Previous research has shown that routine screening labs for patients with mental health complaints being admitted to psychiatry has low yield for finding unexpected pathology. Despite this, it is nearly universal practice for patients to undergo various routine screening labs tests prior to psychiatric admission. Eliminating a policy of routine lab ordering has potential to reduce costs without adversely affecting patient care. However, to our knowledge such a policy has not been adopted by any large hospital or care network. The objective of this study was to describe the effects of a hospital change in policy no longer requiring screening labs on cost of care and patient safety measures. This retrospective cohort study analyzed data from a cohort of patients admitted to a large tertiary care hospital four months before and four months after (allowing for a one-month washout period immediately after) the screening laboratory policy change. All patients who presented to the emergency department and were admitted to the inpatient psychiatry service were included. Data were obtained from an automated query of electronic health records. The primary outcome measure was the number of laboratory tests ordered both in the emergency department as well as during the inpatient stay before and after the policy change. Secondary measures included the number of hospital medicine or specialty consultations while admitted, the number of patient transfers to non-psychiatry services, and number of inpatient deaths. Statistical tests for differences between groups utilized chi square tests for categorical variables and Wilcoxon rank sum tests for continuous variables which were non-normally distributed. 1599 patients were included in the analysis (pre = 659; post = 900). Patient demographics and admitting diagnoses were similar between the groups. The total median number of lab tests ordered during the hospital stay decreased from 3 (IQR, 2) to 2 (IQR, 3) [P<0.0001]. Contributing to this overall decrease was a decrease in the number of tests ordered in the ED and a slight increase in the lab tests ordered on the psychiatry unit. The total median lab charges (ED arrival to hospital discharge) decreased from $399 (IQR, $299) to $304 (IQR, 423) [P<0.0001]. In addition, the number of patients with no labs ordered in the ED increased from 77 (11.7%) to 335 (35.7%) [p<0.0001]. The length of stay in the ED decreased from 529.0 minutes (IQR, 721.0) to 451.5 minutes (IQR, 560) [p<0.0001]. The length of stay in the hospital decreased from 102.65 hours to 97.00 hours (p=0.0465). There were no increases in consultations during the inpatient stay or transfers to hospital medicine after the change. No patients were transferred from psychiatry to an intensive care unit at any point, and no patients died. A policy that avoids routine lab orders for patients admitted to psychiatry can save money and improve ED throughput without increasing adverse outcomes. These data provide support for other hospitals to adopt similar policy changes, with the potential to decrease cost of care for this patient population.
Read full abstract