Plastic crystals are supramolecular materials that possess a unique high entropy mesophase at elevated temperatures, where a long-range structural symmetry coexists with a local molecular orientational disorder. The transition to mesophase can involve a large entropy change useful for thermal energy storage and influences the temperature range of ferroelectric and piezoelectric properties, important for sensor applications. Synchrotron X-ray diffraction and pair distribution function analysis were used to study the structure, while calorimetry, dielectric, leakage current measurements, and density functional theory were used to investigate the influence of the organic cation on the structure and properties of tetraethylammonium bromotrichloroferrate(III) [(C2H5)4N][FeBrCl3] and tetramethylammonium bromotrichloroferrate [(CH3)4N][FeBrCl3]. The [(C2H5)4N][FeBrCl3] mesophase transition had an entropy change of 151.5 J·K–1·kg–1, while [(CH3)4N][FeBrCl3] had only 49 J·K–1·kg–1. This was explained by the [(C2H5)4N][FeBrCl3] mesophase having less long-range structural symmetry and more local orientational disorder, of both the cations and anions, compared to [(CH3)4N][FeBrCl3]. Both materials exhibited at least two conductive mechanisms below the transition, vacancy-mediated ionic and electronic conduction. The introduction of anion orientational freedom, as opposed to cation orientational freedom, at the mesophase transition was most influential for the electrical properties.