Over the last two decades the Owen Tube or derivatives of the original design have been used extensively to determine the settling velocities of suspensions of cohesive material in the field. These gravimetric measurements have been used as elements of basic research programmes and also as important input parameters for predictions of siltation rates. During a two year research programme at HR Wallingford undertaken between 1989 and 1991 consideration was given to an alternative technique for analysing the settling of cohesive material. This technique is based upon obtaining high magnification video images of the processes occurring within the settling column. The video images are then analysed using a PC based image analysis system which enables settling velocities and floc dimensions to be determined. The technique has been applied on a number of occasions over the past four years and was included in the European Intercalibration Exercise that took place on the river Elbe in June 1993. Analysis of the processed field data indicates floc break-up, reflocculation and the development of significant circulations within the settling column during the withdrawal period required for the gravimetric analysis (typically a duration of about an hour). The interpretation of the visual data obtained by the video image analysis technique has indicated median settling velocities significantly greater than those obtained from the gravimetric technique. The paper describes the field and analysis methods and results from the recent intercalibration on the Elbe. During this exercise an experiment was undertaken whereby video image analysis was done on the results of filming a settling column whilst the standard gravimetric technique was applied. The paper also discusses the engineering applicability of the results obtained and raises the question as to which technique provides the most representative rate of settlement of flocs in the natural environment?
Read full abstract