in ion flux associated with conformational changes of the protein are only due to protein lateral motion in the membrane. Representative results are shown using the mitochondrial protein translocation channel TOM-CC and the bacterial channel OmpF. In contrast to OmpF, the gating of TOM-CC is very sensitive to molecular confinement and the nature of lateral diffusion. Hence, supported droplet-interface bilayers are a powerful tool to characterize the link between lateral diffusion and the function of ion channels.

Cephalosporin translocation across enterobacterial OmpF and OmpC channels, a filter across the outer membrane

Gram-negative porins are the main entry for small hydrophilic molecules. We studied translocation of structurally related cephalosporins, ceftazidime (CAZ), cefotaxime (CTX) and cefepime (FEP). CAZ is highly active on E. coli producing OmpF (Outer membrane protein F) but less efficient on cells expressing OmpC (Outer membrane protein C), whereas FEP and CTX kill bacteria regardless of the porin expressed. This matches with the different capacity of CAZ and FEP to accumulate into bacterial cells as quantified by LC-MS/MS (Liquid Chromatography Tandem Mass Spectrometry). Furthermore, porin reconstitution into planar lipid bilayer and zero current assays suggest permeation of ≈1,000 molecules of CAZ per sec and per channel through OmpF versus ≈500 through OmpC. Here, the instant killing is directly correlated to internal drug concentration. We propose that the net negative charge of CAZ represents a key advantage for permeation through OmpF porins that are less cation-selective than OmpC. These data could explain the decreased susceptibility to some cephalosporins of enterobacteria that exclusively express OmpC porins.

Designer Outer Membrane Protein Facilitates Uptake of Decoy Molecules into a Cytochrome P450BM3-Based Whole-Cell Biocatalyst.

We report an OmpF loop deletion mutant, which improves the cellular uptake of external additives into an Escherichia coli whole-cell biocatalyst. Through co-expression of the OmpF mutant with wild-type P450BM3 in the presence of decoy molecules, the yield of the whole-cell biotransformation of benzene could be considerably improved. Notably, with the decoy molecule C7AM-Pip-Phe the yield duodecupled from 5.7 % to 70 %, with 80 % phenol selectivity. The benzylic hydroxylation of alkyl- and cycloalkylbenzenes was also examined, and with the aid of decoy molecules, propylbenzene and tetralin were converted to 1-hydroxylated products with 78 % yield and 94 % (R) ee for propylbenzene and 92 % yield and 94 % (S) ee for tetralin. Our results suggest that both the decoy molecule and substrate traverse the artificial OmpF channel, synergistically boosting whole-cell bioconversions.

Kanamycin Uptake into Escherichia coli Is Facilitated by OmpF and OmpC Porin Channels Located in the Outer Membrane

Despite decades of therapeutic application of aminoglycosides, it is still a matter of debate if porins contribute to the translocation of the antibiotics across the bacterial outer membrane. Here, we quantified the uptake of kanamycin across the major porin channels OmpF and OmpC present in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. Our analysis revealed that, despite its relatively large size, about 10-20 kanamycin molecules per second permeate through OmpF and OmpC under a 10 μM concentration gradient, whereas OmpN does not allow the passage. Molecular simulations elucidate the uptake mechanism of kanamycin through these porins. Whole-cell studies with a defined set of E.coli porin mutants provide evidence that translocation of kanamycin via porins is relevant for antibiotic potency. The values are discussed with respect to other antibiotics.

Lipid Headgroup Charge and Acyl Chain Composition Modulate Closure of Bacterial β-Barrel Channels.

The outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria contains β-barrel proteins that form high-conducting ion channels providing a path for hydrophilic molecules, including antibiotics. Traditionally, these proteins have been considered to exist only in an open state so that regulation of outer membrane permeability was accomplished via protein expression. However, electrophysiological recordings show that β-barrel channels respond to transmembrane voltages by characteristically switching from a high-conducting, open state, to a so-called ‘closed’ state, with reduced permeability and possibly exclusion of large metabolites. Here, we use the bacterial porin OmpF from E. coli as a model system to gain insight on the control of outer membrane permeability by bacterial porins through the modulation of their open state. Using planar bilayer electrophysiology, we perform an extensive study of the role of membrane lipids in the OmpF channel closure by voltage. We pay attention not only to the effects of charges in the hydrophilic lipid heads but also to the contribution of the hydrophobic tails in the lipid-protein interactions. Our results show that gating kinetics is governed by lipid characteristics so that each stage of a sequential closure is different from the previous one, probably because of intra- or intermonomeric rearrangements.

On mechanisms of colicin import: the outer membrane quandary.

Current problems in the understanding of colicin import across the Escherichia coli outer membrane (OM), involving a range of cytotoxic mechanisms, are discussed: (I) Crystal structure analysis of colicin E3 (RNAase) with bound OM vitamin B12 receptor, BtuB, and of the N-terminal translocation (T) domain of E3 and E9 (DNAase) inserted into the OM OmpF porin, provide details of the initial interaction of the colicin central receptor (R)- and N-terminal T-domain with OM receptors/translocators. (II) Features of the translocon include: (a) high-affinity (Kd ≈ 10-9 M) binding of the E3 receptor-binding R-domain E3 to BtuB; (b) insertion of disordered colicin N-terminal domain into the OmpF trimer; (c) binding of the N-terminus, documented for colicin E9, to the TolB protein on the periplasmic side of OmpF. Reinsertion of the colicin N-terminus into the second of the three pores in OmpF implies a colicin anchor site on the periplasmic side of OmpF. (III) Studies on the insertion of nuclease colicins into the cytoplasmic compartment imply that translocation proceeds via the C-terminal catalytic domain, proposed here to insert through the unoccupied third pore of the OmpF trimer, consistent with in vitro occlusion of OmpF channels by the isolated E3 C-terminal domain. (IV) Discussion of channel-forming colicins focuses mainly on colicin E1 for which BtuB is receptor and the OM TolC protein the proposed translocator. The ability of TolC, part of a multidrug efflux pump, for which there is no precedent for an import function, to provide a trans-periplasmic import pathway for colicin E1, is questioned on the basis of an unfavorable hairpin conformation of colicin N-terminal peptides inserted into TolC.

Fluctuation-Driven Transport in Biological Nanopores. A 3D Poisson–Nernst–Planck Study

Living systems display a variety of situations in which non-equilibrium fluctuations couple to certain protein functions yielding astonishing results. Here we study the bacterial channel OmpF under conditions similar to those met in vivo, where acidic resistance mechanisms are known to yield oscillations in the electric potential across the cell membrane. We use a three-dimensional structure-based theoretical approach to assess the possibility of obtaining fluctuation-driven transport. Our calculations show that remarkably high voltages would be necessary to observe the actual transport of ions against their concentration gradient. The reasons behind this are the mild selectivity of this bacterial pore and the relatively low efficiencies of the oscillating signals characteristic of membrane cells (random telegraph noise and thermal noise).

Effect of natural polymorphism on structure and function of the Yersinia pestis outer membrane porin F (OmpF protein): a computational study

The Yersinia pestis outer membrane porin F (OmpF) is a transmembrane protein located in the outer membrane of this Gram-negative bacterium which is the causative agent of plague, where it plays a significant role in controlling the selective permeability of the membrane. The amino acid sequences of OmpF proteins from 48 Y. pestis strains representing all currently available phylogenetic groups of this Gram-negative bacterium were recently deduced. Comparison of these amino acid sequences revealed that the OmpF can be present in four isoforms, the pestis-pestis type, and the pestis-microtus types I, II, and III. OmpF of the most recent pestis-pestis type has an alanine residue at the position 148, where all the pestis-microtus types have threonine there (T148A polymorphism). The variability of different pestis-microtus types is caused by an additional polymorphism at the 193rd position, where the OmpFs of the pestis-microtus type II and type III have isoleucine-glycine (IG+193) or isoleucine-glycine-isoleucine-glycine (IGIG+193) insertions, respectively (IG+193 and IGIG+193 polymorphism). To investigate potential effects of these sequence polymorphisms on the structural properties of the OmpF protein, we conducted multi-level computational analysis of its isoforms. Analysis of the I-TASSER-generated 3D-models revealed that the Yersinia OmpF is very similar to other non-specific enterobacterial porins. The T148A polymorphism affected a loop located in the external vestibule of the OmpF channel, whereas IG+193 and IGIG+193 polymorphisms affected one of its β-strands. Our analysis also suggested that polymorphism has moderate effect on the predicted local intrinsic disorder predisposition of OmpF, but might have some functional implementations.

Quantification of Fluoroquinolone Uptake through the Outer Membrane Channel OmpF of Escherichia coli.

Decreased drug accumulation is a common cause of antibiotic resistance in microorganisms. However, there are few reliable general techniques capable of quantifying drug uptake through bacterial membranes. We present a semiquantitative optofluidic assay for studying the uptake of autofluorescent drug molecules in single liposomes. We studied the effect of the Escherichia coli outer membrane channel OmpF on the accumulation of the fluoroquinolone antibiotic, norfloxacin, in proteoliposomes. Measurements were performed at pH 5 and pH 7, corresponding to two different charge states of norfloxacin that bacteria are likely to encounter in the human gastrointestinal tract. At both pH values, the porins significantly enhance drug permeation across the proteoliposome membranes. At pH 5, where norfloxacin permeability across pure phospholipid membranes is low, the porins increase drug permeability by 50-fold on average. We estimate a flux of about 10 norfloxacin molecules per second per OmpF trimer in the presence of a 1 mM concentration gradient of norfloxacin. We also performed single channel electrophysiology measurements and found that the application of transmembrane voltages causes an electric field driven uptake in addition to concentration driven diffusion. We use our results to propose a physical mechanism for the pH mediated change in bacterial susceptibility to fluoroquinolone antibiotics.

Current Fluctuation Analysis in a Protein Nanopore

Current fluctuation analysis has been widely used over the recent years to study the kinetic effects of different biological systems like neuronal networks or biomembranes. In particular, noise analysis has been successfully employed in protein ion channels to investigate the transport mechanisms that control the channel function. In this work, current fluctuations are analyzed in a protein nanopore, OmpF from E. coli. The study is performed for different electrolytes, including KCl, LiCl, MgCl2, and CaCl2, over a wide range of concentrations and voltages. Previous studies addressing current fluctuations in OmpF investigated the pH titration of the channel residues by analyzing the Lorentzian-like shape of the power spectral densities [1]. A complementary approach is followed here, based on the noise studies of Hoogerheide and colleagues in synthetic nanopores [2]. Special attention is paid to the additional white noise seen in the low frequency range of the power spectral density. The average noise scales with the square of the dc current, showing that this frequency−independent excess noise originates from conductance fluctuations. These fluctuations are analyzed here in terms of the ionic concentration to disclose the different transport mechanisms occurring in OmpF channel.[1] E.M. Nestorovich et al. (2003) Biophys. J. 85:3718−3729[2] D.P. Hoogerheide et al. (2009) Phys. Rev. Lett. 102:256804

Specific or General - It is All About Solute Interactions with the Pore

Recently, Kojima and Nikaido (PNAS, 110: E2629, 2014) examined the idea of potential specificity of porin channels, where -lactam antibiotics’ interaction with the pore-lining residues, demonstrated in vitro, was suggested to facilitate transmembrane transport (PNAS, 99:9789, 2002). The authors came to a conclusion that the binding inside OmpF channel does not significantly affect the penetration of ampicillin and benzylpenicillin.While we emphatically agree with the authors that attractive interactions per se do not constitute the leading imperative in search for an antibiotic with the “magic bullet” potential, it would be surprising if Nature (or pharmaceutical companies, by trial and error) had not explored the benefits of these interactions to facilitate antibiotic translocation. Indeed, the probability of translocation through the OmpF pore for the molecule of ampicillin size that is already at the channel entrance could be estimated as a fraction of one percent (JCP, 116:9952, 2002). This is an impressively small number.The presence of optimal attractive interactions is able to compensate for the entropic cost of confinement (Biochemistry, 52:9246, 2013) and thus increase the translocation probability to 0.5, its maximum value for passive, although interaction-assisted, diffusion. Certainly, not every attractive interaction is optimal or even beneficial for translocation. Too strong or wrongly distributed binding can be detrimental. However, attractive interactions in a particular channel-solute pair are able, at least in principle, to transform a porin, which is “general” for many other solutes, into a “specific” one for the particular pair.

Entropy-enthalpy compensation at the single protein level: pH sensing in the bacterial channel OmpF.

The pH sensing mechanism of the OmpF channel operates via ligand modification: increasing acidity induces the replacement of cations with protons in critical binding sites decreasing the channel conductance. Aside from the change in enthalpy associated with the binding, there is also a change in the microscopic arrangements of ligands, receptors and the surrounding solvent. We show that the pH-modulation of the single channel conduction involves small free energy changes because large enthalpic and entropic contributions change in opposite ways, demonstrating an approximate enthalpy-entropy compensation for different salts and concentrations.

High Salt Concentrations Increase Permeability through OmpC Channels of Escherichia coli

OmpF and OmpC porin channels are responsible for the passage of small hydrophilic solutes across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. Although these channels are two of the most extensively studied porin channels, what had yet remained elusive was the reason why OmpC shows markedly lower permeability than OmpF, despite having little difference in its channel size. The OmpC channel, however, is known to contain a larger number of ionizable residues than the OmpF channel. In this study, we examined the channel property of OmpF and OmpC using the intact cell of E. coli, and we found that the permeability of several β-lactams and lactose through OmpC became increased to the level comparable with OmpF with up to 0.3 m salt that may increase the Debye-Hückel shielding or with 2% ethanol or 0.3 m urea that may perturb the short range ordering of water molecules. Replacing 10 pore-lining residues that show different ionization behavior between OmpC and OmpF led to substantial conversion of channel property with respect to their permeability and response to external salt concentration. We thus propose that the overall configuration of ionizable residues in the channel that may orient water molecules and the electrostatic profile of the channel play a decisive role in defining the channel property of the OmpC porin rather than its channel size.

Experimental Observation of Surface Charge Inversion in a Biological Nanopore in Presence of Monovalent and Multivalent Cations

The electric double layer formed at the pore surface produces the exclusion of coions and the accumulation of counterions. A particularly captivating situation occurs when interfacial charges attract counterions in excess of their own nominal charge, thus leading to an effective charge inversion of the system. This phenomenon has been reported in such diverse systems like lipid vesicles, colloids, Langmuir monolayers, membranes, flexible polyelectrolytes and other synthetic nanodevices that are in contact with an aqueous solution containing multivalent ions. Here, we report experimental evidence of charge inversion in the bacterial channel OmpF of E. coli, not only in presence of multivalent cations but also in presence of monovalent ones. We perform reversal potential experiments in different conditions of pH and salt concentration to analyze both the effect of cation type and size in the selectivity changes.

Electrostatic Interactions Drive the Nonsteric Directional Block of OmpF Channel by La3+

Ion channels regulate the transport of molecules and the electric signal transduction in living cells by means of complex and even highly sophisticated mechanisms. We focus here on the crucial role that polyvalent ions, well-known modulators of many biological nanosystems, play in ion channel function. In particular, we show that trace amounts of lanthanum are able to block the bacterial porin OmpF, a large biological pore of Escherichia coli wide enough to exchange antibiotics and other larger molecules. The underlying mechanism has a strong directional character: it is sensitive to the sign of the applied voltage and to the side of the blocker addition. We explore these channel features by combining planar lipid bilayer electrophysiology at the single channel level, site-directed mutagenesis, and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). In contrast to other well-described channel blockers, which seem to occlude the narrower part of the pore, we envisage a nonsteric mechanism based on electrostatic interactions.