Introduction: Needle knife papillotomy is a method of gaining deep biliary access when standard methods fail and is thought to be potentially unsafe. Studies have shown that when performed by an expert endoscopist, it can be a very effective way of gaining deep biliary access and relatively safe. We retrospectively analysed all needle knife papillotomies performed at our tertiary centre over a five year period. Patients and Methods: A total of 2800 ERCPs were performed between December 2000 and July 2006 and needle knife papillotomy was required in 312 patients (11.4%) with an intention to gain deep biliary access. 131 were males and 181 females. 155 of 312 were referred from other hospitals. All the reports were analysed and cross checked with notes where required. All needle knife papillotomies were performed by either of the two very experienced endoscopists in the centre. Results: Patient's age ranged from 20 to 98 years (mean age 71.9). Sedation was with Midazolam (1-25 mg) along with either Pethidine (12.5-100 mg) or Fentanyl (10-150 mg). Flumazenil was required in 7 patients for reversal. 3 patients required general anaesthetic. Indications were Jaundice (129), Dilated ducts (40), Abnormal LFTs (44), Cholangitis (22), Stones (118), Acute Pancreatitis (34), Stent review (3), Biliary leak (6), Pseudocyst (2), Pain (21), Previously failed (52), Tumour (15), PSC (1). Deep biliary cannulation was achieved in 209 patients at first (67%) and 55 out of 65 patients (84.61%) at second attempts. 2 patients had successful cannulation on 3 rd attempt, making overall successful cannulation in 266 out of 312 (85.25%). Each patient was assessed immediately after procedure, 24 hours later and then followed up at 30 th day by a specialist nurse. Complications were defined and graded according to the consensus criteria (Cotton et al, 1991). There were 52 “adverse events” reported during first attempt with needle knife papillotomy (14.4%) and 18 of these met the definition of “complication” (5.76%). One mild and one moderate bleeds reported (0.64%). There were 2 mild and 3 moderate Pancreatitis (1.6%). Two mild and one moderate perforations occurred (0.96%). Seven cases of mild Cholangitis reported (2.24%). One death occurred due to Pancreatitis (0.3%). Other events include sub mucosal injection (10), abdominal pain (14), sore eye and rhinitis at 30 days. Conclusion: Needle knife papillotomy is effective in gaining deep biliary access and can result in mild complications even in expert hands but severe/fatal complications are very rare.
Read full abstract