Nucleotide Analog Interference Mapping Research Articles

Strategies for Characterization of Enzymatic Nucleic Acids.

Practical application of enzymatic nucleic acids has received more attention in recent years. Understanding the mechanism of catalysis and availability of information on potentials and limitations of these enzymes expands their application scope. A general approach for characterization of functional macromolecules including enzymatic nucleic acids is to perturb a specific set of condition and to follow the perturbation effect by biophysical and biochemical methods. This chapter reviews several perturbation strategies for functional nucleic acids, including deletion, mutation, and modifications of backbone and nucleobases, and consequent kinetic analysis, spectroscopic investigations, and probing assays. In addition to single point mutation and modifications, different combinatorial approaches for perturbation interference analysis provide reliable high amounts of data in a time-effective manner. The chapter compares various combinatorial perturbation interference analysis methods, that is, combinatorial mutation interference analysis (CoMA), nucleotide analogue interference mapping for RNA and DNA (NAIM and dNAIM), chemical and enzymatic combinatorial nucleoside deletion scanning (NDS), and dimethyl sulfate interference (DMSi).

Functional Hallmarks of a Catalytic DNA that Makes Lariat RNA.

Catalytic DNAs, also known as deoxyribozymes, are of practical value for the synthesis of structurally or topologically complex RNAs, but little is known about the molecular details of DNA catalysis. We have investigated a deoxyribozyme that catalyzes the formation of a specific intramolecular 2',5'-phosphodiester bond to produce lariat RNA, which is an important biological intermediate in eukaryotic mRNA splicing. The results of combinatorial mutation interference analysis (CoMA) allowed us to shrink the catalytic core to 70 % of its original length and revealed that the essential part of the deoxyribozyme sequence contained more than 50 % guanosines. Nucleotide analogue interference mapping (dNAIM) and dimethyl sulfate interference (DMSi) experiments provided atomic details of individual guanosine functional groups. Additional spectroscopic experiments and structural probing data identified conformational changes upon metal-ion binding and catalysis. Overall, this comprehensive analysis of the DNA-catalyzed reaction has provided specific insights into the synthesis of 2',5'-branched RNA, and suggested the general features of deoxyribozymes that catalyze nucleic acid ligation reactions.

Nucleotide analog interference mapping.

Methods collectively known as modification interference are exceptionally powerful approaches used to identify functionally important chemical groups in the phosphodiester backbone or nucleobases of an RNA. In a modification interference assay, end-labeled RNAs that have been modified at different positions are allowed to participate in a reaction of interest, and then functional RNA molecules (e.g., those bound by protein or that successfully participate in a processing reaction) are separated from nonfunctional RNA molecules (e.g., those not bound by protein or unable to participate in a processing reaction). Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) involves the incorporation of α-thionucleotides containing a modified base into the RNA molecule of interest. The sites containing the modified base are identified by cleavage with iodoethanol. NAIM is useful whenever the thiophosphate substitution on its own does not prevent or inhibit a specific reaction. To perform NAIM, it is first necessary to perform a thiophosphate interference analysis. Any positions that are not affected by thiophosphate substitution can then be analyzed by NAIM.

Personal reflection (RNA journal 20th anniversary).

Personal reflection (RNA journal 20th anniversary).

The Brace for a Growing Scaffold: Mss116 Protein Promotes RNA Folding by Stabilizing an Early Assembly Intermediate

The ai5γ group II intron requires a protein cofactor to facilitate native folding in the cell. Yeast protein Mss116 greatly accelerates intron folding under near-physiological conditions both in vivo and in vitro. Although the effect of Mss116 on the kinetics of ai5γ ribozyme folding and catalysis has been extensively studied, the precise structural role and interaction sites of Mss116 have been elusive. Using Nucleotide Analog Interference Mapping to study the folding of splicing precursor constructs, we have identified specific intron functional groups that participate in Mss116-facilitated folding and we have determined their role in the folding mechanism. The data indicate that Mss116 stabilizes an early, obligate folding intermediate within intron domain 1, thereby laying the foundation for productive folding to the native state. In addition, the data reveal an important role for the IBS2 exon sequence and for the terminus of domain 6, during the folding of self-splicing group IIB intron constructs.

Probing Essential Nucleobase Functional Groups in Aptamers and Deoxyribozymes by Nucleotide Analogue Interference Mapping of DNA

Nucleotide analogue interference mapping of DNA (dNAIM) is here introduced as a new nonenzymatic interference-based approach that enables high-throughput identification of essential nucleobase functional groups in DNA aptamers and in the catalytic core of deoxyribozymes. Nucleobase-modified ribonucleotides are statistically incorporated into DNA by solid-phase synthesis, employing the 2'-OH group as a chemical tag for analysis of interference effects. This method is exemplified on an AMP-binding DNA aptamer and was further used to identify indispensable nucleobase functional groups for DNA-catalyzed RNA-ligation by the Mg(2+)-dependent deoxyribozymes 7S11 and 9DB1. dNAIM should prove broadly useful for facile structural probing of functional DNA for which active and inactive variants can be separated based on catalytic or ligand-binding activities.

Catalytic Importance of a Protonated Adenosine in the Hairpin Ribozyme Active Site

The hairpin ribozyme accelerates the rate of phosphodiester transfer reactions by at least 5 orders of magnitude. To achieve this rate enhancement, the active site forms via a substrate helix docking event that constrains the scissile phosphate linkage and positions G8 and A38 for catalysis, both of which have been implicated as sites of proton transfer in general acid-base catalysis. To investigate the functional groups required for hairpin activity, we previously reported a series of nucleotide analogue interference mapping experiments [Ryder, S. P., et al. (2001) RNA 7, 1454-1463]. The critical functional groups implicated in those studies were largely consistent with subsequent X-ray crystal structures, but the lack of A38 interference with 8-azaadenosine (n(8)A), a pK(a) perturbed nucleotide analogue, argued against functional base ionization at this site. This is inconsistent with a transition state crystal structure and other biochemical studies. To address this discrepancy, we investigated the hairpin ribozyme with an expanded set of pK(a) perturbed adenosine analogues containing fluorine. A38 was the only site that showed persistent and strong interference with low pK(a) analogues across a variety of construct/substrate pairs. This interference pattern suggests that A38 base ionization is required for catalytic activity. The lack of n(8)A interference at A38, in spite of its reduced pK(a), likely results from n(8)A stabilization of the docked state, which requires an unusual syn glycosidic base conformation at A38 for active site assembly. The fluorinated adenosine analogues are better suited to identify sites of functional ionization in systems where structural rearrangements are closely coupled to catalytic steps. All pK(a) reduced analogues, including those of the previous study, produce selective interference at A38 when substrates are stably bound and docked, consistent with the importance of base ionization at this site.

Improving small-angle X-ray scattering data for structural analyses of the RNA world.

Defining the shape, conformation, or assembly state of an RNA in solution often requires multiple investigative tools ranging from nucleotide analog interference mapping to X-ray crystallography. A key addition to this toolbox is small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). SAXS provides direct structural information regarding the size, shape, and flexibility of the particle in solution and has proven powerful for analyses of RNA structures with minimal requirements for sample concentration and volumes. In principle, SAXS can provide reliable data on small and large RNA molecules. In practice, SAXS investigations of RNA samples can show inconsistencies that suggest limitations in the SAXS experimental analyses or problems with the samples. Here, we show through investigations on the SAM-I riboswitch, the Group I intron P4-P6 domain, 30S ribosomal subunit from Sulfolobus solfataricus (30S), brome mosaic virus tRNA-like structure (BMV TLS), Thermotoga maritima asd lysine riboswitch, the recombinant tRNA(val), and yeast tRNA(phe) that many problems with SAXS experiments on RNA samples derive from heterogeneity of the folded RNA. Furthermore, we propose and test a general approach to reducing these sample limitations for accurate SAXS analyses of RNA. Together our method and results show that SAXS with synchrotron radiation has great potential to provide accurate RNA shapes, conformations, and assembly states in solution that inform RNA biological functions in fundamental ways.

Phosphate residues of antigenomic HDV ribozyme important for catalysis that are revealed by phosphorothioate modification

The aim of our study was to obtain new details on the role of phosphate residues in antigenomic hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme for the development of metal ion binding sites and their participation in the cleavage mechanism. In these studies, the wild-type ribozyme and four in vitro selected variants, R37, R20, R25 and R51, were used. The application of nucleotide phosphorothioates and the NAIM (nucleotide analog interference mapping) technique for the cis-acting ribozymes, wild-type, R25 and R51, revealed the importance of the J4/2 and P1.1 regions in the catalysis. Interestingly, in the wild-type ribozyme, the largest interference effects were observed close to catalytic C76 in the presence of Ca2+, while in the case of Mg2+ were in the structurally important helix P1.1. The results obtained for R25 and R51 suggest different coordination of the divalent ions to the phosphate residues within the ribozyme catalytic core. Additionally, replacing the non-bridging oxygen atoms on sulfur in a phosphate group at the cleavage site in trans-acting ribozyme variants showed that interactions between pro-RP and pro-SP oxygen atoms, and catalytic metal ions, had moderate effects on the cleavage reaction. In the wild-type ribozyme, the ratio of SP/RP isomer cleavage rates decreased from 25 for Mg2+-induced cleavage to ca. 4 when thiophilic Mn2+ or Cd2+ were added; thus a “rescue effect” was observed. Interestingly, the R37, R20, R25 and R51 ribozymes showed a reduced RP/SP ratio of cleavage rates and much smaller “rescue effects”. This suggests that the binding of divalent metal ions in the vicinity of the phosphate group at the cleavage site is very sensitive to the overall ribozyme structure.

A stepwise 2′-hydroxyl activation mechanism for the bacterial transcription termination factor Rho helicase

The bacterial Rho factor is a ring-shaped ATP-dependent helicase that tracks along RNA transcripts and disrupts RNA-DNA duplexes and transcription complexes in its path. Using combinatorial nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM), we explore the topology and dynamics of functional Rho-RNA complexes and reveal the RNA-dependent stepping mechanism of Rho helicase. Periodic Gaussian distributions of NAIM signals show that Rho forms uneven productive interactions with the track nucleotides and disrupts RNA-DNA duplexes in a succession of large ( approximately 7-nucleotide-long) discrete steps triggered by 2'-hydroxyl activation events. This periodic 2'-OH-dependent activation does not depend on the RNA-DNA pairing energy but is finely tuned by sequence-dependent interactions with the RNA track. These features explain the strict RNA specificity and contextual efficiency of the enzyme and provide a new paradigm for conditional tracking by a helicase ring.

RNA biophysics has come of age

RNA biophysics has come of age

Fluorine Substituted Adenosines As Probes of Nucleobase Protonation in Functional RNAs

Ionized nucleobases are required for folding, conformational switching, or catalysis in a number of functional RNAs. A common strategy to study these sites employs nucleoside analogues with perturbed pKa, but the interpretation of these studies is often complicated by the chemical modification introduced, in particular modifications that add, remove, or translocate hydrogen bonding groups in addition to perturbing pKa values. In the present study we present a series of fluorine substituted adenosine analogues that produce large changes in N1 pKa values with minimal structural perturbation. These analogues include fluorine for hydrogen substitutions in the adenine ring of adenosine and 7-deaza-adenosine with resulting N1 pKa values spanning more than 4 pKa units. To demonstrate the utility of these analogues we have conducted a nucleotide analogue interference mapping (NAIM) study on a self-ligating construct of the Varkud Satellite (VS) ribozyme. We find that each of the analogues is readily incorporated by T7 RNA polymerase and produces fully active transcripts when substituted at the majority of sites. Strong interferences are observed for three sites known to be critical for VS ribozyme function, most notably A756. Substitutions at A756 lead to slight enhancements in activity for elevated pKa analogues and dramatic interferences in activity for reduced pKa analogues, supporting the proposed catalytic role for this base. The structural similarity of these analogues, combined with their even incorporation and selective interference, provides an improved method for identifying sites of adenosine protonation in a variety of systems.

Dissecting RNA folding by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM).

Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) is a powerful chemogenetic approach that allows RNA structure and function to be characterized at the atomic level. Random modifications of base or backbone moieties are incorporated into the RNA transcript as nucleotide analog phosphorothioates. The resulting RNA pool is then subjected to a stringent selection step, in which the RNA has to accomplish a specific task, for example, folding. RNA functional groups important for this process can be identified by physical isolation of the functional and the nonfunctional RNA molecules and subsequent mapping of the modified nucleotide positions in both RNA populations by iodine cleavage of the susceptible phosphorothioate linkage. This approach has been used to analyze a variety of aspects of RNA biochemistry, including RNA structure, catalysis and ligand interaction. Here, I describe how to set up a NAIM assay for studying RNA folding. This protocol can be readily adapted to study any RNAs and their properties. The time required to complete the experiment is dependent on the length of the RNA and the number of atomic modifications tested. In general, a single NAIM experiment can be completed in 1-2 weeks, but expect a time frame of several weeks to obtain reliable and statistically meaningful results.

Structural basis for recognition of Co2+ by RNA aptamers

Co(2+) binding RNA aptamers were chosen as research models to reveal the structural basis underlying the recognition of Co(2+) by RNA, with the application of two distinct methods. Using the nucleotide analog interference mapping assay, we found strong interference effects after incorporation of the 7-deaza guanosine phosphorotioate analog into the RNA chain at equivalent positions G27 and G28 in aptamer no. 18 and G25 and G26 in aptamer no. 20. The results obtained by nucleotide analog interference mapping suggest that these guanine bases are crucial for the creation of Co(2+) binding sites and that they appear to be involved in the coordination of the ion to the exposed N7 atom of the tandem guanines. Additionally, most 7-deaza guanosine phosphorotioate and 7-deaza adenosine phosphorotioate interferences were located in the common motifs: loop E-like in aptamer no. 18 and kissing dimer in aptamer no. 20. We also found that purine-rich stretches containing guanines with the highest interference values were the targets for hybridization of 6-mers, which are members of the semi-random oligodeoxyribonucleotide library in both aptamers. It transpired that DNA oligomer directed RNase H digestions are sensitive to Co(2+) and, at an elevated metal ion concentration, the hybridization of oligomers to aptamer targets is inhibited, probably due to higher stability and complexity of the RNA structure.

Chemical basis of glycine riboswitch cooperativity

The glycine binding riboswitch forms a unique tandem aptamer structure that binds glycine cooperatively. We employed nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) and mutagenesis to explore the chemical basis of glycine riboswitch cooperativity. Based on the interference pattern, at least two sites appear to facilitate cooperative tertiary interactions, namely, the minor groove of the P1 helix from aptamer 1 and the major groove of the P3a helix from both aptamers. Mutation of these residues altered both the cooperativity and binding affinity of the riboswitch. The data support a model in which the P1 helix of the first aptamer participates in a tertiary interaction important for cooperativity, while nucleotides in the P1 helix of the second aptamer interface with the expression platform. These data have direct analogy to well-characterized mutations in hemoglobin, which provides a framework for considering cooperativity in this RNA-based system.

Three essential and conserved regions of the group II intron are proximal to the 5′-splice site

Despite the central role of group II introns in eukaryotic gene expression and their importance as biophysical and evolutionary model systems, group II intron tertiary structure is not well understood. In order to characterize the architectural organization of intron ai5gamma, we incorporated the photoreactive nucleotides s(4)U and s(6)dG at specific locations within the intron core and monitored the formation of cross-links in folded complexes. The resulting data reveal the locations for many of the most conserved, catalytically important regions of the intron (i.e., the J2/3 linker region, the IC1(i-ii) bulge in domain 1, the bulge of D5, and the 5'-splice site), showing that all of these elements are closely colocalized. In addition, we show by nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) that a specific functional group in J2/3 plays a role in first-step catalysis, which is consistent with its apparent proximity to other first-step components. These results extend our understanding of active-site architecture during the first step of group II intron self-splicing and they provide a structural basis for spliceosomal comparison.

A Kinetic Intermediate that Regulates Proper Folding of a Group II Intron RNA

The D135 group II intron ribozyme follows a unique folding pathway that is direct and appears to be devoid of kinetic traps. During the earliest stages of folding, D135 collapses slowly to a compact intermediate, and all subsequent assembly events are rapid. Collapse of intron domain 1 (D1) has been shown to limit the rate constant for D135 folding, although the specific substructure of the D1 kinetic intermediate has not yet been identified. Employing time-resolved nucleotide analog interference mapping, we have identified a cluster of atoms within the D1 main stem that control the rate constant for D135 collapse. Functional groups within the κ–ζ element are particularly important for this earliest stage of folding, which is intriguing given that this same motif also serves later as the docking site for catalytic domain 5. More important, the κ–ζ element is shown to be a divalent ion binding pocket, indicating that this region is a Mg2+-dependent switch that initiates the cascade of D135 folding events. By measuring the Mg2+ dependence of the compaction rate constant, we conclude that the actual rate-limiting step in D1 compaction involves the formation of an unstable folding intermediate that is captured by the binding of Mg2+. This carefully orchestrated folding pathway, in which formation of an active-site docking region is early and rate limiting, ensures proper folding of the intron core and faithful splicing. It may represent an important paradigm for the folding of large, multidomain RNA molecules.

A folding control element for tertiary collapse of a group II intron ribozyme

Ribozymes derived from the group II intron ai5gamma collapse to a compact intermediate, folding to the native state through a slow, direct pathway that is unperturbed by kinetic traps. Molecular collapse of ribozyme D135 requires high magnesium concentrations and is thought to involve a structural element in domain 1 (D1). We used nucleotide analog interference mapping, in combination with nondenaturing gel electrophoresis, to identify RNA substructures and functional groups that are essential for D135 tertiary collapse. This revealed that the most crucial atoms for compaction are located within a small section of D1 that includes the kappa and zeta elements. This small substructure controls specific collapse of the molecule and, in later steps of the folding pathway, it forms the docking site for catalytic D5. In this way, the stage is set for proper active site formation during the earliest steps of ribozyme folding.

Backbone and nucleobase contacts to glucosamine-6-phosphate in the glmS ribozyme

The glmS ribozyme resides in the 5' untranslated region of glmS mRNA and functions as a catalytic riboswitch that regulates amino sugar metabolism in certain Gram-positive bacteria. The ribozyme catalyzes self-cleavage of the mRNA and ultimately inhibits gene expression in response to binding of glucosamine-6-phosphate (GlcN6P), the metabolic product of the GlmS protein. We have used nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) and suppression (NAIS) to investigate backbone and nucleobase functional groups essential for ligand-dependent ribozyme function. NAIM using GlcN6P as ligand identified requisite structural features and potential sites of ligand and/or metal ion interaction, whereas NAIS using glucosamine as ligand analog revealed those sites that orchestrate recognition of ligand phosphate. These studies demonstrate that the ligand-binding site lies in close proximity to the cleavage site in an emerging model of ribozyme structure that supports a role for ligand within the catalytic core.

In vivo assembly of functional U7 snRNP requires RNA backbone flexibility within the Sm-binding site

Most histone precursor mRNAs (pre-mRNAs) in metazoans are matured by 3'-end cleavage directed by the U7 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein (snRNP). RNA functional groups necessary for in vivo assembly and activity of the U7 snRNP were examined by nucleotide-analog interference mapping and mutagenesis using a chimeric mouse histone H4 pre-mRNA-U7 snRNA construct that is cleaved in cis in Xenopus laevis oocytes. Assembly of the unique U7 Sm protein core is rate limiting for processing in vivo and requires four conserved nucleotides within the U7 Sm-binding site, as well as the correct positioning and size of the U7 terminal stem-loop structure. To our surprise, pseudouridine substitution revealed a requirement for backbone flexibility at a particular position within the U7 Sm site, providing in vivo biochemical evidence that an unusual C2'-endo sugar conformation is necessary for assembly of the Sm ring.