Mechanism-based Crosslinking Research Articles

Sequence- and Structure-Specific tRNA Dihydrouridylation by hDUS2.

The post-transcriptional reduction of uridine to dihydrouridine (D) by dihydrouridine synthase (DUS) enzymes is among the most ubiquitous transformations in RNA biology. D is found at multiple sites in tRNAs, and studies in yeast have proposed that each of the four eukaryotic DUS enzymes modifies a different site; however, the molecular basis for this exquisite selectivity is unknown, and human DUS enzymes have remained largely uncharacterized. Here we investigate the substrate specificity of human dihydrouridine synthase 2 (hDUS2) using mechanism-based cross-linking with 5-bromouridine (5-BrUrd)-modified oligonucleotide probes and in vitro dihydrouridylation assays. We find that hDUS2 exclusively modifies U20 across diverse tRNA substrates and identify a minimal GU sequence within the tRNA D loop that underlies selective substrate modification. Further, we use our mechanism-based platform to screen small molecule inhibitors of hDUS2, a potential anticancer target. Our work elucidates the principles of substrate modification by a conserved DUS and provides a general platform for studying RNA modifying enzymes with sequence-defined activity-based probes.

Trapping of a Polyketide Synthase Module after C-C Bond Formation Reveals Transient Acyl Carrier Domain Interactions.

Modular polyketide synthases (PKSs) are giant assembly lines that produce an impressive range of biologically active compounds. However, our understanding of the structural dynamics of these megasynthases, specifically the delivery of acyl carrier protein (ACP)-bound building blocks to the catalytic site of the ketosynthase (KS) domain, remains severely limited. Using a multipronged structural approach, we report details of the inter-domain interactions after C-C bond formation in a chain-branching module of the rhizoxin PKS. Mechanism-based crosslinking of an engineered module was achieved using a synthetic substrate surrogate that serves as a Michael acceptor. The crosslinked protein allowed us to identify an asymmetric state of the dimeric protein complex upon C-C bond formation by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The possible existence of two ACP binding sites, one of them a potential "parking position" for substrate loading, was also indicated by AlphaFold2 predictions. NMR spectroscopy showed that a transient complex is formed in solution, independent of the linker domains, and photochemical crosslinking/mass spectrometry of the standalone domains allowed us to pinpoint the interdomain interaction sites. The structural insights into a branching PKS module arrested after C-C bond formation allows a better understanding of domain dynamics and provides valuable information for the rational design of modular assembly lines.

Chemoproteomic Approaches to Studying RNA Modification-Associated Proteins.

The function of cellular RNA is modulated by a host of post-transcriptional chemical modifications installed by dedicated RNA-modifying enzymes. RNA modifications are widespread in biology, occurring in all kingdoms of life and in all classes of RNA molecules. They regulate RNA structure, folding, and protein-RNA interactions, and have important roles in fundamental gene expression processes involving mRNA, tRNA, rRNA, and other types of RNA species. Our understanding of RNA modifications has advanced considerably; however, there are still many outstanding questions regarding the distribution of modifications across all RNA transcripts and their biological function. One of the major challenges in the study of RNA modifications is the lack of sequencing methods for the transcriptome-wide mapping of different RNA-modification structures. Furthermore, we lack general strategies to characterize RNA-modifying enzymes and RNA-modification reader proteins. Therefore, there is a need for new approaches to enable integrated studies of RNA-modification chemistry and biology.In this Account, we describe our development and application of chemoproteomic strategies for the study of RNA-modification-associated proteins. We present two orthogonal methods based on nucleoside and oligonucleotide chemical probes: 1) RNA-mediated activity-based protein profiling (RNABPP), a metabolic labeling strategy based on reactive modified nucleoside probes to profile RNA-modifying enzymes in cells and 2) photo-cross-linkable diazirine-containing synthetic oligonucleotide probes for identifying RNA-modification reader proteins.We use RNABPP with C5-modified cytidine and uridine nucleosides to capture diverse RNA-pyrimidine-modifying enzymes including methyltransferases, dihydrouridine synthases, and RNA dioxygenase enzymes. Metabolic labeling facilitates the mechanism-based cross-linking of RNA-modifying enzymes with their native RNA substrates in cells. Covalent RNA-protein complexes are then isolated by denaturing oligo(dT) pulldown, and cross-linked proteins are identified by quantitative proteomics. Once suitable modified nucleosides have been identified as mechanism-based proteomic probes, they can be further deployed in transcriptome-wide sequencing experiments to profile the substrates of RNA-modifying enzymes at nucleotide resolution. Using 5-fluorouridine-mediated RNA-protein cross-linking and sequencing, we analyzed the substrates of human dihydrouridine synthase DUS3L. 5-Ethynylcytidine-mediated cross-linking enabled the investigation of ALKBH1 substrates. We also characterized the functions of these RNA-modifying enzymes in human cells by using genetic knockouts and protein translation reporters.We profiled RNA readers for N6-methyladenosine (m6A) and N1-methyladenosine (m1A) using a comparative proteomic workflow based on diazirine-containing modified oligonucleotide probes. Our approach enables quantitative proteome-wide analysis of the preference of RNA-binding proteins for modified nucleotides across a range of affinities. Interestingly, we found that YTH-domain proteins YTHDF1/2 can bind to both m6A and m1A to mediate transcript destabilization. Furthermore, m6A also inhibits stress granule proteins from binding to RNA.Taken together, we demonstrate the application of chemical probing strategies, together with proteomic and transcriptomic workflows, to reveal new insights into the biological roles of RNA modifications and their associated proteins.

Mechanism-based cross-linking probes capture the Escherichia coli ketosynthase FabB in conformationally distinct catalytic states.

Ketosynthases (KSs) catalyse essential carbon-carbon bond-forming reactions in fatty-acid biosynthesis using a two-step, ping-pong reaction mechanism. In Escherichia coli, there are two homodimeric elongating KSs, FabB and FabF, which possess overlapping substrate selectivity. However, FabB is essential for the biosynthesis of the unsaturated fatty acids (UFAs) required for cell survival in the absence of exogenous UFAs. Additionally, FabB has reduced activity towards substrates longer than 12 C atoms, whereas FabF efficiently catalyses the elongation of saturated C14 and unsaturated C16:1 acyl-acyl carrier protein (ACP) complexes. In this study, two cross-linked crystal structures of FabB in complex with ACPs functionalized with long-chain fatty-acid cross-linking probes that approximate catalytic steps were solved. Both homodimeric structures possess asymmetric substrate-binding pockets suggestive of cooperative relationships between the two FabB monomers when engaged with C14 and C16 acyl chains. In addition, these structures capture an unusual rotamer of the active-site gating residue, Phe392, which is potentially representative of the catalytic state prior to substrate release. These structures demonstrate the utility of mechanism-based cross-linking methods to capture and elucidate conformational transitions accompanying KS-mediated catalysis at near-atomic resolution.

Engineered Chimeras Unveil Swappable Modular Features of Fatty Acid and Polyketide Synthase Acyl Carrier Proteins.

The strategic redesign of microbial biosynthetic pathways is a compelling route to access molecules of diverse structure and function in a potentially environmentally sustainable fashion. The promise of this approach hinges on an improved understanding of acyl carrier proteins (ACPs), which serve as central hubs in biosynthetic pathways. These small, flexible proteins mediate the transport of molecular building blocks and intermediates to enzymatic partners that extend and tailor the growing natural products. Past combinatorial biosynthesis efforts have failed due to incompatible ACP-enzyme pairings. Herein, we report the design of chimeric ACPs with features of the actinorhodin polyketide synthase ACP (ACT) and of the Escherichia coli fatty acid synthase (FAS) ACP (AcpP). We evaluate the ability of the chimeric ACPs to interact with the E. coli FAS ketosynthase FabF, which represents an interaction essential to building the carbon backbone of the synthase molecular output. Given that AcpP interacts with FabF but ACT does not, we sought to exchange modular features of ACT with AcpP to confer functionality with FabF. The interactions of chimeric ACPs with FabF were interrogated using sedimentation velocity experiments, surface plasmon resonance analyses, mechanism-based cross-linking assays, and molecular dynamics simulations. Results suggest that the residues guiding AcpP-FabF compatibility and ACT-FabF incompatibility may reside in the loop I, α-helix II region. These findings can inform the development of strategic secondary element swaps that expand the enzyme compatibility of ACPs across systems and therefore represent a critical step toward the strategic engineering of "un-natural" natural products.

Developing crosslinkers specific for epimerization domain in NRPS initiation modules to evaluate mechanism.

Nonribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPSs) are complex multi-modular enzymes containing catalytic domains responsible for the loading and incorporation of amino acids into natural products. These unique molecular factories can produce peptides with nonproteinogenic d-amino acids in which the epimerization (E) domain catalyzes the conversion of l-amino acids to d-amino acids, but its mechanism remains not fully understood. Here, we describe the development of pantetheine crosslinking probes that mimic the natural substrate l-Phe of the initiation module of tyrocidine synthetase, TycA, to elucidate and study the catalytic residues of the E domain. Mechanism-based crosslinking assays and MALDI-TOF MS were used to identify both H743 and E882 as the crosslinking site residues, demonstrating their roles as catalytic bases. Mutagenesis studies further validated these results and allowed the comparison of reactivity between the catalytic residues, concluding that glutamate acts as the dominant nucleophile in the crosslinking reaction, resembling the deprotonation of the Cα-H of amino acids in the epimerization reaction. The crosslinking probes employed in these studies provide new tools for studying the molecular details of E domains, as well as the potential to study C domains. In particular, they would elucidate key information for how these domains function and interact with their substrates in nature, further enhancing the knowledge needed to assist combinatorial biosynthetic efforts of NRPS systems to produce novel compounds.

MiCLIP-MaPseq Identifies Substrates of Radical SAM RNA-Methylating Enzyme Using Mechanistic Cross-Linking and Mismatch Profiling.

The family of radical SAM RNA-methylating enzymes comprises a large group of proteins that contains only a few functionally characterized members. Several enzymes in this family have been implicated in the regulation of translation and antibiotic susceptibility, emphasizing their significance in bacterial physiology and their relevance to human health. While few characterized enzymes have been shown to modify diverse RNA substrates, highlighting potentially broad substrate scope within the family, many enzymes in this class have no known substrates. The precise knowledge of RNA substrates and modification sites for uncharacterized family members is important for unraveling their biological function. Here, we describe a strategy for substrate identification that takes advantage of mechanism-based cross-linking between the enzyme and its RNA substrates, which we named individual-nucleotide-resolution cross-linking and immunoprecipitation combined with mutational profiling with sequencing (miCLIP-MaPseq). Identification of the position of the modification site is achieved using thermostable group II intron reverse transcriptase (TGIRT), which introduces a mismatch at the site of the cross-link.

Mechanistic Probes for the Epimerization Domain of Nonribosomal Peptide Synthetases.

Nonribosomal peptide synthetases (NRPSs) are responsible for the synthesis of a variety of bioactive natural products with clinical and economic significance. Interestingly, these large multimodular enzyme machineries incorporate nonproteinogenic d-amino acids through the use of auxiliary epimerization domains, converting l-amino acids into d-amino acids that impart into the resulting natural products unique bioactivity and resistance to proteases. Due to the large and complex nature of NRPSs, several questions remain unanswered about the mechanism of the catalytic domain reactions. We have investigated the use of mechanism-based crosslinkers to probe the mechanism of an epimerization domain in gramicidin S biosynthesis. In addition, MD simulations were performed, showcasing the possible roles of catalytic residues within the epimerization domain.

MiCLIP-MaPseq, a Substrate Identification Approach for Radical SAM RNA Methylating Enzymes.

Although present across bacteria, the large family of radical SAM RNA methylating enzymes is largely uncharacterized. Escherichia coli RlmN, the founding member of the family, methylates an adenosine in 23S rRNA and several tRNAs to yield 2-methyladenosine (m2A). However, varied RNA substrate specificity among RlmN enzymes, combined with the ability of certain family members to generate 8-methyladenosine (m8A), makes functional predictions across this family challenging. Here, we present a method for unbiased substrate identification that exploits highly efficient, mechanism-based cross-linking between the enzyme and its RNA substrates. Additionally, by determining that the thermostable group II intron reverse transcriptase introduces mismatches at the site of the cross-link, we have identified the precise positions of RNA modification using mismatch profiling. These results illustrate the capability of our method to define enzyme-substrate pairs and determine modification sites of the largely uncharacterized radical SAM RNA methylating enzyme family.

The structural organization of substrate loading in iterative polyketide synthases.

Polyketide synthases (PKSs) are microbial multienzymes for the biosynthesis of biologically potent secondary metabolites. Polyketide production is initiated by the loading of a starter unit onto an integral acyl carrier protein (ACP) and its subsequent transfer to the ketosynthase (KS). Initial substrate loading is achieved either by multidomain loading modules or by the integration of designated loading domains, such as starter unit acyltransferases (SAT), whose structural integration into PKS remains unresolved. A crystal structure of the loading/condensing region of the nonreducing PKS CTB1 demonstrates the ordered insertion of a pseudodimeric SAT into the condensing region, which is aided by the SAT-KS linker. Cryo-electron microscopy of the post-loading state trapped by mechanism-based crosslinking of ACP to KS reveals asymmetry across the CTB1 loading/-condensing region, in accord with preferential 1:2 binding stoichiometry. These results are critical for re-engineering the loading step in polyketide biosynthesis and support functional relevance of asymmetric conformations of PKSs.

Mechanism of intersubunit ketosynthase-dehydratase interaction in polyketide synthases.

Modular polyketide synthases (PKSs) produce numerous structurally complex natural products that have diverse applications in medicine and agriculture. PKSs typically consist of several multienzyme subunits that utilize structurally defined docking domains (DDs) at their N and C termini to ensure correct assembly into functional multiprotein complexes. Here we report a fundamentally different mechanism for subunit assembly in trans-acyltransferase (trans-AT) modular PKSs at the junction between ketosynthase (KS) and dehydratase (DH) domains. This mechanism involves direct interaction of a largely unstructured docking domain (DD) at the C terminus of the KS with the surface of the downstream DH. Acyl transfer assays and mechanism-based crosslinking established that the DD is required for the KS to communicate with the acyl carrier protein appended to the DH. Two distinct regions for binding of the DD to the DH were identified using NMR spectroscopy, carbene footprinting, and mutagenesis, providing a foundation for future elucidation of the molecular basis for interaction specificity.

Structural and Biochemical Analysis of Protein-Protein Interactions Between the Acyl-Carrier Protein and Product Template Domain.

In fungal non-reducing polyketide synthases (NR-PKS) the acyl-carrier protein (ACP) carries the growing polyketide intermediate through iterative rounds of elongation, cyclization and product release. This process occurs through a controlled, yet enigmatic coordination of the ACP with its partner enzymes. The transient nature of ACP interactions with these catalytic domains imposes a major obstacle for investigation of the influence of protein-protein interactions on polyketide product outcome. To further our understanding about how the ACP interacts with the product template (PT) domain that catalyzes polyketide cyclization, we developed the first mechanism-based crosslinkers for NR-PKSs. Through in vitro assays, in silico docking and bioinformatics, ACP residues involved in ACP-PT recognition were identified. We used this information to improve ACP compatibility with non-cognate PT domains, which resulted in the first gain-of-function ACP with improved interactions with its partner enzymes. This advance will aid in future combinatorial biosynthesis of new polyketides.

Using modern tools to probe the structure-function relationship of fatty acid synthases.

Fatty acid biosynthesis is essential to life and represents one of the most conserved pathways in nature, preserving the same handful of chemical reactions across all species. Recent interest in the molecular details of the de novo fatty acid synthase (FAS) has been heightened by demand for renewable fuels and the emergence of multidrug-resistant bacterial strains. Central to FAS is the acyl carrier protein (ACP), a protein chaperone that shuttles the growing acyl chain between catalytic enzymes within the FAS. Human efforts to alter fatty acid biosynthesis for oil production, chemical feedstock, or antimicrobial purposes has been met with limited success, due in part to a lack of detailed molecular information behind the ACP-partner protein interactions inherent to the pathway. This review will focus on recently developed tools for the modification of ACP and analysis of protein-protein interactions, such as mechanism-based crosslinking, and the studies exploiting them. Discussion specific to each enzymatic domain will focus first on mechanism and known inhibitors, followed by available structures and known interactions with ACP. Although significant unknowns remain, new understandings of the intricacies of FAS point to future advances in manipulating this complex molecular factory.

Probing the Selectivity and Protein⋅Protein Interactions of a Nonreducing Fungal Polyketide Synthase Using Mechanism-Based Crosslinkers

Protein·protein interactions, which often involve interactions among an acyl carrier protein (ACP) and ACP partner enzymes, are important for coordinating polyketide biosynthesis. However, the nature of such interactions is not well understood, especially in the fungal nonreducing polyketide synthases (NR-PKSs) that biosynthesize toxic and pharmaceutically important polyketides. Here, we employ mechanism-based crosslinkers to successfully probe ACP and ketosynthase (KS) domain interactions in NR-PKSs. We found that crosslinking efficiency is closely correlated with the strength of ACP·KS interactions and that KS demonstrates strong starter unit selectivity. We further identified positively charged surface residues by KS mutagenesis, which mediates key interactions with the negatively charged ACP surface. Such complementary/matching contact pairs can serve as "adapter surfaces" for future efforts to generate new polyketides using NR-PKSs.

Sulfonyl 3-Alkynyl Pantetheinamides as Mechanism-Based Cross-Linkers of Acyl Carrier Protein Dehydratase

Acyl carrier proteins (ACPs) play a central role in acetate biosynthetic pathways, serving as tethers for substrates and growing intermediates. Activity and structural studies have highlighted the complexities of this role, and the protein-protein interactions of ACPs have recently come under scrutiny as a regulator of catalysis. As existing methods to interrogate these interactions have fallen short, we have sought to develop new tools to aid their study. Here we describe the design, synthesis, and application of pantetheinamides that can cross-link ACPs with catalytic β-hydroxy-ACP dehydratase (DH) domains by means of a 3-alkynyl sulfone warhead. We demonstrate this process by application to the Escherichia coli fatty acid synthase and apply it to probe protein-protein interactions with noncognate carrier proteins. Finally, we use solution-phase protein NMR spectroscopy to demonstrate that sulfonyl 3-alkynyl pantetheinamide is fully sequestered by the ACP, indicating that the crypto-ACP closely mimics the natural DH substrate. This cross-linking technology offers immediate potential to lock these biosynthetic enzymes in their native binding states by providing access to mechanistically cross-linked enzyme complexes, presenting a solution to ongoing structural challenges.

Mechanism-based crosslinking as a gauge for functional interaction of modular synthases

Protein-protein interactions between domains within fatty acid and polyketide synthases are critical to catalysis, but their contributions remain incompletely characterized. A practical, quantitative system for establishing functional interactions between modifying enzymes and the acyl carrier protein that tethers the nascent polymer would offer a valuable tool for understanding and engineering these enzyme systems. Mechanism-based crosslinking of modular domains offers a potential diagnostic to highlight selective interactions between modular pairs. Here kinetic activity analysis and isothermal titration calorimetry are shown to correlate the efficiency of a ketosynthase-carrier protein crosslinking method to the binding affinity and transacylase activity that occurs in ketosynthase chain elongation.

A mechanism-based cross-linker for the identification of kinase-substrate pairs.

The reversible phosphorylation of proteins is one of the most important mechanisms for the regulation of signal transduction cascades. Recently, there has been substantial progress made in the identification of new phosphoproteins and phosphorylation sites. Unfortunately, there are very few methods available that allow this information to be used to identify the upstream kinase responsible for the phosphorylation event. Herein, we describe a new method that allows the cross-linking of a substrate of interest to its upstream kinase. This method relies upon a novel, mechanism-based cross-linker and the replacement of the phosphorylated residue with a cysteine residue. The application of this method to a number of kinase-peptide substrate pairs is described.

Sequence-specific and mechanism-based crosslinking of Dcm DNA cytosine-C5 methyltransferase of E. coli K-12 to synthetic oligonucleotides containing 5-fluoro-2'-deoxycytidine.

The product of the dcm gene is the only DNA cytosine-C5 methyltransferase of Escherichia coli K-12; it catalyses transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl methionine (SAM) to the C-5 position of the inner cytosine residue of the cognate sequence CCA/TGG. Sequence-specific, covalent crosslinking of the enzyme to synthetic oligonucleotides containing 5-fluoro-2'-deoxycytidine is demonstrated. This reaction is abolished if serine replaces the cysteine at residue #177 of the enzyme. These results lend strong support to a catalytic mechanism in which an enzyme sulfhydryl group undergoes Michael addition to the C5-C6 double bond, thus activating position C-5 of the substrate DNA cytosine residue for electrophilic attack by the methyl donor SAM. The enzyme is capable of self-methylation in a DNA-independent reaction requiring SAM and the presence of cysteine at position #177.