Modern Wheat Breeding Research Articles

A comparison of drought responses in wild wheat relatives and domesticated wheat grown under irrigated and rainfed field conditions

ContextDomestication and breeding processes for developing modern wheat plants from diverse wild relatives and landraces have had unintended effects of loss of genetic diversity. This reduction in genetic variation undermines the ability of modern wheat cultivars to tolerate environmental stresses such as drought. Wheat wild relatives possess untapped genetic potential for tolerating abiotic stress, especially drought. Yet, their morpho-physiological adaptation and drought stress resilience mechanisms remain underexplored. ObjectiveThis study aimed to investigate the adaptive responses of plants within the Triticum spp. genepool, encompassing wheat wild relatives, landraces, and modern cultivars to drought stress under rainfed and irrigated field conditions. MethodsFrom an initial pool of 110 genotypes screened during the first growing season in 2022, 20 best performing genotypes, including modern cultivars for comparison, were selected for a second growing season in 2023 based on their relative yield performance. Two different treatment conditions, irrigated and rainfed, were applied during both growing seasons. This experiment observed single plants per replicate. Multiple parameters, including days to heading and flowering, plant height, number of spikes per plant, spike length, spike weight per plant, straw weight per plant, aboveground biomass per plant, grain yield per plant, thousand kernel weight, harvest index, stomatal conductance, and vegetation indices, were assessed on the selected genotypes. ResultsTaking averages measured across both growing seasons, we observed significant genotypic variation across several parameters: days to heading and flowering, plant height, number of spikes per plant, spike length, spike and straw weight per plant, aboveground biomass per plant, grain yield per plant, thousand kernel weight, harvest index, stomatal conductance, and vegetation indices. Water stress during the rainfed treatment significantly reduced grain yield (by 21 %) and stomatal conductance (by 45 %). Stomatal conductance was associated with grain yield and yield-related traits under rainfed conditions. Diverse physiological drought tolerance mechanisms associated with stomatal regulation were identified, revealing genotype-specific responses to drought stress. Genotypes such as T. dicoccoides (G242), T. urartu (G45), T. boeoticum (G27) and T. araraticum (G221) exhibited isohydric adaptation, whereas T. monococcum sinskajae (G89) and T. durum cv. Sambadur (G41) exhibited anisohydric adaptation. ConclusionSome genotypes of T. dicoccoides, T. urartu, T. boeoticum and T. araraticum exhibited isohydric adaptation, while T. monococcum sinskajae and T. durum cv. Sambadur exhibited anisohydric adaptation under drought stress which needs further verification. These genotypes can serve as donors for introducing drought tolerance traits within wheat improvement programs. ImplicationsThese findings holds great significance in improving drought tolerance in modern wheat breeding programs.

The Tetratricopeptide repeat protein TaTPR-B1 regulates spike compactness in bread wheat.

Spike compactness (SC) is strongly associated with wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) grain yield. In this study, we conducted a quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis using a doubled haploid (DH) population derived from a cross between two common wheat varieties with contrasting spike morphology, revealing 16 stable QTLs associated with SC. The effect of a major QTL, QSc.cau-6B.1, was validated in 231 F7 recombinant inbred lines (RILs) derived from the same cross as the DH population. Using two residual heterozygous lines (RHLs), we delimited QSc.cau-6B.1 to an approximately 0.5-Mbp physical interval containing four high-confidence genes. The tetratricopeptide repeat-TraesCS6B03G1214400 (TaTPR-B1) was the priority candidate gene according to sequence and expression variations between near-isogenic lines. Accordingly, TaTPR-B1 knockout in the common wheat variety 'CB037' significantly increased SC compared to the wild type (WT). Conversely, TaTPR-B1 overexpression in the common wheat variety 'Fielder' significantly decreased SC compared to the WT. Moreover, we developed a PCR-based marker targeting the 32-bp insertion/deletion (InDel) between the two TaTPR-B1 alleles, which could be practical and valuable in modern wheat breeding programs for diagnostic purposes. Collectively, these findings provide insight into the genetic basis of SC in common wheat and present a valuable target with a breeder-friendly diagnostic marker for gene pyramid breeding.

Genome architecture of the allotetraploid wild grass Aegilops ventricosa reveals its evolutionary history and contributions to wheat improvement

The allotetraploid wild grass Aegilops ventricosa (2n = 4x = 28, genome DvDvNvNv) has been recognized as an important germplasm resource for wheat improvement owing to its ability to tolerate biotic stresses. In particular, the 2NvS segment from Ae. ventricosa, as a stable and effective resistance source, has contributed greatly to wheat improvement. The 2NvS/2AS translocation is a prevalent chromosomal translocation between common wheat and wild relatives, ranking just behind the 1B/1R translocation in importance for modern wheat breeding. Here, we assembled a high-quality chromosome-level reference genome of Ae. ventricosa RM271 with a total length of 8.67 Gb. Phylogenomic analyses revealed that the progenitor of the Dv subgenome of Ae. ventricosa is Ae. tauschii ssp. tauschii (genome DD); by contrast, the progenitor of the D subgenome of bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is Ae. tauschii ssp. strangulata (genome DD). The oldest polyploidization time of Ae. ventricosa occurred ∼0.7 mya. The Dv subgenome of Ae. ventricosa is less conserved than the D subgenome of bread wheat. Construction of a graph-based pangenome of 2AS/6NvL (originally known as 2NvS) segments from Ae. ventricosa and other genomes in the Triticeae enabled us to identify candidate resistance genes sourced from Ae. ventricosa. We identified 12 nonredundant introgressed segments from the Dv and Nv subgenomes using a large winter wheat collection representing the full diversity of the European wheat genetic pool, and 29.40% of European wheat varieties inherit at least one of these segments. The high-quality RM271 reference genome will provide a basis for cloning key genes, including the Yr17-Lr37-Sr38-Cre5 resistance gene cluster in Ae. ventricosa, and facilitate the full use of elite wild genetic resources to accelerate wheat improvement.

Modern wheat breeding selection synergistically improves above- and belowground traits.

The haplotypes selected by modern wheat breeding to improve aboveground traits enlarge the root systems of wheat seedlings.

Genomic insights into the origin and evolution of spelt (Triticum spelta L.) as a valuable gene pool for modern wheat breeding

Spelt (Triticum aestivum ssp. spelta) is an important wheat subspecies mainly cultivated in Europe before the 20th century that has contributed to modern wheat breeding as a valuable genetic resource. However, relatively little is known about the origins and maintenance of spelt populations. Here, using resequencing data from 416 worldwide wheat accessions, including representative spelt wheat, we demonstrate that European spelt emerged when primitive hexaploid wheat spread to the west and hybridized with pre-settled domesticated emmer, the putative maternal donor. Genomic introgression regions from domesticated emmer confer spelt’s primitive morphological characters used for species taxonomy, such as tenacious glumes and later flowering. We propose a haplotype-based “spelt index” to identify spelt-type wheat varieties and to quantify utilization of the spelt gene pool in modern wheat cultivars. This study reveals the genetic basis for the establishment of the spelt wheat subspecies in a specific ecological niche and the vital role of the spelt gene pool as a unique germplasm resource in modern wheat breeding.

A new target for improving wheat end-use quality.

This article is a Commentary on Liu et al. (2023), 239: 87–101.

Permanent Spreading of 1RS.1AL and 1RS.1BL Translocations in Modern Wheat Breeding.

Wheat-rye translocations 1RS.1BL and 1RS.1AL are used in bread wheat breeding worldwide because a short arm of rye chromosome 1 (1RS) when introgressed into the wheat genome confers resistance to diseases, pests and better performance under drought-stress conditions. However, in durum wheat genotypes, these translocations occur only in experimental lines, although their advantages could enhance the potential of this crop. P.P. Lukyanenko National Grain Centre (NGC) has successfully developed commercially competitive cultivars of bread and durum wheat demanded by many agricultural producers in the South of Russia for decades. Here, 94 accessions of bread and 343 accessions of durum wheat, representing lines and cultivars from collection, competitive variety trials and breeding nursery developed at NGC were screened for 1RS using PCR markers and genomic in situ hybridization. The 1RS.1BL and 1RS.1AL translocations were detected in 38 and 6 bread wheat accessions, respectively. None of the durum wheat accessions showed translocation, despite the fact that some of them had 1RS.1BL donors in their pedigree. The absence of translocations in the studied durum wheat germplasm can be caused by the negative selection of 1RS carriers at different stages of the breeding process due to low quality and difficulties in transferring rye chromatin through wheat gametes.

The selection and application of peduncle length QTL QPL_6D.1 in modern wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) breeding.

QPL_6D.1b displayed an additive effect with Rht-B1b and Rht-D1b in reducing wheat plant height and peduncle length, which confers shorter peduncle length and more kernels per spike, and had been broadly selected by Chinese modern wheat cultivars. Peduncle length (PL), as the key component of wheat plant height (PH), plays critical role in determining wheat lodging resistance and wheat pathogen resistance; then, its breeding selection and genetic basis remain largely unclear. Here the PH and PL were investigated in 406 wheat accessions in eight environments. In this study, a PL preferentially QTL QPL_6D.1 was identified in six environments by GWAS, which explained 13.6-24.2% of wheat PL variations in natural population. The allele QPL_6D.1b displayed a significantly additive effect with Rht-B1b and Rht-D1b in controlling PH and PL and could freely combined with Rht-B1b and Rht-D1b in current wheat cultivars. Haplotypic analysis demonstrates the QPL_6D.1b has been selected by Chinese modern wheat cultivar and confers shorter PL and more kernels per spike, highlighting its potentials in wheat breeding.

Advances in the Mining of Disease Resistance Genes from Aegilops tauschii and the Utilization in Wheat

Aegilops tauschii is one of the malignant weeds that affect wheat production and is also the wild species ancestor of the D genome of hexaploid wheat (Triticum aestivum, AABBDD). It contains many disease resistance genes that have been lost in the long-term evolution of wheat and is an important genetic resource for the mining and utilization of wheat disease resistance genes. In recent years, the genome sequence of Aegilops tauschii has been preliminarily completed, which has laid a good foundation for the further exploration of wheat disease resistance genes in Aegilops tauschii. There are many studies on disease resistance genes in Aegilops tauschii; in order to provide better help for the disease resistance breeding of wheat, this paper analyzes and reviews the relationship between Aegilops tauschii and wheat, the research progress of Aegilops tauschii, the discovery of disease resistance genes from Aegilops tauschii, and the application of disease resistance genes from Aegilops tauschii to modern wheat breeding, providing a reference for the further exploration and utilization of Aegilops tauschii in wheat disease resistance breeding.

Genome-wide association study of yield-related traits in common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) under normal and drought treatment conditions.

The primary goal of modern wheat breeding is to develop new high-yielding and widely adaptable varieties. We analyzed four yield-related agronomic traits in 502 wheat accessions under normal conditions (NC) and drought treatment (DT) conditions over three years. The genome-wide association analysis identified 51 yield-related and nine drought-resistance-related QTL, including 13 for the thousand-grain weight (TGW), 30 for grain length (GL), three for grain width (GW), five for spike length (SL) and nine for stress tolerance index (STI) QTL in wheat. These QTL, containing 72 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), explained 2.23 - 7.35% of the phenotypic variation across multiple environments. Eight stable SNPs on chromosomes 2A, 2D, 3B, 4A, 5B, 5D, and 7D were associated with phenotypic stability under NC and DT conditions. Two of these stable SNPs had association with TGW and STI. Several novel QTL for TGW, GL and SL were identified on different chromosomes. Three linked SNPs were transformed into kompetitive allele-specific PCR (KASP) markers. These results will facilitate the discovery of promising SNPs for yield-related traits and/or drought stress tolerance and will accelerate the development of new wheat varieties with desirable alleles.

Proteins from Modern and Ancient Wheat Cultivars: Impact on Immune Cells of Healthy Individuals and Patients with NCGS.

In non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS), the elimination of wheat results in a clear symptom improvement, but gluten has still not been proven as (the sole) trigger. Due to the increase in the prevalence of gluten-related diseases, the breeding of high-performance wheat cultivars is discussed as a trigger. To analyze the immune stimulation and signal pathways, the immune cells of healthy subjects and patients with NCGS were stimulated with gliadins from wheat, and the expression and secretion of interleukin 1ß (IL1ß) and interleukin 6 (IL6) were studied. To determine the impact of wheat breeding, the monocyte cell line THP1 and human immune cells were stimulated with gliadin, glutenin, and albumin/globulin fractions of ancient and modern cereals, and expression of inflammatory molecules was checked. Immune cells of patients with NCGS showed an increased expression of IL1ß and IL6 after stimulation with gliadins compared to immune cells of healthy controls. Gliadins caused a strong activation of P-STAT3 in immune cells of healthy controls, and inhibitors of JAK and NFκB pathways considerably reduced this response. In addition to gliadins, we further showed that glutenins and albumin/globulins from all wheat cultivars from the last century, and especially from einkorn and spelt, also markedly induced the expression of inflammatory genes in THP1 and human immune cells. There was no correlation between enhanced immune stimulation and ancient or modern cultivars. This does not support the hypothesis that modern wheat breeding is responsible for the increase in gluten-related diseases. An altered immune situation is suggested in patients with NCGS.

Genetic Diversity and Selection Signatures in Synthetic-Derived Wheats and Modern Spring Wheat.

Synthetic hexaploid wheats and their derived advanced lines were subject to empirical selection in developing genetically superior cultivars. To investigate genetic diversity, patterns of nucleotide diversity, population structure, and selection signatures during wheat breeding, we tested 422 wheat accessions, including 145 synthetic-derived wheats, 128 spring wheat cultivars, and 149 advanced breeding lines from Pakistan. A total of 18,589 high-quality GBS-SNPs were identified that were distributed across the A (40%), B (49%), and D (11%) genomes. Values of population diversity parameters were estimated across chromosomes and genomes. Genome-wide average values of genetic diversity and polymorphic information content were estimated to be 0.30 and 0.25, respectively. Neighbor-joining (NJ) tree, principal component analysis (PCA), and kinship analyses revealed that synthetic-derived wheats and advanced breeding lines were genetically diverse. The 422 accessions were not separated into distinct groups by NJ analysis and confirmed using the PCA. This conclusion was validated with both relative kinship and Rogers' genetic distance analyses. EigenGWAS analysis revealed that 32 unique genome regions had undergone selection. We found that 50% of the selected regions were located in the B-genome, 29% in the D-genome, and 21% in the A-genome. Previously known functional genes or QTL were found within the selection regions associated with phenology-related traits such as vernalization, adaptability, disease resistance, and yield-related traits. The selection signatures identified in the present investigation will be useful for understanding the targets of modern wheat breeding in Pakistan.

Dispersed emergence and protracted domestication of polyploid wheat uncovered by mosaic ancestral haploblock inference

Major crops are all survivors of domestication bottlenecks. Studies have focused on the genetic loci related to the domestication syndrome, while the contribution of ancient haplotypes remains largely unknown. Here, an ancestral genomic haploblock dissection method is developed and applied to a resequencing dataset of 386 tetraploid/hexaploid wheat accessions, generating a pan-ancestry haploblock map. Together with cytoplastic evidences, we reveal that domesticated polyploid wheat emerged from the admixture of six founder wild emmer lineages, which contributed the foundation of ancestral mosaics. The key domestication-related loci, originated over a wide geographical range, were gradually pyramided through a protracted process. Diverse stable-inheritance ancestral haplotype groups of the chromosome central zone are identified, revealing the expanding routes of wheat and the trends of modern wheat breeding. Finally, an evolution model of polyploid wheat is proposed, highlighting the key role of wild-to-crop and interploidy introgression, that increased genomic diversity following bottlenecks introduced by domestication and polyploidization.

Shaping polyploid wheat for success: Origins, domestication, and the genetic improvement of agronomic traits.

Bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L., AABBDD, 2n = 6x = 42), which accounts for most of the cultivated wheat crop worldwide, is a typical allohexaploid with a genome derived from three diploid wild ancestors. Bread wheat arose and evolved via two sequential allopolyploidization events and was further polished through multiple steps of domestication. Today, cultivated allohexaploid bread wheat has numerous advantageous traits, including adaptive plasticity, favorable yield traits, and extended end-use quality, which have enabled its cultivation well beyond the ranges of its tetraploid and diploid progenitors to become a global staple food crop. In the past decade, rapid advances in wheat genomic research have considerably accelerated our understanding of the bases for the shaping of complex agronomic traits in this polyploid crop. Here, we summarize recent advances in characterizing major genetic factors underlying the origin, evolution, and improvement of polyploid wheats. We end with a brief discussion of the future prospects for the design of gene cloning strategies and modern wheat breeding.

GgComp enables dissection of germplasm resources and construction of a multiscale germplasm network in wheat.

Accurate germplasm characterization is a vital step for accelerating crop genetic improvement, which remains largely infeasible for crops such as bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), which has a complex genome that undergoes frequent introgression and contains many structural variations. Here, we propose a genomic strategy called ggComp, which integrates resequencing data with copy number variations and stratified single-nucleotide polymorphism densities to enable unsupervised identification of pairwise germplasm resource-based Identity-By-Descent (gIBD) blocks. The reliability of ggComp was verified in wheat cultivar Nongda5181 by dissecting parental-descent patterns represented by inherited genomic blocks. With gIBD blocks identified among 212 wheat accessions, we constructed a multi-scale genomic-based germplasm network. At the whole-genome level, the network helps to clarify pedigree relationship, demonstrate genetic flow, and identify key founder lines. At the chromosome level, we were able to trace the utilization of 1RS introgression in modern wheat breeding by hitchhiked segments. At the single block scale, the dissected germplasm-based haplotypes nicely matched with previously identified alleles of “Green Revolution” genes and can guide allele mining and dissect the trajectory of beneficial alleles in wheat breeding. Our work presents a model-based framework for precisely evaluating germplasm resources with genomic data. A database, WheatCompDB (http://wheat.cau.edu.cn/WheatCompDB/), is available for researchers to exploit the identified gIBDs with a multi-scale network.

Wheat breeding history reveals synergistic selection of pleiotropic genomic sites for plant architecture and grain yield

Diversity surveys of crop germplasm are important for gaining insights into the genomic basis for plant architecture and grain yield improvement, which is still poorly understood in wheat. In this study, we exome sequenced 287 wheat accessions that were collected in the past 100 years. Population genetics analysis identified that 6.7% of the wheat genome falls within the selective sweeps between landraces and cultivars, which harbors the genes known for yield improvement. These regions were asymmetrically distributed on the A and B subgenomes with regulatory genes being favorably selected. Genome-wide association study (GWAS) identified genomic loci associated with traits for yield potential, and two underlying genes, TaARF12 encoding an auxin response factor and TaDEP1 encoding the G-protein γ-subunit, were located and characterized to pleiotropically regulate both plant height and grain weight. Elite single-nucleotide haplotypes with increased allele frequency in cultivars relative to the landraces were identified and found to have accumulated over the course of breeding. Interestingly, we found that TaARF12 and TaDEP1 function in epistasis with the classical plant height Rht-1 locus, leading to propose a “Green Revolution”-based working model for historical wheat breeding. Collectively, our study identifies selection signatures that fine-tune the gibberellin pathway during modern wheat breeding and provides a wealth of genomic diversity resources for the wheat research community.

Spike Density Quantitative Trait Loci Detection and Analysis in Tetraploid and Hexaploid Wheat Recombinant Inbred Line Populations.

Spike density (SD) is an agronomically important character in wheat. In addition, an optimized spike structure is a key basis for high yields. Identification of quantitative trait loci (QTL) for SD has provided a genetic basis for constructing ideal spike morphologies in wheat. In this study, two recombinant inbred line (RIL) populations (tetraploid RIL AM and hexaploid RIL 20828/SY95-71 (2SY)) previously genotyped using the wheat55K SNP array were used to identify SD QTL. A total of 18 QTL were detected, and three were major and one was stably expressed (QSd.sau-2SY-7A.2, QSd.sau-AM-5A.2, QSd.sau-AM-7B, and QSd.sau-2SY-2D). They can explain up to 23.14, 19.97, 12.00, and 9.44% of phenotypic variation, respectively. QTL × environment and epistatic interactions for SD were further analyzed. In addition, pyramiding analysis further revealed that there were additive effects between QSd.sau-2SY-2D and QSd.sau-2SY-7A.2 in 2SY, and QSd.sau-AM-5A.2 and QSd.sau-AM-7B in AM. Pearson’s correlation between SD and other agronomic traits, and effects of major or stable QTL on yield related traits indicated SD significantly impacted spike length (SL), spikelet number per spike (SNS) and kernel length (KL). Several genes related to spike development within the physical intervals of major or stable QTL were predicted and discussed. Collectively, our research identified QTL with potential applications for modern wheat breeding and broadening the genetic basis of SD.

Exploring the diversity of promoter and 5'UTR sequences in ancestral, historic and modern wheat.

A data set of promoter and 5′UTR sequences of homoeo‐alleles of 459 wheat genes that contribute to agriculturally important traits in 95 ancestral and commercial wheat cultivars is presented here. The high‐stringency myBaits technology used made individual capture of homoeo‐allele promoters possible, which is reported here for the first time. Promoters of most genes are remarkably conserved across the 83 hexaploid cultivars used with <7 haplotypes per promoter and 21% being identical to the reference Chinese Spring. InDels and many high‐confidence SNPs are located within predicted plant transcription factor binding sites, potentially changing gene expression. Most haplotypes found in the Watkins landraces and a few haplotypes found in Triticum monococcum, germplasms hitherto not thought to have been used in modern wheat breeding, are already found in many commercial hexaploid wheats. The full data set which is useful for genomic and gene function studies and wheat breeding is available at https://rrescloud.rothamsted.ac.uk/index.php/s/DMCFDu5iAGTl50u/authenticate.

The decreased expression of GW2 homologous genes contributed to the increased grain width and thousand‑grain weight in wheat-Dasypyrum villosum 6VS·6DL translocation lines.

This study demonstrated that the aberrant transcription of DvGW2 contributed to the increased grain width and thousand-grain weight in wheat-Dasypyrum villosum T6VS·6DL translocation lines. Due to the high immunity to powdery mildew, Dasypyrum villosum 6VS has been one of the most successful applications of the wild relatives in modern wheat breeding. Along with the desired traits, side-effects could be brought when large alien chromosome fragments are introduced into wheat, but little is known about effects of 6VS on agronomic traits. Here, we found that T6VS·6DL translocation had significantly positive effects on grain weight, plant heightand spike length, and small negative effects on total spikelet number and spikelet compactness using recipient and wheat-D. villosum T6VS·6DL allohexaploid wheats, Wan7107 and Pm97033. Further analysis showed that the 6VS segment might exert direct genetic effect on grain width, then driving the increase of thousand-grain weight. Furthermore, comparative transcriptome analysis identified 2549 and 1282 differentially expressed genes(DEGs) and 2220 and 1496 specifically expressed genes(SEGs) at 6days after pollination(DAP) grains and 15 DAP endosperms, respectively. Enrichment analysis indicated that the process of cell proliferation category was over-represented in the DEGs. Notably, two homologous genes, TaGW2-D1 and DvGW2, were identified as putative candidate genes associated with grain weight and yield. The expression analysis showed that DvGW2 had an aberrant expression in Pm97033, resulting in significantly lower total expression level of GW2 than Wan7107, which drives the increase of grain weight and width in Pm97033. Collectively, our data indicated that the compromised expression of DvGW2 is critical for increased grain width and weight in T6VS·6DL translocation lines.

Potential Use of Wild Einkorn Wheat for Wheat Grain Quality Improvement: Evaluation and Characterization of Glu-1, Wx and Ha Loci

Wild einkorn (Triticum monococcum L. ssp. aegilopoides (Link) Thell.) is a diploid wheat species from the Near East that has been classified as an ancestor of the first cultivated wheat (einkorn; T. monococcum L. ssp. monococcum). Its genome (Am), although it is not the donor of the A genome in polyploid wheat, shows high similarity to the Au genome. An important characteristic for wheat improvement is grain quality, which is associated with three components of the wheat grain: endosperm storage proteins (gluten properties), starch synthases (starch characteristics) and puroindolines (grain hardness). In the current study, these grain quality traits were studied in one collection of wild einkorn with the objective of evaluating its variability with respect to these three traits. The combined use of protein and DNA analyses allows detecting numerous variants for each one of the following genes: six for Ax, seven for Ay, eight for Wx, four for Gsp-1, two for Pina and three for Pinb. The high variability presence in this species suggests its potential as a source of novel alleles that could be used in modern wheat breeding.